~$900 college laptop / light video editing (looking at Lenovo ThinkPad T580 vs Legion Y530)

Valid Form
  • Total budget and country of purchase: ~$900 USA

  • Do you prefer a 2 in 1 form factor, good battery life or best specifications for the money? Pick or include any that apply. Prioritizing best specs, decent battery life. In that order.

  • How important is weight and thinness to you? mildly. Over 5lbs and/or thicker than 1 inch might be pushing it for carrying a laptop around a campus daily.

  • Which OS do you require? Windows, Mac, Chrome OS, Linux. Windows.

  • Do you have a preferred screen size? If indifferent, put N/A. 15.6". Open to a smaller 14" thinkpad, but not larger.

  • Are you doing any CAD/video editing/photo editing/gaming? List which programs/games you desire to run. Video editing (mostly 1080p) vlogs. Little to no gaming or CAD.

  • If you're gaming, do you have certain games you want to play? At what settings and FPS do you want? N/A

  • Any specific requirements such as good keyboard, reliable build quality, touch-screen, finger-print reader, optical drive or good input devices (keyboard/touchpad)? Out of this list, prioritizing good build quality (hold up well over 4+ years) and keyboard. No disk drive or touch screen.

  • Leave any finishing thoughts here that you may feel are necessary and beneficial to the discussion.

I've narrowed laptop choices down to two around the same price point (<$900) and want to pick the best for college and basic short video editing.

For roughly the same price:

Legion y530Thinkpad T480
i7-8750H 6 core Processor (2.20GHz, up to 4.10GHz with Turbo Boost, 9MB Cache)i5-8250U Processor (1.60GHz, up to 3.40GHz with Turbo Boost, 6MB Cache)
8GB DDR4 2666MHz4 GB DDR4 2400MHz
NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1050 4GBIntegrated Intel® UHD Graphics 620
1TB Hard Disk Drive, 7200rpm500 GB Hard Disk Drive, 7200rpm, SATA3, 2.5"
15.6" screen14" screen

It seems like I get significantly better specs for a same price y series, is reason to go with a thinkpad beyond its renowned durability?

Posted Aug 13, 2018, 4:42 PM UTC

27
starchaserroAffiliate Links | noteb.com•

Hi,

If you're going to use it for video editing - I'd go for the six-core CPU - check this out: Lenovo Ideapad Legion Y530 vs Lenovo Thinkpad T480 these are 2 different laptops. Indeed the thinkpad is a reliable laptop, and if you don't game there's no need for a dedicated GPU - but that six-core CPU is going to be such a great tool for video editing. It's a tough choice.

Here are other options for you: noteb search went for quad-core CPU with TDP over 25W - should exclude any "u" CPU from the list - you need at least a HQ or H for video editing (you can do with a U cpu but if you can go for a better CPU why not?)

You can see and change the search parameters using the "Refine results" button in the upper-left part of the search results page. You can also click on the laptops for more information.

2
shopineerMade Shopineer•

I would maybe prefer something with a dGPU if this is for video editing. Also, I would try to get an SSD in this price range if at all possible.

What about the Acer Swift 3?

  • 8th Generation Intel Core i5-8250U Processor (Up to 3.4GHz)
  • 15.6"
  • 1920 x 1080
  • 8 GB RAM
  • 256 GB SSD
  • NVIDIA GeForce MX150 with 2 GB of dedicated GDDR5 VRAM
  • Windows 10 Home
  • 10 hours battery life
  • 4.63 lbs.

It also has good build quality (aluminum case), a backlit keyboard and an IPS screen for wider viewing angles.

This latest gen quad core CPU / MX150 GPU should be useful for video editing and multitasking.

Alternatively, there is also the ASUS FX504GE with an even faster CPU and SSD + HDD if you prefer that.

For more options you can check this list of gaming laptops. Even if you won't be gaming there are a few laptops with similar specs there.

2
mavagam99•

I recently purchased that exact Swift 3 with the MX150 and i5-8250U, but unfortunately, I had to take it back. It was a perfect device in every way except one major flaw - it didn't go to sleep. Sleep mode would only turn off the screen but the activity light and fans were still on. I thought I got a defective unit, so I exchanged it for another one but the same problem persisted. Most likely some software issue that could be fixed in the future though.

2
meat_meat•

Could also check out the Dell Inspiron 7577: https://www.notebookcheck.net/Dell-Inspiron-15-7000-7577-i5-7300HQ-GTX-1060-Max-Q-Laptop-Review.264134.0.html

That configuration can be found for as low as $750-800 on sale, $850 is the typical asking price these days.

Just ordered one so I can't say how it is in person, but it's been well reviewed and packs a GTX 6GB 1060 Max-Q when most other $850-900 laptops feature a 1050 or 1050ti. Also has 6-7 hour battery life which is better than its gaming peers.

Biggest issue might be weight, it has a pretty nondescript chassis design (no gaudy "gamer" crap) but weighs about 5.7 lbs.

2
ballervilleOP•

Thanks for this, I'll check out similar models. I think since the primary intensive use of the laptop will be video editing I should prioritize the CPU over the GPU.

1
meat_meat•

Yeah, best CPU you can get is a 7th gen quad core i7, and the IPS panel is a little lackluster so might be worth investing in one of the new 8th gen hexacore CPUs with a good (80-90% sRGB) panel.

2
LonerIM2Affiliate Links | LaptopLegend.com•

If you are open to other options, I would recommend this [ASUS VivoBook] (https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0786TPWBP/?tag=bkadamos_alltest-20) because it comes with everything you need, 8th generation, i7 quad core CPU which is one of the best in the market and great for your usage, 8GB of ram for smooth multitasking, 1TB HDD, good SSD storage of 256GB for faster boot up and loading, 15.6 inch Full HD screen which is a must have for this price range, lightweight, long battery life, backlit keyboard, and it’s within your budget.

If you don't like this option then I would recommend that you check my best gaming and college laptop to compare it with similar options

1