You literally cannot make this stuff up anymore: Josh Donaldson is being held out of tonight's lineup in single A rehab game due to soreness in his calf. Which he has been rehabbing FOR THREE MONTHS ALREADY.

Injury

Posted Aug 29, 2018, 8:52 PM UTC

25779
mysurgeon10Tm-5x5-R,HR,RBI,SB,OBP / W,K,S,ERA,WHIP•

Might as well amputate now and go by Lieutenant Danaldson

255
inrihab12T-H2H-R/HR/RBI/SB/AVG/OBP-W/SV/K/ERA/WHIP•
21
AK_Happy12Team-H2H-7x7-R-HR-RBI-K-AVG-OPS-SB / W-L-QS-ERA-WHIP-SV-K/9•

You ain't got no legs, Lieutenant Donaldson.

Yes, I know that.

6
mysurgeon10Tm-5x5-R,HR,RBI,SB,OBP / W,K,S,ERA,WHIP•

God bless you

5
stArlingArcher•

Lmao!!

3
porschekid11•

I’m in tears. So tragic. Why didn’t Forrest just leave him laying in the turf?!

1
Pure-PessimismESPN 14 team - H2H Points - Dynasty Keep Forever•

Depends on how much he does or doesn’t like ice cream.

13
KDog13k•

Magic Legs

8
fromman003•

Like on the space shuttle

2
Ipeeandgiggle•

Awesome comment and your cake day.

​

Brother, you hit the Reddit jackpot!

3
GivenToFly88•

Underrated top comment.

0†
Saltwooder•

Earlier in the season I traded Donaldson to get dozier. Then I traded Robbie ray to get donaldson back. 2 weeks ago i traded donaldson AGAIN for Nelson Cruz (keeper league).

I hate his calves.

87
Thunder_Thighs#10 Team-Head-To-Head-ESPNStandard•

Those are all really good trades for you though. You got a top 50 hitter for him, then you gave up a shitty pitcher to get him back, and then you traded him again for a slugger. It’s a win-win man.

73
ReeceChops44•

Yeah, at least he got something. I drafted him in the third round just to wait on his broke ass to get back.

23
Sod_Off_Shotgun•

I traded Jose Ramirez for him

Yeah

41
MyMomSaysImAMod•

F

35
RealDeal8312tm-H2H-6x6•

Dude....

6
OldRancidSoup10 Teams, AL only, 5x5, Keeper•

Why?

4
Dirtin•

I did the same, then I traded him for Bergman because I really needed SS eligibility and we added throw ins to make it even. I added Blake Snell, and he added Jon Gray. Oops.

3
Saltwooder•

I've had jd as a keeper since his days on the A's. It was a bit sad for me.

3
yankfan212•

I mean can we at least get a picture of this so called “calf”....

5
So-_-It-_-Goes•

I would like to trade your league for mine, when people laughed at the idea of trading for an injured Donaldson.

2
Saltwooder•

He was actually "healthy" for the first trade and then robbie ray was actually hurt also for the second one

1
drose198812 Team-Roto-5x5-Mix•

Will this be career-ending calf soreness?

51
RealDeal8312tm-H2H-6x6•

No, it's just a case of dead calf

7
Spaceisterrifying•

Veal is back on the menu!

4
Boston_Red_Sox•

I kept him last year. He is not being kept this year. Biggest cliff since miggy

33
brg000820T Dynasty 6x6 H2H (OBP,QS,SV/HD)•

Miggy was at least looking pretty good this season then his bicep exploded.... hello darkness my old friend

2
Faldien•

Will there be a press conference?

18
CheesecakePower10 T H2H Points-Keep 6 drafted after first 4 rounds, no penalty•

I wish he just said he was out the rest of the season at that press conference

7
ArrivesLate•

Right?! But at this point even if he played I’m not sure I would start him. I’ve got Muncy and Suarez and I haven’t seen anything from him that would warrant a guaranteed lock over those two. If Vlad gets called up, Donaldson is getting dropped.

