Kitchen Outlets Have Really Weird/Crazy Behavior
Hi, I have 5 electrical outlets in my kitchen—each of which is installed in a 2-gang box accompanied by a switch to control under-cabinet lights.
3 of these outlets are non-functional. Of the gang boxes with the non-functional outlets, 2 have non-functional switches (the under-cabinet lights won't turn on*) and 1 does have a functional switch but it appears to be on an independent circuit.
* ^(This isn't always the case, read on for more details)
I recently purchased an electrical outlet tester, and here are the results:
- When all the under-cabinet switches are off: Tester reports "Open Neutral" on all non-functional outlets
- When either of the two non-functional switches is turned on: Tester reports "Live Ground Reverse" on all non-functional outlets with the exception of a single plug/receptacle on one outlet (which I will call outlet #3) where it reports "Live Ground Reverse / Missing Ground"
- When I physically hold one of the non-functional switches exactly in the middle between its on and off state: Tester reports "Correct" wiring on all non-functional outlets (except the odd receptacle on outlet #3), although one LED indicator on the tester is dimmer than the other
Here's another thing that's strange. If I plug my old slow cooker into the odd receptacle on outlet #3 and turn it on, the other non-functional outlets then start to report "Live Ground Reverse / Missing Ground" but nothing else changes (the slow cooker stays off).
But here is where it gets really strange... If I then turn on the "non-functional" switch on outlet #1, the under-cabinet lighting for that switch suddenly starts working again, but the slow cooker stays off.
If I instead turn on the "non-functional" switch on outlet #2, the under-cabinet lighting for that switch starts working again AND the slow cooker (on outlet #3) turns on as well.
So my main questions are:
- What the heck is going on here?
- What needs to be done to fix the problem?
Thanks for your insight.
Other notes: This is an older kitchen so the outlets are not GFCI protected. The breaker panel also indicates the kitchen circuits have split wiring.
Posted Sep 13, 2018, 4:10 AM UTC
Based on your description:
Kill all power to the kitchen immediately and get an electrician out there. Fix should cost around 300-750.
It should take about 2 hours.
You are describing a problem that clearly involves a series circuit (Likely due to a crap connection) and a bonded neutral to ground (likely due to a moron). This is undiagnosable via the internet but easily fixed onsite.
Thanks for the info. I will heed your advice and get an electrician to come look at it.
Just to clarify, all the outlets and under-cabinet lights were functional up until a few months ago. So it would seem there was some sort of spontaneous electrical fault that caused or at least contributed to the problem.
It may also be worth noting that (I've read that) outlet testers may erroneously report "Live Ground Reverse" when really it's just an open neutral on a circuit where a device/fixture is attempting to draw power.
One other thing that may be worth noting is that the switch in the gang box with outlet #3 (the one with the odd plug/receptacle) is white in color whereas all the other switches and outlets are almond in color. Thus it would appear that the switch was swapped out at some point (maybe 10-20 years ago), and at least superficially it would seem to be a likely culprit.
However that switch and the circuit it's on haven't had any problems. For whatever reason though, that particular switch is on the same circuit as the dining room and a large chandelier in the main hall area (whereas all the other kitchen outlets/switches are on circuits confined to the kitchen).