Necrium Rogue: (Rank 3 to Legend) Discussion of Strengths and Weaknesses

Discussion

Edit/Update 2: I just wanted to say thank you for supporting this deck. I loaded up my deck tracker today to find that my list is now recognised on HSReplay, which seems insane to me. Thank you for trying out the list. Whats more though is that with 530 games recorded (admittedly low) the deck records the highest winrate out of all Deathrattle Rogues on HSReplay at 59.4%.

This also gives the benefit of letting us now see the winrate and mulligan percentages of each individual card.

I have added a link to the list on HSReplay here:

https://hsreplay.net/decks/e6hfMjNNx81Ufy2J36Zh0d/#tab=overview

Proof of my 73% winrate, legend and decklist https://imgur.com/a/91tedQf

First of all I don't want to make any claims over this being my decklist alone. This is heavily inspired by other Deathrattle Rogue lists out there, however, it includes a few tech choices. I am making this post to open a discussion on these choices and the Archetype's strengths and weaknesses as a whole.

I reached Legend with a Winrate of 73% over 33 games from Rank 3.

I started the season out playing Spell Hunter to Rank 3 and from there Deathrattle Hunter to Rank 2. This was when I hit a losing streak of nine straight games. This obviously tilted me and so I decided my target of Legend for the month was over. (I am not a pro-player by any means, this is only the third time I have hit Legend). Owing to this, I started experimenting with a few decks and eventually landed back on Necrium (Deathrattle) Rogue and found myself back in contention for Legend.

This list is similar to other builds with a few tech options. Personally I prefer the lists incorporating Cavern Shinyfinder over Keleseth and I will talk about this later.

Card Choices

Sonya Shadowdancer This card has been the MVP of many games. Sonya is a value generating machine that can win games by herself. I won a few games simply from the opponent conceding to Sonya played into Blightnozzle Crawler, which can become a great single target removal option or in some cases an entire board clear. As well as this, playing her and then killing off Devilsaur Egg or Mechanical Whelp can create insane game winning value against slower decks. After trying out Sonya I do consider her a core card for the deck but do believe the deck can be further improved to make better use of Sonya. I can't take credit for the idea of using her however, as this tech option was inspired by the list u/aspoic posted earlier.

Zilliax I included Zilliax after initially running x2 copies of Eviscerate. This was because I found the deck to have enough reach without Eviscerate and that stalling and healing against aggro decks was my major concern. Zilliax was most often played as a standalone minion in my climb to Legend but on some occasions the Magnetic ability allowed me to push for lethal, making Zilliax one of the most versatile cards in the deck.

Strengths and Weaknesses

I found the main strength of this deck to be its ability to snowball out of control and produce obscenely sticky boards for the opponent to clear. I believe this is fairly evident from the statistics posted above with Mage, Warrior and Druid being some of the best match ups. The inclusion of Mossy Horror also assists in Control match ups as it allowed me to push damage through Giggling Inventors and deal with Doomsayers efficiently. Though I don't hink its any surprise by now that Mossy Horror is currently an extremely effective card.

However, the main weakness, from my experience, with the deck is trying to take back the board if it is lost. The vast majority of my losses were to decks that were able to stick minions faster than myself. This list simply doesn't have strong enough answers to early board floods and the deathrattle minions can be prepared for by the opponent and removed before you are able to generate any form of value from them. This is my major concern with the deck and I would like to know if anyone else has thought the same thing or had differing views.

Going back to why I prefer the builds that run Cavern Shinyfinder over Keleseth, this is relating to the previous issue. Necrium Blade, to me feels like the be all and end all of this decks early game plan. If you draw Eggs and Blightnozzle's but you can not trigger their deathrattles, they simply become under par minions which get steamrolled by Zoo style decks. Cavern Shinyfinder allows for on curve tutoring of the key component of the deck and Necrium Blade into Blightnozzle Crawler has been the only way I have pushed Zoo Warlock off the board. Again I would like to know if anyone disagrees and believes Keleseth is the better option and why.

