r/chomsky•
bleer95

Gary Johnson is running for senate. We know the bad with him, but let's look at the good his foreign policy might be able to produce.

Discussion

Disclaimer: this is in no way an endorsement of Johnson, his policies are far too pro-business for my liking (indeed, his business and fiscal policies seems very much inline with free-market libertarianism, in addition to more traditional libertarian social theory). Rather, it is highlighting areas which Johnson gets right IMO, and perhaps noticing places where America's progressive democrat left can work with others to get some good out of policy. However, I've looked over his foreign policy and while there's definitely lack of knowledge, it does have some legitimate points to make too.

This is from Wikipedia:

> In his campaign for the Libertarian Party nomination, he stated he opposed foreign wars and pledged to cut the military budget by 43 percent in his first term as president.[131] He would cut the military's overseas bases, uniformed and civilian personnel, research and development, intelligence, and nuclear weapons programs, while maintaining an "invincible defense."[146][147] Johnson opposes U.S. involvement in the War in Afghanistan and opposed the U.S. involvement in the Libyan Civil War.[148] He has stated that he does not believe Iran is a military threat, would use his presidential power to prevent Israel from attacking Iran, and would not follow Israel, or any other ally, into a war that it had initiated.[149] While Johnson views the Islamic threat to the US as overrated, he has been openly advocating for greater diplomacy with China regarding North Korea, which, in his view, "is the biggest threat in the world today," stating "...one of these days, one of their ICBMs is going to work."[150] However, he does support waging war for humanitarian reasons.[151][152][153]

For the American political system, Johnson's foreign policy views don't really conform to the traditional base of the dems and republicans. Unlike a lot of America's politicians, even its' progressive left (which seems largely focused on domestic issues first and foreign issues a distant second), Johnson's reforms to foreign policy are concrete, relatively radical (departure from demonizing Iran, defending Israel, serious cutbacks to the military budget) and more inline with a progressive agenda (though they stem from a very different line of reasoning).

Still, there are, of course, legitimate sources of concern (would Johnson's views change once business interests make their interests in overseas wars more apparent? would he stop American involvement in supporting foreign regimes with human rights abuses should they be profitable? What does he mean by "humanitarian war"?). So I'd like to discuss what we can get out of Johnson and what we should expect from him should he (or more broadly, his ideology) gain more traction with the American population.

Posted Aug 17, 2018, 6:42 PM UTC · edited

213
wageslave92•

He’d probably just mimic Rand, who does have some marginal affect on FP, in the very least bringing to the table POV which otherwise would not be voiced. Its good that the reasonably sane views which they hold are widely aired, but I’ve also noticed that traditionally left ideas which now happen to be associated to the antiestablishment right are being used to discredit a lot of people in a kind of irrational guilt by association. Clearly that’s not any fault of his, but it is something which will be a persistent barrier for some time to come, even while it will have some benefits too. I don’t think he’ll have any major impact.

3
bleer95OP•

> He’d probably just mimic Rand, who does have some marginal affect on FP, in the very least bringing to the table POV which otherwise would not be voiced.

A good comparison now that I think about it. I think Johnson's views are perhaps more extreme than Rand's though (certainly, more willing to confront Israel in a meaningful way). Moreover, I have the sense that Johnson is more likely to stick to his principles on this, as he's less involved with the Republican party machine. Paul, for instance, has shown moments of faltering (he offered a budget ammendment in 2016 calling for a 16% boost in military spending). On a personal level, Rand Paul seems to have a distrust or dislike of most of the Muslim nations in the Middle East (on a cultural level) and expresses support for Israel in word. Johnson doesn't really seem to have that, at least, not as far as I can tell.

http://www.ontheissues.org/2016/Rand_Paul_Foreign_Policy.htm

> Its good that the reasonably sane views which they hold are widely aired, but I’ve also noticed that traditionally left ideas which now happen to be associated to the antiestablishment right are being used to discredit a lot of people in a kind of irrational guilt by association. Clearly that’s not any fault of his, but it is something which will be a persistent barrier for some time to come, even while it will have some benefits too.

