Is Garnet Run at 1 or 2 in Brilliant Engines?

Discussion

I’m not sure as to whether Garnet is a one of or two of in Brilliant engines (ones where the light monster i send isn’t important). At one, drawing the Garnet will make three other cards useless in your deck. But resolving Brilliant Fusion once would make two other Brilliant Fusions dead in the deck?

At two you will always have Brilliant Fusion alive in the deck, but you are literally running two normal monsters.

At one, you reduce the chance of drawing a normal monster in the first place, but again would make two cards dead after resolving it once.

I don’t think it’s preference, there has to be an answer. I can’t seem to find one online

Posted Aug 20, 2018, 9:55 AM UTC

2144
sawdomisehttps://imgur.com/a/BGNvOrH•

As a wise man once said:

If you run 1 Garnet, you will draw it.

If you run 2 Garnets, you will draw both.

One is probably the best.

57

Thats why you run 3. You draw that and brilliant. Activate brilliant summon garnet and make missus radiant.

4
RedPondaGive me all your combo decks•

1 garnet, 3 brilliant. 2 garnet is cutting too much consistency for little compromise around the issues you listed.

25
NephisimianI have no idea what I'm doing but it seems to be working.•

Either. But only cowards run 2. Running 2 roughly doubles your chance of opening one of them, so its a matter of how important the Brilliant engine is for you. If you rely on it then you should probably run 2 because you brick more if you open no brilliant than you do if you open a garnet. If it's supplementary, such as in World Chalice, you run 1 because it's fine if you can use it, its fine if you can't.

That being said, I have run 2 in decks occasionally, specifically 1 Lapis and 1 Lazuli, because I like to be able to use Lapis Lazuli as a finisher card against big spam boards. It's a consistent 3000-5000 damage that pitches the lazuli from deck to recover the milled Lapis, which you can then discard for knightmares.

12
InfernoidsorDie•

I don't want 2 in my deck because I'm a coward it's because it's an earth attribute for an easy nat beast. Same with infernoids when I did the brilliant shenanigans I ran two because at the very least it was a big normal ns beater that doesn't take up levels.

2
NephisimianI have no idea what I'm doing but it seems to be working.•

When real duelists want to negate spell cards, they run Imperial Order and a Kyrios Gyphon engine!

-2
InfernoidsorDie•

Sorry dude I ain't ever had someone chain MST to my natbeast when I activate it at standby so

3
TheWinterSaint:att-dark: ASSvendread Savior•

usually one garnet. you should only run 2 if your deck lives or dies by brilliant fusion.

8
zone-zone•

even then just 1

7
TheWinterSaint:att-dark: ASSvendread Savior•

But what if you are playing gem-knights?

1
KronicNinja•

The funny thing is Gem-Knights don't even play Garnet.

8
EseMesmoScraps will be meta, my uncle works at yugioh•

Gem-Knights would rather run Tourmaline over Garnet for Prismaura. Ruby is good, but removal is better.

2
zone-zone•

pretty sure Gem Knight FTK doesnt even run a single Gem Knight Garnet

2
ytpies•

A good way of looking at it is to think about which scenario is worse: having Garnet in your hand, or not having Garnet in your deck.

If your deck falls into the former category (most do), run 1.

If your deck is super reliant on Brilliant Fusion, or you have some way of using Garnet if you draw it, you might be in the second category, and could consider running 2 Garnets.

7
dakattack101•

Instead of giving a judgment on this, I'll simply provide some statistics, assuming a 40 card deck and 6 card opening hand:

  • With 1 Garnet, there's a 15% chance you open it
  • With 2 Garnet, there's a 28% chance you open at least one Garnet, but only 2% chance you draw both

So by adding the second Garnet, you increase your odds of opening a Garnet by 13% but also decrease your odds of turning off your Brilliant Fusions by 13%. If you don't mind drawing a Garnet because Brilliant will plus you so hard, run the 2nd. If your deck typically needs all your cards in hand to win the duel, I would say run 1 and hope you get lucky.

7
breadvisionOPNekroz•

Can you let me know how you did the math for opening two garnet

1
dakattack101•

Of course! Go to the Hypergeometric calculator: https://stattrek.com/online-calculator/hypergeometric.aspx

Enter based on the following:

- Population size = Deck size

- Number of successes in population = Number of Garnets in your deck (in this case "success" is actually drawing the Garnet, lol)

- Sample size = Hand size (usually 5 or 6)

- Number of successes in sample = Number of Garnets in your opening hand (1 or 2)

It will spit out all those numbers at the bottom, which tells you the probability of opening more, less or exactly the number of Garnets in your deck. This is an amazing tool for deck building, if you haven't played around with it you should try it out!

1
RNGtan•

u/dakattack101 's math lacks something: It is ignoring all the cases there you do and don't open Brilliant Fusion itself. You actually need multivariate hypergeometric calculation in order to determine how often the second Garnet really saves you. The only times where the Garnet matters is when you open Brilliant Fusion.

Just opening at least one Brilliant: 39.43%.

