r/NYGiants•
splendic

Eli vs O-Line Wall of Text

DISCUSSION

We've clearly got a long season ahead of us, and there's no reason to have the same basic arguments filling the sub day after day, so I want to clear up some of the Eli vs. O-Line discussion for both sides as best I can.

O-Line: The line is a shallow collection of mostly below average players. Some are inexperienced, but all look poorly coached; at best unprepared for the Cowboys this week. If you watched offensive packages with extra blockers (like that two TE set), you'll also see poor blocking from the TEs as well. There’s a chance that the line could become marginally better over the season, and position players could improve their blocking, but it's even more likely that the many upcoming high-pressure D-Lines will deflate the potential progress any of the Giant’s blockers could make.

O-Line fixes: Clear cap space for any potential offseason moves, and draft draft draft. Move up for big talents within reach, or drop down to stock up for depth. Clearing cap space likely means committing to Lauletta, or going after a relatively mobile journeyman QB. Unless there’s a Vick/RGIII-eque talent about to magically emerge in the next draft, it doesn’t make sense to take yet another QB and keep everything else the same. I’m not overly enthusiastic about the options, but the team looks to be against the wall on that decision. No matter what the direction the Jints go with, the line rebuild to even get back to average is likely to take at least two seasons, probably more.

Eli: Eli manning as an aging pocket passer is most likely done with this team as it’s currently constructed and coached. I say this as a career-long Eli fan (and usual apologist). Considering his ability to stay healthy after being assaulted week in and out over the last 3 seasons, I believe he could still play for another team that has average to above average protection. Whether or not anyone in that situation would want him (especially with his contract) is a different issue altogether.

Here’s where we hopefully quash some of the constant arguing: I don’t believe that Eli is done because of his age, or simple natural decline. I believe that playing under heavy pressure for so many games (multiple seasons) has eroded his effectiveness, and degraded his skillset. His footwork is sloppier than usual, his reads are off, his decisions are made under panic even when he’s got more time (running right into a visually present linebacker with your star RB open?), his passes look wobbli(er than usual) and too high a percentage of downfield passes are inaccurate. His ability to get the team set in time to call out schemes or consider potential audibles is also diminished. His completion percentage is fine, but the rest of the team isn’t built to last on only short yardage gains with no blockers, no matter how good Odell and Saquon are.

Could the coaches adjust to give him a better chance to succeed? They could sacrifice Engram over the middle for jumpballs, they could design more QB bootlegs, they could put a real fullback out there and commit to a more supported running game to try to open play action, they could move the checkdown routes to sideline outs, curls, slants, etc…but these are all such common sense, you’ve got to assume they rightly don’t want to risk injury to all the WRs again. Plus, it’d likely take many games for Eli to completely regain his composure, and that’s not a luxury either he or the team have to spare, unless they’re ready to admit the whole rebuilt operation is a wash.

Is it the front office’s and O-Line’s fault that Eli’s devolved like this? Most likely. But still, his fundamentals look broken, and they are not likely to improve with this offense as it’s currently constructed, especially with so many effective D-Lines about to come calling. I can’t say I’d necessarily pull him before the half-season mark, but I think it’s safe to say he’s done with Giants; a victim of poor personnel management more than natural decline.

For right now, maybe you’d argue to go with Lauletta for his mobility. There’s a chance that the coaches could gameplan around his legs (though their ability to make adjustments has not inspired confidence). There’s a chance that he could extend plays and make more out of what the same Offense has to offer. The flip side is that he could also regress on his fundamentals, mechanics, and game management if he also ends up under constant pressure. In the case that the coaches “break” the rookie this season, it could be necessary to look for a new #1 QB in the off season instead of a backup.

(TLDR) Let’s try to stop arguing about whether the issue is the O-Line or Eli. Eli is absolutely worse whether or not he’s being pressured, and it’s probably the fault of many years of bad Line play and the team managers for not supporting him with the personnel his skillset requires... but it’s not likely just due to simple natural decline from aging. There’s no good reason to argue about whether the line is THE problem, or Eli is THE problem. Eli looks broken, and the protection is/was to blame. What’s important is where do we go from here? Redesign the Offense with more risk to the WRs? Drop Eli and hope Lauletta’s mobility is enough to give the same O more play options? Or keep Eli in to avoid breaking the Rookie and cross our fingers for next season’s moves.

Posted Sep 17, 2018, 7:18 PM UTC

86
ThrillHammer•

He's got the deer in the headlights look, and missing open receivers downfield to throw checkdowns, it's ptsd at this point....

11
bonerbasketball•

I agree. Even when he does get a clean pocket you can see he’s still waiting for the pressure and not making reads

6
jerusalemcruiser•

Good read, I agree with everything you say for the most part. If I was Shurmur I’d be giving Lauletta some reps

4
s0m3f00l•

Remember this classic OG3 highlight?

http://www.nfl.com/videos/nfl-game-highlights/09000d5d81b085de/Vick-injured-on-rushing-attempt

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_0xdHAdpPI4

This is what happens with an elite QB and a shitty line forcing him to keep running around like a fool.

edit: remember this during the next draft when you are shouting to get the next QB

3
splendicOP•

I totally agree. A mobile QB actually having to run is a stop gap at best. Still, it might end up needing to be a priority over the next couple of seasons if they want any chance of having a productive O. It's ugly all around.

3
[deleted]•

[removed]

1