Green Building Advisor???

What is everyone’s thought on this as a source of reputable information? I was a big fan as this website as an intro to green building until I met Martin Holiday. What are your thoughts?

Posted Aug 30, 2018, 1:19 AM UTC

47
JenJudy•

I've met Martin and I like him. He's a strong personality and I can understand why he might rub some people the wrong way, but he knows what he's talking about and his integrity is terrific. I've seen him make comments on the site dissing their own advertisers when the advertisers are BSing.

The quality of advice there is about 100X better than on r/homeimprovement. There are some regulars there who are incredibly knowledgeable, and if someone give bad advice, they'll get corrected pretty quickly.

3
BuildingSciOP•

I do see quality information show up but I think strong personality is putting it lightly. I have seen him demonize and belittle too many people.

2
WizardNinjaPirate•

If you are going to use your opinion of a persons personality as a guide to them being reputable or not you're gonna have a bad time...

2
BuildingSciOP•

I was thinking about this as an overall problem within the green building industry. So many of the long time leaders lose a lot of credibility due to how they act and speak to those who don’t build at a level they deem appropriate. It becomes really difficult to convince people to build better houses after you mock them for what they currently do.

1
tuctrohs•

Is there any other communication channel that has done more than GBA to advance your goals?

1
BuildingSciOP•

I have been looking to people and organizations like Gord Cooke, Housing Innovation Alliance, IBACOS, Building America, EEBA, Mike Barsik, Southface, Advanced Energy, and a few good builders that I have connections with. There are good people leading the charge and providing amazing information.

2
jnksjdnzmd•

I've always liked it. What does that guy say about it?

1
JenJudy•

He's the editor. OP liked GBA but got turned off by meeting their editor.

1