Overall, the deck carried me to Legend incredibly successfully and definitely has room for improvement. If the meta starts to favour slower decks, I think this Archetype has staying power. However, if faster decks begin to dominate then I think this Archetype will most likely fall into obscurity.

Deck Code:

Nerium Rogue

Class: Rogue

Format: Standard

Year of the Raven

2x (0) Backstab

2x (1) Cold Blood

2x (1) Fire Fly

2x (2) Cavern Shinyfinder

2x (2) Sap

2x (3) Devilsaur Egg

2x (3) Necrium Blade

1x (3) Sonya Shadowdancer

2x (4) Blightnozzle Crawler

2x (4) Elven Minstrel

2x (5) Carnivorous Cube

2x (5) Giggling Inventor

1x (5) Leeroy Jenkins

2x (5) Necrium Vial

1x (5) Zilliax

2x (6) Mechanical Whelp

1x (6) Mossy Horror

AAECAYO6AgSvBM/hAsvsAqCAAw20AYwCzQOrwgLrwgLl0QKL4QLb4wK09gLi+ALe+gLs/ALRgQMA

To use this deck, copy it to your clipboard and create a new deck in Hearthstone

I apologise if this turns out to be awfully formatted. I have not done any posts like this before to reddit. This is a repost as I previously posted this without realising I had gone against the rules of titling my post. I believe we are still within the 3 week period of Boomsday release so the amount of games played should be sufficient for discussion. Thank you to those who helped me sort this out. Edit: Added winrate and games in write up.

Posted Aug 17, 2018, 10:18 PM UTC · edited

17072
Pikachu-22•

I really like mossy horror especially against giggling inventor and having synergy with your deathrattles

45
DocRedNYC35•

Interesting that you cut Vilespine

44
sqrlaway•

My guess is redundancy with Blightnozzle and the clumsiness of comboing it out

28
My_Big_Mouth•

Have you tried the Necrium/Egg/Cube package in an odd rogue deck? Working well for me at the moment with a 68% 19-9 winrate from rank 5.

19
_Click_OP•

Sounds like an interesting idea. My first thought is that the dagger upgrade kind of goes against using Necrium Blade but I may be wrong, it appears to be working for you.

26
My_Big_Mouth•

The 2/2 weapon helps a lot vs Zoo which is mainly why I think the deck is doing well. I'm 6-0 vs Warlock with 4 of them Zoo.

7
BigDaddyXV•

I kinda had that idea as well but I just didn't try it. What 3 and 5 drops do you run

6
My_Big_Mouth•

1x (3) Blink Fox

2x (3) Devilsaur Egg

1x (3) Edwin VanCleef

2x (3) Hench-Clan Thug

1x (3) Ironbeak Owl

2x (3) Necrium Blade

2x (3) SI:7 Agent

2x (3) Vicious Fledgling

2x (5) Carnivorous Cube

2x (5) Giggling Inventor

1x (5) Leeroy Jenkins

2x (5) Vilespine Slayer

1x (5) Zilliax

Code: AAECAaIHBqICsgKvBJ74Asf4AqCAAwyMAssD1AXdCIHCAp/CAqvCAuvCAovhAqbvAuL4At76AgA=

6
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
GingrichYurr•

The person asked specifically for 3 and 5 drops.

4
mooshoorama•

I'm kinda doing the same thing. I feel like the 2/2 dagger helps better early game, then the usual shenanigans. Does your list include a Sonya as well or would that be better suited to a non-odd list? Thanks!

4
My_Big_Mouth•

I don't use sonya in mine

2x (1) Cold Blood

2x (1) Deadly Poison

2x (1) Fire Fly

2x (1) Southsea Deckhand

1x (3) Blink Fox

2x (3) Devilsaur Egg

1x (3) Edwin VanCleef

2x (3) Hench-Clan Thug

1x (3) Ironbeak Owl

2x (3) Necrium Blade

2x (3) SI:7 Agent

2x (3) Vicious Fledgling

2x (5) Carnivorous Cube

2x (5) Giggling Inventor

1x (5) Leeroy Jenkins

2x (5) Vilespine Slayer

1x (5) Zilliax

1x (9) Baku the Mooneater

AAECAaIHBqICsgKvBJ74Asf4AqCAAwyMAssD1AXdCIHCAp/CAqvCAuvCAovhAqbvAuL4At76AgA=

4
deck-code-bot•

Format: Standard (Raven)