One Garnet: The chance of opening at least one live Brilliant (1-3 Brilliant, 0 Garnet) is 34.25%.

Two Garnets: The chance of opening a live Brilliant (1-3 Brilliant, 0-1 Garnet) is 38.87%.

The second Garnet basically improves your entire hand 4.6% of the times BUT increases your chance to brick by 13%. Doesn't look too good on paper anymore, does it? Run the second Garnet if your decks depends on it massively or can deal with the brick (World Chalice with Imduk, for example), otherwise 1 Garnet is mathematically superior.

0
breadvisionOPNekroz•

Could you also cite the website that you used for these results, or the general equation?

1
RNGtan•

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hypergeometric_distribution#Example

You can do it yourself, but might get tedious if you have too many variables. I don't know how to write binomial coefficients on reddit so let's do (x y).

The probability of opening a specific hand with Brilliant Fusion is:

([Total number of Brilliant Fusions] [Brilliant Fusions in hand]) * ([Total number of Garnets] [Garnets in hand]) * ([Total number of other cards] [Other cards in hand]) / ([Total number of cards] [Number of cards you draw])

For example, the probability of opening exantly one Brilliant Fusion and no Garnet in a deck with one Garnet going second would be:

(3 1) * (1 0) * (36 5) / (40 6)

Do that with all other combinations: 1 Brilliant, 2 Brilliant, 3 Brilliant, then add the results and get 34.25% . Remember to decrease the amount of "other cards" you draw as the number of Brilliant Fusions increases.

To compare that with two Garnets, do all of these combonations: 1 Brilliant, 2 Brilliant, 3 Brilliant, 1 Brilliant + 1 Garnet, 2 Brilliant + 1 Garnet, 3 Brilliant + 1 Garnet. Add all of them up, then get 38.87% . Also remember that the total amount of "other cards" is now 35, not 36.

0
dakattack101•

Odd that you say my calculation lacks something, when what you are trying to calculate and what I was trying to calculate are different things. My calculation is correct for what I was trying to show.

Your calculation is asking the question: "What are the odds I'll open a live Brilliant Fusion?"

My calculation is asking the question: "What are the odds I'll brick with 1 Garnet or 2 Garnet?"

You can say my math is lacking something I guess, but really I wasn't trying to answer your question because you may draw a Brilliant later in the game. A live Brilliant is live in your deck or in your hand, and a dead Brilliant is dead in your deck and in your hand, and you really don't know when you will draw it. Your statement "The only time the Garnet matters is when you open Brilliant" is completely false. You could open Garnet, and draw Brilliant later, and it may or may not be dead. Its true that the opening 5 cards are the most important as they are the only cards you are guaranteed to see, but your calculation completely ignores later cards as "important".

0
RNGtan•

Garnet doesn't exist in a vacuum. It has to be taken in the context of Brilliant Fusion. I am referring to this line:

[..] but also decrease your odds of turning off your Brilliant Fusions by 13%.

It really doesn't. Brilliant Fusion being turned off doesn't matter if you don't open it in the first place. Opening a Garnet always impacts the hand so the 28% brick chance stands, but not drawing Garnet doesn't automatically make it functional; the opposing result is not not-opening Garnet, it is opening Brilliant Fusion.

And of course I have only taken into account opening hands because you gave the premise:

assuming a 40 card deck and 6 card opening hand

Subsequently adding another condition is unfairly moving the goalpost. I can also turn that around: If I have to take into account the probability of drawing into Brilliant Fusion, you have to take into account drawing the second Garnet since your 28% isn't valid anymore. The seventh card has a chance of 8.82% of being Brilliant Fusion if you haven't opened previously but also 5.88% of being a Garnet if you run two Garnets and 2.94% if you run one. The odds don't improve too much over the course of the game and at that point the game should have progressed to a state where the player will either be dead or will establish a solid hold without it.

I get it. Saying that one's assessment miss something can come over as overly harsh, especially over the Internet, but it just bugs me whenever people spread false info. You certainly were not the first though.

0
HotlinedoucheJoin the Cybernetic Revolution•

you play 1 garnet and 3 Brilliant Fusions, this increases the chance drawing brilliant turn 1 and decreases the chance of having garnet in your starting hand.

4
breadvisionOPNekroz•

Should you not care about drawing Brillaint Fusion after turn one? Does the opening hand matter more in this case?

2
HotlinedoucheJoin the Cybernetic Revolution•

in yugioh all that matters is turn 1.. sadly

11
Urodacus•

Unless against some decks but it's quite rare

1
breadvisionOPNekroz•

As an addition, I am having similar issue in my Nekroz deck with the Impcantations. Currently, it is better to summon Talismandra from deck, as it is the one that searches monsters. Clausolas searches spells, so there really isn’t a need to summon Candoll, its counterpart. As such Talismandra is a pseudo-Garnet because i don’t want to draw it. I run:

x3 Candoll x2 Talismandra

I sometimes consider dropping Talismandra to one but again I run into the same issue with pseudo-Garnets.

Of course this will change when the new Impcantations come out.

Edit: I’m considering doing x2 Candoll and x1 Talismandra. Is this a bad idea? I need to get to 40 cards.