1
CheesecakePower10 T H2H Points-Keep 6 drafted after first 4 rounds, no penalty•

Yeah I picked up Turner while he was injured and now he's guaranteed to start over Donaldson. Only holding Donaldson since I have the space and I don't want him beating me in the playoffs somehow

1
yankfan212•

LOL I just want so badly to drop him but I hold in fear....

16
mfranko8812T 5x5 H2H (OPS/QS/SV+HD) \ 12T Dynasty 7x7 (OPS/XBH/BB/K9)•

I am in a comfortable first so I can afford to hold him. Bur I must admit I've had some strong urges to cut him this season. I might do it tonight.

3
SobahJam•

I HODL my Bitcoin for the same reason

3
aLittleLebowski12T-H2H-PTS-Redraft-BB=1B•
16
IThinkTheClockIsSlow12 Teams, Keep 6, H2H, Points•

I understood he had passed thru waivers. Maybe there is a trade in the works. Not that I give a fuck at this point

11
yttimz•

This is it. Read yesterday, he will be dealt today. This would all make it come together.

3
Begs142912 Team H2H 5x5 Redraft (Yahoo Pro)•

I'm guessing it's just general soreness like when you go to the gym for the first time in forever

11
ChinaBasin•

Ok, but I'm fairly confident that I could've made this up.

11
zomgz0mbie10Teams-H2H-R 2B 3B HR TB H IP W SV K BB PKO QS•

How far the mighty have fallen.

6
LetMeRageThat•

This is Mets-esque

6
quinoa•

Shout out to the guy that said my Arenado + JoRam 1st/2nd pick combo was worse than the Altuve/Donaldson I could have had

6
DrJesusTralfaz•

Has he actually had a torn calf or a calf strain this entire time or has he just missed an entire season due to "soreness"?

5
cjohnson0312Team-H2H-6x6 AVG,OBP,W,IP,K,SV+H,ERA,WHIP•

I think everyone has accepted that there's a cover-up going on with what's actually been wrong with Donaldson. Gibby gets really angry anytime a reporter tries to find out what's going on, and he's usually really laid back

2
SconnieBro10 team H2H Points•

He’s on waivers and they are likely just being cautious in case he really does get hurt playing in A ball.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
at1445•

Right, but in reality if a team is going to trade for him, playing in 1 or 3 minor league games isn't going to change a thing. Unless he actually hurts himself. There's 0 benefit to rolling him back out before a trade happens.

1
JohnCarloStanton•

They're not going get good prospects in return right now, so why not just keep him and offer him qualifying offer? If he rejects, comp pick would be better than whatever prospects they get back now. If he accepts, it's still only a one year commitment and he might rebound.

1
at1445•

I don't disagree, but the guys on MLB Radio think there's 0 chance he'd turn it down and the Jay's don't want to take that risk when they're not really planning on competing/have prospects that could use that playing time that should be getting called up soon-ish.

1
rexmanly•

Are we sure this isn't just leprosy?

3
Scotty_FN_Knows•

The Sorest Calf That Ever Lived: A Josh Donaldson Story

3
Jawn0ftheDead•

He's had this calf strain since 2016

3
nyybaseball3#12Teams-H2H-#5x5 standard•

Reminds me of the time I drafted Steve Nash at the end of his career in fantasy basketball and he was out like 3/4 of the season due to “general soreness”

3
dontIitter12-H2H-w/OBP+SO+IP-Y!•

Im reminded of matt kemps woebegone 2013 season in which he played 72 games mixed in around running on an “antigravity treadmill” perpetually. All the while it was reported he was on track to begin a rehab assignment next wk for about 2months.this is worse.

1
oogla_ve14Team/3keep-Daily H2H-BA HR RBI R SB OPS K ERA WHIP W S Kd9•

You lost me at how we literally couldn't have up with this scenario. It's depressing, and ridiculous, but surely within what a normal person could theoretically come up with as a possibility.

If, instead, his calves opened up like the head of that old jewelry store guy in Men In Black and there were two aging aliens inside his calf cavities that had been driving Josh Donaldson like some sort of sports car, then yeah. We probably couldn't have come up with that (though I just did, so...)

3