Class: Rogue (Valeera Sanguinar)

ManaCard NameQtyLinks
1Cold Blood2HP, Wiki, HSR
1Deadly Poison2HP, Wiki, HSR
1Fire Fly2HP, Wiki, HSR
1Southsea Deckhand2HP, Wiki, HSR
3Blink Fox1HP, Wiki, HSR
3Devilsaur Egg2HP, Wiki, HSR
3Edwin VanCleef1HP, Wiki, HSR
3Hench-Clan Thug2HP, Wiki, HSR
3Ironbeak Owl1HP, Wiki, HSR
3Necrium Blade2HP, Wiki, HSR
3SI:7 Agent2HP, Wiki, HSR
3Vicious Fledgling2HP, Wiki, HSR
5Carnivorous Cube2HP, Wiki, HSR
5Giggling Inventor2HP, Wiki, HSR
5Leeroy Jenkins1HP, Wiki, HSR
5Vilespine Slayer2HP, Wiki, HSR
5Zilliax1HP, Wiki, HSR
9Baku the Mooneater1HP, Wiki, HSR

Total Dust: 9400

Deck Code: AAECAaIHBqICsgKvBJ74Asf4AqCAAwyMAssD1AXdCIHCAp/CAqvCAuvCAovhAqbvAuL4At76AgA=


^I ^am ^a ^bot. ^Comment/PM ^with ^a ^deck ^code ^and ^I'll ^decode ^it. ^If ^you ^don't ^want ^me ^to ^reply ^to ^you, ^include ^"###" ^anywhere ^in ^your ^message. ^About.

3
realcoolsid123•

Just tried this list, have to say it feels pretty good! Most of the time I was using necrium blade for controlling the board, but a few times I was able to proc deathrattles too so that was a definite match winning bonus.

Besides, using coldblood on egg means I could have a massive tempo swing with 4 mana. Definitely liking the feel.

I included a Sonya and Myra's unstable element in my list instead of the fledglings since most of the time they're a vanilla 3-3 anyway with so many decks shutting them down early.

Idea is pretty cool, don't think it loses much tempo compared to the pure aggro list, given that a 3 attack blade is really good at controlling the board with so many minions at 3 health (si7, fledglings, blinkfox). Will have to play a few more matches to know for certain though.

3
GFischerUY•

How is Myra's working? I'm playing a similar list, cut a blade for Necrium Vial, it's disgusting.

1
Frostmage82•

Could use more 1 drops imo. Owl, Edwin and Fledgling are all expendable to add Dire Mole and maybe Void Ripper since it's great against opposing taunts and also pops your eggs.

The list looks pretty sweet though.

2
GrayHyena•

Hi. I really like this deck list. So, how confident are you in the removal of preparation and eviscerate? I found prep at least to be lackluster myself. I've been playing my own version of this at high Legend, where I see mostly Druids warlocks and Rogues of all variants. Are there any changes that you would make if that was all you saw, most of the time?

12
_Click_OP•

As I said, I found the deck to have enough reach without Eviscerate. The fact that there are successful Keleseth builds I think adds to this other than just my own experiences.

Without Eviscerate the only real use for Prep is on Necrium Vial which I have never found myself wanting to discount. I guess Sprint may be a decent inclusion if you like the preps but I don't feel the deck lacks card draw for what it trys to achieve.

6
metsfan1025•

I’d been playing Sonya and I gotta say while she can be a little clunky at times, she can also cause some absolute shenanigans. Especially if your opponent leaves a cube on board since you can get a 1 mana cube and copy of whatever you cube afterwards.

8
ToxicAdamm•

It's hilarious when you have DK Valeera up and start cubing cubes. Your opponent loses track of which cube contains minions. It's like a shell game.

7
Kaserbeam•

If you just hover over the cube it tells you whats inside it where it usually lists buffs and things like that.