That's another good point, but I will counter argue that the American progressive left is really more the American domestically progressive left. Certainly, Johnsons proposal of a 43% military budget cut is more concrete and to my liking than nice sounding rhetoric by the more progressive left like Ocasio-Cortez about "spending money on bombs and not hospitals" which hasn't translated into much on the ground. Johnson doesn't seem to have a particular care about Israel's policy towards the Palestinians and the Middle East region generally, but at the same time, I'd prefer a man who makes it clear he won't back Israeli warmongering (even if it's just over budgetary reasoning) than somebody who puts out tepid condemnations about human rights abuses in Palestine like Sanders. It's weird to say, but he might be hte guy to either 1. make a bridge at the lawmaking level between progressive dems and more deficit/debt minded republicans or 2. (and this is unlikely), the guy to actually show up the progressive dems on foreign policy and force their anti-war positions further left. Certainly, it hurts a socialists credibility if their constituency criticizes them for being further right than a guy who believes near-unquestioningly in free market economics. It's possible that that would simply disillusion a lot of America's burgeoning left, but it could also have hte effect of putting some heat on the American left's politicians who thinks they can be progressive by just focusing on issues of healthcare and minimum wage (and Johnson actually does have some social views which are relatively progressive, such as pardoning non-violent drug offenders, being pro-abortion, being pro-gay marriage, ending the war on drugs etc...). Ultimately, people in Yemen would rather see a guy who says "fuck it, we're not bombing Sanaa anymore, it doesn't make fiscal sense" than a socialist who says "well, I think let's cut the bombing in Yemen costs from $300 million to $150 million and spend the rest on hospitals!" (numbers obviously not to scale).

>I don’t think he’ll have any major impact.

You're probably right on the senatorial level. he's only one man (assuming he wins the seat to begin with), but at the same time, the 2016 election saw Johnson do the best a third party has since 96. He caught a wave of voters. Originally I thought it was jsut the "I'm just a republican but I don't like that Trump is overtly racist" group, but now I'm starting to have second thoughts. Even if Johnson is goofy (and that seems to be part of his charm, as well as part of the reason many don't like him), he tapped into a part of the population which is free-market libertarian (like my dad). That's not something to glorify in and of itself, but if that sort of politician starts making inroads into congress and the senate, it could have serious effects on America's foreign policy, some of which might be negative, but some of which might also be good, and unlike most of the establishment Rs and Ds (and even soem of the more "maverick" members of both parties), he might be genuine in his approach.

I probably wasn't clear enough on this, but this is less about Johnson (though he is the face of American free-market libertarianism) but more about what his political following could entail, particularly as a lot of it is free of the party machinery of the Republicans and Democrats.

1
wageslave92•

Perhaps. Though it’s difficult to put much trust into the beliefs candidates espouse on the campaign trail.

I think the main difference between progressives and libertarians on the issue of militarism and adventurism is principle/practical. This is a generalization, but it appears most libertarians are opposed to these issues on practical grounds, where as most progressives take a principled stance. The whole mistake/immoral thing.

Idk, I feel like token libertarians are good for the reasons we’ve said, but as we also hinted, they’re pretty destructive as well. I have no idea if they’ll emerge as a prominent alternative for people on the right, though my suspicions suggest that they won’t, the extreme popular right has entrenched itself into the Republican Party, and once they discover the parties betrayed them they’ll probably shift somewhere far too extreme for Libertarian candidates.

2
bleer95OP•

> Perhaps. Though it’s difficult to put much trust into the beliefs candidates espouse on the campaign trail.

That's true, though, I will say, Johnson took some unusually bold risks in his foreign policy platform that indicate to me that he might be the genuine article. It would have paid better to just pay lip service to Israel (as well as several other allies) or overall just avoid the topic, but he said, very straightforwardly, that they wouldn't receive his backing. We've seen some of his free-market libertarian ilk talk the talk, but I have the sense (and this is totally subjective TBH), that Johnson will walk the walk.

> I think the main difference between progressives and libertarians on the issue of militarism and adventurism is principle/practical. This is a generalization, but it appears most libertarians are opposed to these issues on practical grounds, where as most progressives take a principled stance. The whole mistake/immoral thing.

