Muhammad cartoon competition cancelled because of threats...

(Question/Discussion)

So it appears Geert Wilders has cancelled the cartoon competition depicting the Islamic prophet Muhammad. It was supposed to be a cartoon competition in which the prophet would be portrayed in a satirical way. This has lead to a wave of protests in Pakistan. I've watched the news recently and I saw how cazy some of the religious extremists can get in this country. Just two days ago a Pakistani man was arrested in The Hague after he posted a video on Facebook in which he threatened Geert Wilders with death.

​

After receiving hundreds of death threats Wilders decided to cancel the competition. He said he did this primarily out of safety reasons. I guess even an individual like him knows his limits. He's been living in isolation for 14 years now while being protected by bodyguards wherever he goes in public.

​

I was just wondering what you guys thought of this. Is this a de facto capitulation of the freedom of speech in our country to the blasphemy laws of Islam or would I be exaggerating by claiming this? Perhaps Wilders has planned this ahead of announcing this competition in April knowing the backlash from some of the Islamic countries would be extreme.

​

I'd love to read your input! :-)

Posted Aug 30, 2018, 7:07 PM UTC

5134
douglasmorrayNew User•

Although what he’s doing is controversial, I think it’s a good way for Geert to showcase how intolerant Islam is to the world. This should be considered 50% successful, for the attention it gets.

48
help8adam•

fuck pakistan

37
aNumbr2fromChickFilANew User•

SECOND that statement

14
Mohkale77•

And cue the hoards of Muslims screaming about upholding their faith by silencing people from opposing them through waves of death threats. Mashallah, truly a great and peaceful act. This is just another case of people being scared into remission, when will it end?

25
NeoMarxismIsEvilمحمد كذب (Never-Moose)•

These idiots might as well all be holding signs that say "kill those who say Islam is violent".

2
kuttijananiNew User•

I think some Muslims will still harm him because he had the audacity to exercise his freedom.

23
xhcd•

What a sad state of affairs. If the secular West can't stand up for free speech and against religious oppression anymore, who will? That in 2018 people need police protection for their opinions in Europe is just depressing.

18
NeoMarxismIsEvilمحمد كذب (Never-Moose)•

Yes exactly. It's not just decline of the west, it's decline of the whole world.

11
dontgiveupcaribNew User•

West is declining, East Asia is rising. Leftists have destroyed western culture

3†
NeoMarxismIsEvilمحمد كذب (Never-Moose)•

Rising economically but not in human rights terms.

2
dontgiveupcaribNew User•

Human rights might be something only a small subset of humans believe in. They’re also so vague and arbitrary that anyone can claim anything is a human right. For example the cartoons were seen as hurting Muslims human rights and thus wrong, criticizing Islam is Islamophbic and hurting their rights, etc. Eventually the subjectivity of said rights ends up destroying the whole concept itself.

East Asia will be the next economic global superpower and Islam will become 1/2 the worlds population, while the West will decline into a third world cess pool. The sjws who enable this will still be squabbling, while the most dominant economic and social global forces will be authoritarian.

2
NeoMarxismIsEvilمحمد كذب (Never-Moose)•

Yes, it is capitulation. People should remember that soldiers and civilians were willing to fight and die at various points to secure these sorts of rights.

It seems that this is no longer the case, so people can expect that these rights will be completely lost again. Anyone who wants to shut down a more important event such as a political debate can now do so simply by issuing a sufficient number of death threats.

9
dontgiveupcaribNew User•

The question then remains whether free speech was something

2
carolus_martellus•

It's not capitulation, it's exactly what he was counting on. Now he can portray himself as a victim.

2
naIamgood•

He did his job. He showed off muslims as intolerant freedom hating savages who are quick to kill for simple things such as drawing a cartoon

9
DROAWT17Never-Moose Theist•

I advocate for harmony. If Muslims are threatening violence and willing to censor free speech and it's a slim chance for them to see reason, something need to be done about that. People need to be prepared for a fight.

It's like dealing with toddlers, you can't give into their tantrums, you have to grow a backbone and say "too fucking bad deal with it".