15
trafficante•

I’m experimenting with a slow control mech deathrattle deck that grinds out wins with pogos and holy moly is Sonya insane when comboed with the 1 mana rush poisonous ooze. Those lil oozes are so good from hand (especially after playing the DK) that I’m considering dropping Vilespine.

2
mooshoorama•

Can you post a link for mobile please?

6
_Click_OP•

AAECAYO6AgSvBM/hAsvsAqCAAw20AYwCzQOrwgLrwgLl0QKL4QLb4wK09gLi+ALe+gLs/ALRgQMA

11
deck-code-bot•

Format: Standard (Raven)

Class: Rogue (Maiev Shadowsong)

ManaCard NameQtyLinks
0Backstab2HP, Wiki, HSR
1Cold Blood2HP, Wiki, HSR
1Fire Fly2HP, Wiki, HSR
2Cavern Shinyfinder2HP, Wiki, HSR
2Sap2HP, Wiki, HSR
3Devilsaur Egg2HP, Wiki, HSR
3Necrium Blade2HP, Wiki, HSR
3Sonya Shadowdancer1HP, Wiki, HSR
4Blightnozzle Crawler2HP, Wiki, HSR
4Elven Minstrel2HP, Wiki, HSR
5Carnivorous Cube2HP, Wiki, HSR
5Giggling Inventor2HP, Wiki, HSR
5Leeroy Jenkins1HP, Wiki, HSR
5Necrium Vial2HP, Wiki, HSR
5Zilliax1HP, Wiki, HSR
6Mechanical Whelp2HP, Wiki, HSR
6Mossy Horror1HP, Wiki, HSR

Total Dust: 8240

Deck Code: AAECAYO6AgSvBM/hAsvsAqCAAw20AYwCzQOrwgLrwgLl0QKL4QLb4wK09gLi+ALe+gLs/ALRgQMA


^I ^am ^a ^bot. ^Comment/PM ^with ^a ^deck ^code ^and ^I'll ^decode ^it. ^If ^you ^don't ^want ^me ^to ^reply ^to ^you, ^include ^"###" ^anywhere ^in ^your ^message. ^About.

3
_Click_OP•

Not sure how to do this, do I just paste the deck code as a comment?

2
SquiggleSauce•

Yuup

2
mooshoorama•

Yes please. On mobile we can't highlight certain portions but only the comments themselves.

2
SquiggleSauce•

It's a tough life

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
KreaHS•

This looks fun, I'll have to try it. I've been playing Big Rogue instead, and while it's good vs Control, it struggles v aggro.

Can't say I hate doing this though: https://i.imgur.com/Gc9fidp.jpg

https://i.imgur.com/lXfvhoy.jpg

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/179571246378254337/480131265291354123/unknown.png

https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/179571246378254337/480056239657713664/unknown.png

How do you fair vs more common aggro decks?

5
_Click_OP•

Aggro is tough. I say towards the end that if more Aggressive decks form the meta this archetype may be pushed out. However, it definitely isn't an unwinnable match up, Blightnozzle Crawler is a hell of a card. Which is funny to me as I rated it one of the worst cards of the set during pre-release. I think my winrate was probably inflated by an abundance of slower hunter and mage decks on EU.

3
leoben1987•

I'm interested in playing this deck and I'd love to hear more about it. What are its match ups like? Does it pack enough punch to compete with other late-game decks?

1
BigDaddyXV•

How do you usually approach the druid matchup?? Do you still go kinda wide on board or do you keep about 2-3 minions.

3
_Click_OP•

Honestly Druids have been a good match up. Obviously I have limited data but the Malygos and Togwaggle builds simply cant deal with sticky deathrattle minions. I prefer to go taller, usually with Whelps but going wide is definitely good if you have Mossy Horror or other ways to deal with Spreading Plague. On the other hand, Token Druid was a bad match up during my climb as if they commit to the board early its hard to push them off with this list.

2
wisdomattend•

Looks nice. Any chance of a mulligan guide?

3
_Click_OP•

Not sure I have enough play experience to really make a mulligan guide but I can give my initial opinions.