Completely agreed. I don't see Johnson making any ideological grandstands (though I don't think he has any of the personal bigotries or fetishes that many GOP members do). Still, if this movement comes about, it could provide a common alliance for the progressive left to work with on foreign policy. It's better to have an end to the war on Yemen, even if it's because 50% of the reasoning is humanitarian and 50% for fiscal reasons than to have an ideologically uniform reasoning but only 25% of the vote needed for it. Hell, it might even be something with which America's progressive population can push America's progressive politicians. It'd be embarrassing for Bernie or Warren or Ocasio-Cortez to be on stage debating Johnson on foreign policy and for them to be booed by their own support base because they can't stand up to Israel while Johnson just says "fuck 'em, not our problem." Like I said, America's progressive left is, at this point, largely the American domestic progressive left, with slightly less imperialist features. Regardless of the reasoning or logic, that would be the kind of discussion that could push a progressive foreign policy out of the progressive left, at least in a practical sense. Indeed, it makes sense to support smart policy making even if it comes with faulty logic or from politicians we don't like (IE: I think Trump is trash, but his move on Pakistan was right IMO).

> Idk, I feel like token libertarians are good for the reasons we’ve said, but as we also hinted, they’re pretty destructive as well. I have no idea if they’ll emerge as a prominent alternative for people on the right, though my suspicions suggest that they won’t, the extreme popular right has entrenched itself into the Republican Party, and once they discover the parties betrayed them they’ll probably shift somewhere far too extreme for Libertarian candidates.

I agree that a libertarian party could be destructive (certailny they'd be a disaster for economic and labor issues), Johnson isn't exactly super informed and his party needs serious reform before it becomes a viable option to the public. Still, if Johnson becomes the head of a meaningful free market libertarian movement which shows repeated success in congress, the senate and various other significant political positions, we could see the more center right parts of the population (what we call fiscally conservative, socially liberal) slowly abandon the GOP for libertarian upstarts. If nothing else, this could divide the republican party. They're a party which stick together because they like to win, but they're also a party with significant internal divisions, and I think a lot of them are disillusioned with Trump after the Syria missile strikes. If libertarians can show that they can win and make an impact, we could see the GOP slowly start to lose its party discipline. This isn't a next two years kind of thing, but over the next decade or two, it could see the division of the two parties into dems, progressives, libertarians, and hardcore republicans. That would make for some uncomfortable alliances (indeed, it would be tough for labor issues to even come to the table without a significant progressive contingent), but it could also provide fertile ground for a more diverse foreign policy discussion (I mean, let's be real, dem and republican positions on states like Ukraine and Israel barely differ, one says "we need to defend Israel because it's a democracy" while the other says "we need to defend Israel because it's surrounded by savage Muslims"). The progressive and libertarian parties feeling less tied down to traditional republican and democrat neoliberal/neoconservative party ideology, we could see some change.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
Stealin_Yer_Valor•

he isn't even good on foreign policy that dickhead wanted to continue the Cuba embargo.

1
bleer95OP•

No he doesn't. At least, not presently, IDK about the past.

http://www.ontheissues.org/2016/gary_johnson_foreign_policy.htm

1
Stealin_Yer_Valor•

Oh word thats good, I thought he did but maybe im thinking of 2012. hes still phenomenally bad on economic issues tho.

2
bleer95OP•

You might be thinking of somebody entirely different. I can't find anything on his cuba position other than what I posted. Hell, he's opposed to Venezuela regime change too.

> hes still phenomenally bad on economic issues tho.

True. But this is about his foreign policy. It's not an endorsement, it's an analysis of where American progressives can work with American free market libertarians on foreign policy issues, or in some cases, where they can learn from free market libertarians.

1
nonviolently2•

Why vote for Johnson when the sun’s going to swallow the earth eventually anyway?

1
bleer95OP•

never said vote for him

1
vnny•

no

0
bleer95OP•

After reading that brief breakdown of Johnson's views, you don't think there's anything positive to be said about his foreign policy views whatsoever?

If you think he'll compromise them or that he's not being honest, that's one thing, but it seems kind of pointless to just say "no" when this man is probably more anti-war than any other significant candidate in 2016 except for Stein.

1