Lenovo ThinkPad T580 vs Lenovo Legion Y530.

Budgeting a laptop ~$900 for college and light video editing (1080p).

For roughly the same price:

Legion y530Thinkpad T480
i7-8750H 6 core Processor (2.20GHz, up to 4.10GHz with Turbo Boost, 9MB Cache)i5-8250U Processor (1.60GHz, up to 3.40GHz with Turbo Boost, 6MB Cache)
8GB DDR4 2666MHz4 GB DDR4 2400MHz
NVIDIA GeForce GTX 1050 4GBIntegrated Intel® UHD Graphics 620
1TB Hard Disk Drive, 7200rpm500 GB Hard Disk Drive, 7200rpm, SATA3, 2.5"
15.6" screen14" screen

It seems like I get significantly better specs for a same price y series. Thinkpad enthusiasts, does anyone have experience with Y-series lenovo laptops? What was your preference and is there any reason to go with a thinkpad beyond its renowned durability and time tested design? Should I care about dedicated graphics that much if its only real use would be for video editing? Open to other models or options

Posted Aug 13, 2018, 4:53 PM UTC

35
FormPlusFunctionX1C5, T430, X201, T41•

These are very different laptops, designed for very different use cases.

You do get more "bang for your buck" with the Legion, but its also less portable, and (assuming) worse battery life due to the discrete graphics and high-powered CPU, not to mention larger screen.

If you plan on carrying this thing with you take the T480 for sure. If you're just using it docked most of the time, and you are careful with your laptop, the legion will be OK. I don't really see the need for a discrete GPU though from your description.

4
ballervilleOP•

You're absolutely right, the dGPU is unnecessary. I'm looking into something that doesn't have one. Thanks for the insight.

1
choob13•

gpu is not uneccesary for video editing

1
dsp_pepsi•

Do not get the Legion for video editing. The CPU can handle it, but the screen is dim and very color inaccurate. The battery life is not suited to student life either.

2
ballervilleOP•

Have you used the Legion? It looks like the T480 uses the same screen specs listed, how would it be different visually?

1
dsp_pepsi•

I can't speak to the T480, but I own the Legion. For gaming and productivity, it's a fantastic laptop. But as I said before, the screen is dim and not very color accurate. At 1080p it's not a good fit for 4K editing either.

Since you don't need a dGPU, spend your money on something with a decently bright and accurate display and better battery life. The Legion is a gaming laptop hiding behind a business chassis.

1