Against aggressive decks like Zoo Warlock I want Fire Fly, Necrium Blade and Blightnozzle Crawler. Obviously backstab aswell. I usually throw eggs back into my deck unless my hand is already pretty good as they can usually be dealt with. Go for the board as quickly and recklessly as possible, go for tempo over value, swing with blade even without a deathrattle on board if need be. I often found when going second to play Fire Fly and coin Flame Elemental on turn one just to get board presence.

Against slower decks Id say you're pretty favoured (warrior, mage, some warlocks). Look for early deathrattle minions like egg and Necrium Blade. Fire Fly and Backstab can be thrown against decks that are passive in the early game. Go for value and watch out for weapon removal as this can ruin your day. Sometimes I prefer playing slower, Egg on three then Necrium Blade after to ensure there is always a target even if they break your weapon.

Hope this helps.

2
Fogfish420•

I really want to craft this deck as it looks like a ton of fun tbh,but I don't have a whole bunch of stuff so rip.

2
SquiggleSauce•

Every deck loses its luster after a few games. Just play whatever you have, the grass is always greener on the other side.

20
_Click_OP•

Definitely, the deck is fun but please don't craft it if you are low on dust. The meta isn't settled at all and this list may turn out to be dreadful eventually if aggro takes over.

6
inkfluence•

The grass is greener on the side you water.

1
techno_babble_•

I'm having a lot of fun with this deck - thanks. I especially like the infinite poisonous rush 1/1s with Sonya!

2
_Click_OP•

Thats the best complement for me, great to hear its fun for you.

2
techno_babble_•

I've tried quite a few versions of deathrattle rogue, and so far this one is working the best. I'm still getting used to the play style, and not always sure when to tempo vs. trying to get value from the deathrattles etc. Do you stream?

1
_Click_OP•

No I'm not a streamer or pro-player. Nor do I have any intention to be. I replied to a previous comment with a few mulligan tips and basics which shouldn't be to hard to find.

1
mightbulb•

First of all thank you for the list and great writeup. I played a similar list earlier to rank 2 and now have been playing your list to climb the lower legend ranks on EU with reasonable success.

Ive heard a lot of people say that this deck is just a strictly worse version of DR Hunter, but I disagree with that heavily. I think the first thing that differs from Hunter is the deck's ability to create in one or two turns a board state that threatens lethal hard and is almost impossible to clear. I haven't had such explosive turns with Hunter at least.

Another thing that surprised is me is the versatility of the deck. It has the longevity to go far past turn 10 but can also dish out serious early pressure when needed. Especially with the Giggling stall I've stolen wins with Vial or Cube shenanigans in games I thought were surely lost. Add Sonya to the mix with crawler boardclears and such, and I believe this deck definitely should be taken seriously.

For the list... I haven't missed vilespine slayers or eviscerates, if i can connect to face it's usually more than enough. And to connect to face I've also played a second copy of Mossy Horror in Druid heavy times. It's greedy but not expected and also gives felixibility to use one for popping eggs when you end up with too many.

Tl;Dr: Enjoying the deck, feel like it's underestimated

2
Rednelol•

Hey ! First of all thanks a lot for the guide and the work put into it. I have to say I was very enthusiastic about it and after trying the deck (and some variations) for some time I'm quite perplex.

I found the deck to be extremely inconsistent, often finding myself with absolutely horrendous hands, and with the very limited card draw it seems almost impossible to either recover or refill if needed. Sure sometimes you'll generate obscene boards by turn 5 and win the game from there, but it's far from being regular in my experience.

I must be doing something wrong considering I can barely maintain a positive winrate.

How do you approach most games ? Wait for value turns even if it means not playing anything for a few turns sometime? Or play vanilla egg / mechs with no activator and hope for the best ? I'm obviously not talking about the games where stars align and everything works, as it is not the majority in my experience.

Thanks a lot !

2
_Click_OP•

Hi, interesting points here. Difficult to say how I approach games, it really depends on the match ups. Generally I seem to play the deck somewhat different to other people, though this clearly worked for me and I would recommend others to try. I play the deck more aggressively, especially against board orientated decks. As you said this deck struggles to recover and because of this I'd favour generating minions quickly (fire fly coin flame elemental turn 1) for instance. Be liberal with your deathrattle triggers.

