r/atheism•
ReddBert

Confirmation. What to do if you don't want to do that.

As part of the Action wiki, I'm preparing pages on [Holding your ground](https://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/wiki/action/holding_your_ground).

​

The first topic is Confirmation and if you don't want to do that. For those of you who are not in that situation it may still be a good read because of the line of arguments followed (taking the moral route, trying to seek agreement instead of a head-on conflict).

​

....

Posted Sep 2, 2018, 3:35 PM UTC

26
Bassopotamus•

Upon realizing that confirmation was me accepting to be part of the church and not my parents choice like baptism, I told my rents I wasnt going through with it. They made me anyway. Kinda defeats the point doesn't it? Forcing someone to do something they don't wanna do will almost always backfire.

3
Psych-adin•

"Fake it 'till you make it" Because that that totally works.

/s

1
JackRawlinsonAnti-Theist•

"This is a solemn promise made before god, as a commitment to god. I don't believe in god. You do. You're saying I should lie to your god?"

2
SpHornetAtheist•

it omits the downsides of holding your ground

1
ReddBertOPAgnostic Atheist•

I do stress that one should be safe or not stand up. And the confirmation page itself starts with discouraging people to stand up because of consequences (but if they do it anyway, it is best that they are prepared and know ways to reduce fall out). But perhaps a page on the downsides is a good idea! :-) If you have points for that, I’d love to hear them.

....

1
SpHornetAtheist•

I do stress that one should be safe or not stand up.

sure i saw that, but being safe to stand up doesn't mean there are no possible negative outcomes

If you have points for that, I’d love to hear them.

i know to little of it, i have no personal experience, but reading stories here, i've heard loads about people becoming hostile or distant when they learn people are atheist

i agree that in many cases it can be good stand up, but i think people should weigh the downsides and upsides themselves

2