Do you have to discuss a religion-related issue ahead? Make it both cordial and more effective
The experiences from people on this stub are clear: People don't change their religious opinion based on cold hard facts and logical arguments. The Socratic method of asking questions ("street epistemology") is much more effective at getting people to make the first step of starting to think critically.
If you have a discussion with someone you know, this can be a bit harder as you're not putting on the hat of wanting to learn about the interlocutor. Then the incessant questions may be perceived as a cross-examination which doesn't help either. Plus, the interlocutor is at a disadvantage because you take the initiative, and he has to come up with answers while having not much time to think about them.
You can avoid that situation by sending a couple of those questions ahead. You are giving your interlocutor time to think over them. This has several advantages. You may already make a bit of progress in getting him to think critically. Any change of mind, however minute, is not perceived as loss of face. Also, by sending the questions you are basically giving away your advantage, so the interlocutor will not feel ambushed and the conversation will be more level.
For the questions below, they have also been selected because it is likely that for several of them the interlocutor and you will agree on the answer. And agreement helps in a conversation.
The questions and an introduction are part of a new page of the Action wiki, and you can find it here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/atheism/wiki/action/cordial_conversation
(Link now fixed)
Bert
I found these questions on the internet and thought I'd share them with you because I'd like to discuss XYZ with you and I thought that this would help us to find common ground.
1. Of the total world population, 33% of the people subscribe to the largest religion in the world. Assuming this largest religion is the one and true religion, what percentage of the world population is wrong?
2. If you take a guess, then of the people who follow a false religion, what percentage of these people will think they have the right religion?
3. In both of the largest religions (christianity and islam) there are those who are of the opinion that evolution is true and those who are of the opinion that creationism is true. Which of the following aspects is a factor that determines what is actually true (as captured if there had been a camera running through the ages): a) the way a person is raised; b) the strength of the personal conviction to know the correct answer.
4. There are and have been hundreds of religions (with thousands of gods). Being contradictory, how many of these religions can at most be right?
5. Based on your answer to question 4, do you think there is evidence that mankind is good at making religious stories up?
6. Typically, kids all over the world adopt the religion of their parents. Do you think that the veracity of the religion is an important factor in this process?
7. Assuming false religions exist, which of the following factors do you think would contribute to the religion maintaining itself despite being false? a) exposure to the tenets of the religion from a young age, b) social pressure to conform and discouraging honest questioning of the religion, c) empty promises and threats about the afterlife, d) religious leaders financially benefitting from the followers, e) call belief without evidence a virtue, d) declare doubting the religion a sin.
8. Your neighbours have two kids. The first kid doesn’t do mischief because he doesn’t want to. The second kid doesn’t do mischief because his father threatens to spank him if he does and his mother promises the kid a present if he doesn’t. Which of the two kids do you think is the more moral kid, if any?
9. The dean of a university in a US state expunges bad grades for students who flatter him during their stay at the university and gets them interviews for the best jobs in the area. Those who don’t resort to sweet-talking end up with sub-par jobs or even unemployed. Do you think this is fair?
10. In common with most other humans, most atheists don’t steal, rape, kill or do other bad things. Taking your answer to question 8 into account, who do you think is more moral: A person whose morals are guided by the promise of a reward and threat of punishment in the afterlife, or an atheist who just lives by the principle of doing no harm?
11.\ Taking your answer to question 9 into account, do you think that the best system a fair and just god could come up with would be to reward those that resort to sweet-talking and punish those that don’t?
12. What do you think of the notion that - as there is only one reality and religious differences are a source of sorrow in the world - friction between people and countries could be reduced if people were more open to the possibility that their religious opinion might be wrong and would align their opinions with reality because it is not moral to perpetuate a falsehood?
Posted Sep 9, 2018, 2:26 PM UTC · edited
I would say it's more effective in most cases, but we still need firebrands. I'm the sort of person who was rudely awoken from my faith by people mocking it and forcing me to find answers to prove them wrong (which led to deconversion). If I was instead given polite, thought-provoking questions I don't know if I'd have become an atheist so soon.
Edit: I meant to say, those are some good questions, OP.
Mocking is one of the methods based on a psychological angle. I think it is in particular effective if the person being mocked is in the minority or alone with the person doing the mocking.
Other approaches using psychology can be based on
- fear (what if you are wrong and there is a higher power but it wants you to be honest, instead of blindly regurgitating what is in scriptures and what your parents indoctrinated you with)
- appeal to their feeling of moral superiority and using that to force them to be honest
You can also reduce the threshold that people don't dare to draw a conclusion (e.g. that evolution is true for example based on the vitamin C example) by letting them say what they think an alien who landed with a spaceship would conclude. Then they don't have to say it for themselves (but in fact they did make a step forward because they acknowledged the facts ).
Acknowledging that people are emotional beings and that one has to find out what approach works for that individual to get them to think is essential for making a positive change in this society instead of giving up and saying it can't be done. You are one of the many pieces of evidence that it is not impossible. So, thanks for sharing that!
...