Against slower decks you have to manage your resources. Make sure the deathrattle you want to trigger will, do not leave it to chance. Also dont over commit your board. I can't emphasise this enough. Like you said the deck has a small draw shell though this should not really be a problem if resources are managed correctly. Over commiting leads to board wipes and Spreading Plagues. Mossy Horror isn't always the best here. If you can clear otherwise and fear a second plague keep hold of him.

One strong deathrattle (cube or whelp) can be more than enough late game pressure with triggers.

Hope this helps.

1
TheJackFroster•

So what is the big damage combo here? Just Leeroy, Cube hit with Necrium Blade 2nd time? Surely having preps and shadowsteps to get a 3 mana cube or leeroy with a 2 mana vial to do Leeroy, Cube, Prep, Necrium Vial 2nd Necrium Blade hit would let this deck have much better time vs high armour druids.

1
_Click_OP•

Druid has been a strong match up due to repetitive damage from sticky boards they cannot clear. Also not once have I actually used the cube leeroy combo. To me it seems to dreamy and best case scenario. I prefer to play more aggressive with this deck and just use leeroy as a six-ten damage card with cold blood. But this may just be my own playstyle.

4
Hyogita•

starting your deck from rank 25, rank 20 now, so far so good.

1
Jordandavis7•

Thanks for posting your list. I’ve been experimenting with a similar list this season and right now I am sort of stuck at rank 3... been racking my head with what changes to make. I recently cut keleseth and added the shiny finders and saps and believe the deck performs much better this way. I’m interested in your variant, with Sonya, a 2nd Blightnozzle and giggling inventors over vilesplines

Also, I’ve been experimenting with a single prep, and it’s created some explosive turns for sure, but maybe it’s unnecessary

1
tzeriel•

Mechanical Whelp has been the most underperforming, underwhelming card for me in both the Rogue and Hunter decks.

I’m curious why people keep trying Rattle Rogue when Rattle Hunter seems to outperform it in literally every way.

1†
Erythais•

Because they like the deck and not everyone is interested in playing a T1 FOTM deck?

4
Frostmage82•

Mechanical Whelp is the primary reason Hunter has a winning matchup against the heavier control decks in the meta. Having played a lot with and lot against DR Hunter, I consider Whelp to be one of the best cards in the deck.

1
tzeriel•

Disagree. Hunter does better because it can apply pressure through taunts and has better deathrattle tools. Play Dead is >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 2 deathrattlee for 5

-1
Frostmage82•

Disagree. Hunter does better because it can apply pressure through taunts and has better deathrattle tools. Play Dead is >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> 2 deathrattlee for 5

I have no idea what this has to do with Mechanical Whelp. I certainly didn't suggest that Rogue is better than Hunter, because that's a crazy opinion. Backstab to help vs aggro and Cold Blood as an additional reach tool and Egg activator are nowhere near enough to compensate for better DR synergy, better midgame and DK Rexxar.

1
YouNeedNoGod•

Have you tried Myra?

1
_Click_OP•

Don't have her so no. Can't say I feel inclined to add her to the deck though.

1
mooshoorama•

I have her in my deck. When she hits its great but the deathrattle pool is pretty bad. I have her there mainly for deathrattle synergy. Don't craft her but if you have her, she's not the worse.

1
L3gitAWp3r•

If I only have enough dust to craft either zilliax or Sonya for this deck, which should I craft?

1
_Click_OP•

If you are low on dust I do not suggest crafting this list. It may well get pushed out of the meta if it speeds up.

However, between the two cards I would say Sonya is the better card in this specific list but Zilliax will undoubtedly go further in terms of value for dust as it appears in a number of different archetypes.

3
L3gitAWp3r•

Thanks! So Sonya is more important to this deck but zilliax is more used in the current meta?

2
Erythais•

Yes

2
b0wzy•

Sonya also rotates sooner than zilliax

2
impore•

Thats a bigboy win rate, very impressive

1
_Click_OP•

Haha thanks appreciate it

1