7
NeoMarxismIsEvilمحمد كذب (Never-Moose)•

Except that dealing with these toddler tantrums requires guns and the willingness to shoot people who are trying to murder them which apparently most people in Europe are now too pussy ass to do.

Meanwhile the same terrorists try either successfully or unsuccessfully to murder people even they don't draw Mohammad.

6
dontgiveupcaribNew User•

Its very sad, the West has further been weakened by its own political correctness

6
Justice91OPNew User•

Perhaps I should try again in clarifying my position. What I'm afaid of is the possibility of Wilders having set a dangerous precedent. Of course I'm aware he's not active in the judiciary system so to what extent he may actually influence national legislation as a politician remains to be discussed. What he may have done nevertheless is set a precedent which extremist individuals in the future may exacerbate upon. Who is to say where this will lead to and where this will end. Why should the arbitrary sentiments of ideologues following the belief system of Islam be prioritized over the liberty of free speech (which happens to be a byproduct of the age of enlightenment)? Although I do have to nuance my opinion in the sense that I do quite understand the motives of mr. Wilders. Extremists jeopardizing the safety of Dutch nationals in foreign countries is obviously unacceptable.

6
NeoMarxismIsEvilمحمد كذب (Never-Moose)•

Yes, Wilders specifically is irrelevant. The main problem is that it demonstrates that discussions and debates can be shut down by threatening violence, so we can expect the use of this tactic to become more common.

7
dontgiveupcaribNew User•

Ask those in your country and culture that supported the Islamists in the first place

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
NordKoreanskeSpionNew User•

And there were also a lot of inbred muslims in his comments who were praising Hitler and the Holocaust and hoping for another holocaust.

3
TotesMessenger•

I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:

 ^(If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads.) ^(Info ^/ ^Contact)

2
makahlj7proud Islamophobe•

If it was the Netherlands doing it, I would call this capitulation. But it was a private event, so the organizers can do whatever they want - organize it, cancel it etc. without owing an explanation to anybody. I admire Mr. Wilders' stance against Islam, but he is doing it at a great cost for himself, and we don't have the moral right to demand more sacrifices from him.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
AverageBubble•

It's funny how white people think getting more white people killed is a strategy. keep listening to those neat radio shows and your trustworthy politicians XD. oh and by all means keep meeting up in your discord, reddit, iirc and white bars.

sincerly, a race traitor.

oh hey, not only have you goofballs killed a white girl in virginia, you're also getting whites killed around the world. good moves muhdudes. keepin it strategeric.

praying for 6 more years of this shit, and then some sweet ass reprisals.

1
AverageBubble•

ISLAM SCARY! MAKE IT GO AWAY!

1
ghostfivenineSince 2015•

Netherlands has the freedom of speech to allow the cartoon contest. Pakistan and other Muslim countries have the freedom to protest against things they don't like.

Besides the death threats, I think everything worked out exactly the way it was supposed to.

0
jf00112New User•

Besides the death threats, I think everything worked out exactly the way it was supposed to.

You conveniently put the death threat aside, which is where the issue actually is.

Countries stating their objection thru diplomatic tools is fine.

Threatening violence/death to others is a crime.

If I'm free to speak, but you threaten to kill me for what I said, then you're committing a crime and I should be protected from your threat by the law.

I hope they investigate the death threats.

6
ghostfivenineSince 2015•

Yeah, you make a good point.

2
makahlj7proud Islamophobe•

Threatening violence/death to others is a crime.

Murdering one for insulting Islam might be a crime in the Netherlands, but it is apparently a commendable deed in Pakistan (see Mumtaz Qadri). Same about threatening.

2
NeoMarxismIsEvilمحمد كذب (Never-Moose)•

Yea, I don't think we can expect Pakistan to prosecute anyone for death threats when the threats are targeted against an "enemy of islaaaaaam" because even if it's illegal and even if the prosecutor prosecuted the crime, mobs of violent Islamic thugs would be doing their best to behead the prosecutor.

1
XhaBeqoNever-Moose atheist•

Besides the death threats, I think everything worked out exactly the way it was supposed to.

Not simple death threats, but death threats from extremists who have a very good record of actually going through with their threats.

3