Discussion reports: Races of the Steppes and Savannas.

Welcome, and what is this about:

This is the first post of a series. On our discord, there is a weekly discussion with a small group on a topic of the design of SotE, and there may be other design discussions as well. A summary of such discussion is then posted here, for public comment by anyone interested. You are not guaranteed an answer by the devs to your comments, much less that we will implement them. But we will try to read all of them, to see if they are helpful.

Today’s notes taken by Magnive, edited by Calandiel.

Introduction:

Today's discussion was about races, starting with what would live on plains.

A recap of what has been decided about races so far. There are two kinds, generalist and marginal races. The generalist races are adapted to living in prime lands, and may have a preference for the kind of place they live in, but should be able to do reasonably well in most places. Every continent will typically only have one of these living on it. Examples of generalist races are humans (preference for farmland), and Elves (preference for woods). Then there are the marginal races, who have adapted to living in environment that is not as prime, being pushed away by generalist races. These are tied to a certain biome. Marginal races will live in some place of a continent that is also inhabited by another race. An example would be Dwarves, living in mountains.

We will now (and in future discussions) discuss various biomes, and what would evolve there, keeping in mind that they would be pushed away from better areas to live. We will start with plains.

Steppes and savannas:

Fewer environmental dangers, but perhaps not as much opportunity for food.

Combination of loess soil (not that fertile) and little rainfall can create much large game, but little farming, unless there’s a river running through.

Bad for farming unless you have chemical fertilizers.

Soil varying, but without rainfall it’s difficult to have agriculture.

Generally, savannas lend themselves mostly to pastoral societies.

Refuge populations for less developed societies and orcish horde types, as they were refuges for steppe horse people historically.

People here tend to be powerful if they can trade with civilizations… but also often end up destroying these civilizations, or at least damaging heavily them which fits well with SotE’s theme of growth and decay.

Until advanced gunpowder weapons are researched, steppe people wrecking things were a credible threat to basically all civilizations in their vicinity - here, magic and tactics might be a potential substitute, though.

Bad for building civilization, but good at supporting barbarian/horde types, who could potentially fight on even footing with civilized races.

Eating grass: a time-consuming but persistent source of food which means that you have to do it practically always, whereas carnivores feast for a short time, and can then spend the rest of the time doing other things. So probably not a good basis for a sentient race. See hunting hypothesis

On the other hand eating things that eat grass doesn’t allow for high population density. General population is limited by how much grass is present, which is determined by soil quality and climate

Probably leads to smaller bands/tribes, as populations will likely be spread out by necessity. At its most complex: probably loose confederacies.

Specialization: this kind of nomad behavior probably wouldn’t allow for diversity of professions. When a significant chunk of collective effort is spent on hunting, soldiers are better off while artisans suffer.

This creates societies well fit for warfare. Almost everyone can be used as a soldier If there’s a river, generalists could possibly settle around it.

Possible races:

Orcs:

Biased towards nomadic pastoralism.

Possibly breeding horses capable of supporting them

Minotaurs:

Herbivores (or omnivores)

Halflings:

Live underground, possibly omnivores.

Create relatively complex societies.

Based on meerkats

Notes:

Predators in savannas would be thinner than in steppes (thickness traps heat, being lean disposes of it).

A potential herbivore race would have long lives, get little done in years they had due to having to eat for so long. They’d be large and defensive of their young (due to long lifespans), similar to mammoths

Question to consider: Mid-sized saber-toothed cat as intelligent marginal species?

Steppe vs savanna vs grassland:

Temperatures and seasonal differences.

Savannas have better climate (for vegetation/agriculture) compared to steppes.

Lots of food (grass), humans just can’t eat it.

Either adapt to eating grass, or raise cattle and the like, then eat that.

Omnivores that evolve on these biomes would likely become a generalist race (as humans did) without some additional drawbacks.

Posted Sep 16, 2018, 9:31 PM UTC

297
DemianskyDev•

Steppes and savannas will likely become "flashpoints" for conflict, as they often tend to evolve geographically from arid grasslands to relatively fertile grasslands. China and Ukraine are great historical examples where; if you can manage or resist the powerful barbarians that live on the steppes or savannas, you can tap the tremendous carrying capacity of the grasslands adjacent the steppe or savannas. Of course, the flip side is that civilized peoples dwelling near these marginal areas end up empowering these marginal land barbarians with inventions they never would have ever produced on their own.

As in history, a good (but sometimes double edged) tactic for dealing with these rugged, powerful barbarians is to bring them into your military's ranks as mercenaries against your enemies. Better to have them turned on your foes than on your own peoples. The drawback to this tactic is that if they become TOO successful in your employ, they might just decide that they'd be better off conquering their employers.

16
Alin144•

How about having nomadic Centaurs?

7
DemianskyDev•

It's still a subject of design discussion at the moment, but we've been considering "semi-civilized" races like Centaurs, Minitaurs, Gnolls, etc. They would ideally exist as societies that enjoy some form of organization, but which never/rarely advance further than tribalistic societies due to significant restraints on their ecology.

4
catchykick•

Now this is epic 😎

5
AlexiumII•

Elves? I'm in.

5
Enkidu88•

Beautiful worldbuilding

5
Jocavalo•

Truly a fascinating topic

2