I Dirty Bulked For Years. HELP!
In my early 20s I was relatively fit.
Sometime between 25-now (30) I ate like shit and lifted heavy which gave me this 236lb body which has OKAY muscle but also has a gut. I'm not comfortable at this weight and would prefer to be 190lbs and under (I remember this weight and it also helped being this weight for sports).
I HAD above knowledge in my 20s about dieting and exercises but that was 10 years ago and I honestly forgot half the stuff I've learned through college and online sources.
I don't really care that much about having a bodybuilder or fitness model look so I don't care too much about maintenance muscle. I messed up and now I'm in a body I do not like.
Current Routine at the gym:
day 1:
10 minute walk
upright row, shoulder press, front dumbbell raise with hammer grip, hammer curls, pull ups, pushups dips
10-15 min walk
day 2:
10 minute walk
deadlift, squat, lunges, box jumps
15 min walk
day 3:
8 minute walk, 2 minute side shuffle on treadmill
45 second sprints with 2 minute breaks in between for a total of 30 minutes.
Diet as of March is a low calorie / keto type. I keep it under 2000 cals
Every 2 weeks or so I will indulge in like 4-5 beer and a plate of nachos.
I'm open to all suggestions and critique of what I can do to adjust and get to my goal.
EDIT: Sorry I forgot to mention I am 5'11
Posted Aug 21, 2018, 4:45 PM UTC · edited
You're 30 and weigh 236 ... I'm going to guesstimate that you're roughly 6 feet tall .... and you work out regularly. Your TDEE is somewhere near 3200 calories per day. 2000 is probably a bit too low. And with all the activity you're doing, adding some protein and fiber will be helpful. Calculate your correct TDEE and subtract 500 - that's what you should be eating everyday to lose 1 lb per week.
5'11! sorry I forgot to mention. But wow that's a damn good guess.
calc says 3,174 maintenance. So I'm looking at basically 2700? That seems awfully high no?
I used to buy into protein powders but thought it was snake oil a few years ago, is it worth getting back into?
Not sure what you mean by protein powder being snake oil. Check the protein content on it, check the calories. You should know exactly what you're getting out of it, which is essentially lots of protein with a low amount of calories. I personally like using protein isolate powder as it tends to have more protein per calorie.
The numbers given above should be roughly correct. Keep in mind that they assume that you're doing intense workouts every day. They also assume an average metabolic rate for you. 2700 would be to lose a pound a week, 2200 would be for 2 pounds per week.
My recommendation would be to use those numbers as a starting point then trust the scale over time. If you're eating 2700 and not losing, then just adjust down. There are lots of factors that could make the numbers a bit off for you (not an accurate calorie burn estimate for your workouts, not perfectly counting calories, having a lower than average metabolism). All of these issues can essentially be resolved by lowering your calorie intake target by a bit.
What I mean is that I used to buy protein powder years ago and over time I would always read that it's just a waste of money and that you get enough protein through eating chicken/fish. I did buy a brand called AllMax Isolate I think.
I used this https://tdeecalculator.net/ calculator and set it to "moderate activity".
I'll hammer down on the cal counting starting at 2700 like you suggested. I usually eyeballed things because I knew the calorie for certain foods ie: 1 large egg = 70 cals
How much does sleep have a part in weight loss?
Protein powder is definitely not snake oil, it is exactly what it claims to be. It is also not magic and not significantly different than other forms of protein (some protein powders can be available in the body faster that dietary protein but its not a big deal for most people).
You 100% can get your protein from chicken and fish. Eat what you like within your calorie limits and you will lose weight.
If you're not losing at eating 2700, best advice that I can give is start by getting a food scale and weighing everything that you can to reduce intake error. If you're still not losing then reduce your calorie intake.
Edit: Just saw the question about sleep and I don't have a good answer. Maybe someone more knowledgeable about it can jump in on that one.
That's assuming you eat enough chicken and fish. Calculate your protein needs and meet them either with protein powder or chicken and fish or some combo of the three.
I would recommend you set you activity level to light if your job doesn’t revolve around physical labour.
Sleep in important not because sleep itself will cause you to gain or lose weight but people that are tired tend to eat more (to stay alert) and tired people also have less self control. Sleep also allows you to recover faster and thus have more intense workouts. So while sleep itself doesn’t technically change CICO, it will affect CI and CO for most people.
Not who you were talking to but this number is highly suspect.
Your sedentary TDEE is around 2500, your activity is fine, but it's unlikely to total 4200 calories each week. That's the problem with using those modifiers, I mean to me, personally, 4200 calories a week worth of exercise is more than "moderate".
Here is my suggestion. Don't add in calories every single day but rather, add in calories if you feel like you need them on a case by case basis, and try to not eat back 100% of the estimated exercise calories for the day, because one of the things that humans are worse at than estimating portion size is estimating calories burned. We're a lot more efficient than we assume.
I lift 3-5 times a week and do cardio 2-4 times and I almost never see the need to eat above my target calories of 1650.
Personally I'd say "get as aggressive as you can without putting the entire thing at risk". If you're feeling good at 2k calories per day, and don't think you'll binge, do that.
Now, the biggest question, how's your accuracy in tracking? Do you weigh your food? At least the calorie dense items?
Protein powder isn't "snake oil". It's protein and maybe a tiny bit of fat or carbs for flavor (depending on brand) but it's not any more beneficial than solid protein, and in fact, some people (including me) don't feel as sated from drinking as opposed to eating and so I'd rather use my calories on meat (or cheese, yum cheese!) than on whey.
This is exactly what I was thinking, almost word-for-word. You saved me a lot of time with your comment. 👍 Cheers!
I think that above poster is on to something. I was considering the calorie values above and they felt a bit high, possibly over-estimating exercise.
I still hold to what I said above though, choose a starting calorie intake then adjust to lose at the rate that you want.
Actually I'm surprised I didn't say this specifically. It's typically the advice I give.
"Pick a number, see how it works, adjust".
That's great advice thanks man. and to everyone else who replied.
It seems I most likely need to track my calories more. Right now I'll make a keto meal off this site https://www.ruled.me/keto-recipes/dinner and eat a size based off of what my lunch is. Which is 9/10x chicken breast in a salad. I usually just eat 1 boiled egg for breakfast around 10am.
My SO is 34, weighs about what you do, and is 6ft tall so I really just estimated based on him. :)