3
NephisimianI have no idea what I'm doing but it seems to be working.•

Talismandra is much less of a garnet because you can still do things with it. You still summon 2 monsters and you still search a card, even if its one you can search in other means. I would just max out both tbh.

8
Stratos1000•

1 garnet. Some people say running 2 garnet increases the chance of opening a live brilliant, but the only way to open a "dead" brilliant is drawing garnet, and running 2 increases the chance of drawing garnet.

3
JayofLegendUtopia the Lightning Crash Flower Cardian Lightflare•

Isn't the chance of drawing both Garnets if you run 2 lower than drawing 1 garnet at 1?

Just ran the math in the hypergeometric calculator assuming 40 card deck and 1 garnet you have a 12.5% chance of opening it. If you run 2 the chances of drawing 1 goes up to 22.4% but drawing both is a 1.2% chance.

5
NephisimianI have no idea what I'm doing but it seems to be working.•

Sure but a more than 80% increased chance of drawing one garnet is still horrible. Decks that rely on brilliant fusion tend to be decks that can't afford to have to play from a 4 card hand.

5
JayofLegendUtopia the Lightning Crash Flower Cardian Lightflare•

80% chance increase in drawing a Garnet but a 10 fold decrease in your brilliant fusion being dead. Mathematically that just makes sense and only doesn't if you shift the goal posts to talking about only having a 4 card opening hand.

2
NephisimianI have no idea what I'm doing but it seems to be working.•

Which is what we're doing. Of course more garnets reduces the chance of Brilliant being dead, but it increases the chances of your hand being dead. Remember that every time you draw a garnet, you could have drawn an Ash instead, which means you should only run multiple garnets if your deck can't function without brilliant fusion. But even then you'll be running the predaplant engine to get to it so you're increasing your numbers of garnets once again. There's a balance that needs to be found and it's not easy.

3
drkitteh•

That's part of the issue with drawing garnet though. It's an entirely dead card for the vast majority of decks. You might be able to have a dead BF less often, but lots of decks that rely on BF will just lose anyway because that garnet traded that hand's power for some consistency.

2
sheffieldboy•

Always just the single copy. You want to mitigate your chances of dead drawing cards.

To ensure BF is accessed more consistently, I always try to include 3 Lonefire, 3 Scorpio and 1 Cobra for added access.

2
jpz719•
  1. The reason is because you should, ideally, be saving your brilliant for when you can actually use that extra summon.
1
zone-zone•

look around some people already did the math and running 1 is the best

1
KuraudiioI Tilt Everyone Cuz I Maindeck Macro Cosmos•

Does you deck need to resolve brilliant fusion? If no only play one.

If it does you should be playing 2, you will instantly lose 1/8 of you games, if your playing cobra as well so 1/4 you will instantly lose, e.g. if your playing something like lightsworn play only one garnet because brilliant is only a bonus in that deck, if your playing something like madolches play 2 if you don't wan't to lose in the draw phase.

1

1 garnet. If you run 2 garnet and you end up with a hand of brilliant and 1 garnet that's still shit because you have a garnet in hand that you can't use for anything but knightmare fodder.

1
DrivenDust•

okay.

I have seen many wild speculations and assumptions that aren't true regarding your question.

In fact, it REALLY depends on your deck, so please answer this question; what deck does OP run?

Then I will be able to EASILY tell you what's right or wrong.

1
breadvisionOPNekroz•

Look to another comment I made. I’m running Nekroz. I’m just using the Brilliant Fusion Problem to illustrate my issue with pseudo- Garnets. I’m considering running Brilliant Fusion, but i don’t know how many Normal Simmons I would need to main before it’s a good idea

2
DrivenDust•

I think I kinda get it? But are you thinking about also running Brilliant Fusion in the Nekroz deck? Or is Brilliant for a new deck you are thinking about?

Regarding your Impcantation question :

3x candoll 1x talismandra

A dead Talismandra isn't the worst due to you potentially using it as Ritual fodder AND it not being your only way to search cards. The more Talismandra you play rather than single card dependant searchers the more do you promote a bricky hand. Does that make sense?

Brilliant fusion is a more difficult card. You always have to think about how important said engine is. I'll give some other examples:

Back in the day of 60 cards I believe 2 Darling Cobra would be right just like I am playing 2Gem-Knights currently in my World Chalice Build for Brilliant Fusion. Most of the time the brilliant fusion/Ophrys Scorpio play is so important that it's literally the only thing your hand hand can do. If that play fails, you'll be in giant trouble.

I'd say that like 90% of the decks that currently still use brilliant fusion (like World Chalice) can't breathe without Brilliant, so I would rather run 2Gem-Knights. Regarding World Chalice as an example again (I'm a giant WC nerd, sry :o) I also feel very validated in this theorycrafting due to the last win of WC being also with 2 Gem-Knights.

Also in the deck you're easily able to shuffle a dead Gem-Knight you have in hand back into your deck.

It would once again really help me if I knew which deck you were thinking about putting BF in.

If it was Nekroz, don't even bother.

1