Poor experience with new player auto-guilds

I'm busy running an alt, for reasons, and I have to say that the experience of the levelling guilds they automatically put you in is very poor.

For those that don't know, when you reach certain achievement points, you are dropped into a guild. That first guild has an automatic rancor raid going on. You can request stuff, etc.

Of course, as everyone has crap toons and gear, the rancor raid isn't about strategy, but rather about everyone hammering their head against the wall until it breaks. Aka, it can take some time.

But once you hit two stars on five toons (or maybe its gear level four, I can't remember), you're automatically bounced up to a higher tier newbie guild. And all your raid progress is lost.

So you do more raid attempts (because the game is pushing you towards them via quests), now on Rancor & Sith Raid. But in a few more days, you've been booted up a level again.

Repeat ad nauseum.

Now, I know they want to keep things at a "challenging" level, but so far, despite throwing all the work I can at these raids every day, I've gotten zero rewards from them. And, frankly, as these guilds work the bosses like we used to do non-heroic Tank is the days before we'd worked it out (aka, just throwing squads at it until it dies), I don't expect to get any rewards until I get up a 7* squad and join a real guild.

And that... is good intentions making a bad experience.