r/WWII•
robcore

Concerns regarding netcode and (lacking) studio support.

Discussion

Dear u/SHG_Hammer ,

Your netcode and game engine are NOT robust enough to compensate for the latency variance introduced by the lack of server location diversity provided by Daddy Warbucks (Activision).

Thanks to your clusterfuck of a matchmaking system, every single west coast lobby contains players from Hawaii, Alaska, Saskatchewan, Alberta, BC, California, Mexico, Guam, Guatemala, etc, and that's not including the fucking party system allowing for players from Australia, Japan, China, the UK, you name it. This is on the TWO server clusters you have in California, and the one in Seattle.

Fine. That's the nature of online gaming. Couldn't you, however, adjust your goddamned netcode to actually give high bandwidth, low-latency players priority over players tethering xbox live from their shitty Verizon connections? Make the people who actually CAUSE the discrepancy in the game suffer instead of those of us who have our connections optimized.

I swear to god it keeps getting worse. There is less consistency in this game than ghosts or even infinite warfare. I'm sick of it, and probably gonna ditch this unsupported shit pile for BO4 despite having been loyal to your studio since AW.

You honestly need to prove to us that you give a shit and are willing and capable of fixing your OWN FUCKING CODE, or the numbers will convince Activision to drop your otherwise lazy studio.

"Real people work at our studio." Yeah? Well real people spend money and time to play your game, and right now we're pissed because you're hiding away like scared turtles who don't know what to do.

Get your shit together.

Posted Sep 22, 2018, 9:28 AM UTC

1217
Kthorn90•

Yeah it's gone to shit recently and just keeps getting worse. I'm losing interest more and more each day because of this crap.

9
zero1918•

Not to be that guy, but Ghosts and IW both had crisp hit reg and excellent netcode.

The problem with SHG is that they don't seem to test enough their product or, that's an hilarious stretch, they're testing a different version of the product. How's that old bugs keep on coming back even after they got solved months earlier? Just look at the War announcer, it popped out of nowhere, got fixed and for some reason it returned one or two months later. Same goes with the green star.

5
KiIroywasHere:Xbox: :PrestigeMaster: :Allies: Sierra098•

Call me crazy, but I'm fairly certain the war announcer was a deliberate choice to bring back.

2
davidMP95•

I'm in Scotland and was playing against Americans the other night. i think i'll play this weekend then stop, it's not worth the frustration anymore.

5
robcoreOPGalatians 4:16•

Right? This is supposed to be a fun de-stressor!

1
thegameflak:PlayStation: Requisitions is cancer•

It happens to me all the time too, mate. I sometimes even get dumped into lobbies where I'm the only non-American in there, with maybe one other person that is in Europe. And those lobbies are always shite for lag advantage, favouring the Americans of course.

It has gone to the point where I now just block any user that has "English (United States)" as their primary languages spoke selection, unless I can tell for other reasons that they're from the UK/ Ireland and just got lazy (or whatever) when they selected their language.

1
Mike01010011•

This is the only thing that spoils the game for me everyday. Otherwise SHG did a great job with ww2.

Battle(non)sense did some great videos regarding this:

Call of Duty World War 2 Netcode Analysis https://youtu.be/R9iRFkGhze8

Call of Duty World War 2 Netcode: 60 Hz Placebo? https://youtu.be/EOuG2j2rTTs

4
robcoreOPGalatians 4:16•

Good links, I'm a big fan of his! He has one on gpns (game-versions of vpn that claim to improve ping) that's really good too. Tldr they're bullshit.

Also, he taught me that I want every single technical reference narrated to me by someone with a German accent.

1
Mike01010011•

Yes, German efficiency at its finest! He also analyzed other services which claimed to reduce latency but in his results he did not see any reduction but was careful to say that was his results and other people may get different results

2
Cipher20•

I don't think the hit detection issues are caused by bad netcode. Do you honestly think that a studio of this caliber would get something as simple as the netcode wrong? While much smaller devs have no trouble getting their online games to work properly. Do you think Activision doesn't have competent enough network engineers to create a properly working netcode? It's just not plausible.

People keep saying how good Infinite Warfare netcode was but both IW and SHG are owned by Activision and a lot of the same people worked on both games. You can go cross-reference the credits to see that. I bet that the same people worked on the netcode on both games too.

I've also tested the connections in WW2 a lot and played on different servers and it doesn't make any difference to the hit detection whether I'm playing on a <20ms server or a 150+ms server. The hit detection issues don't seem to be connected to networking at all.

I think the hit detection issues are intentional. A feature to balance out skill differences in lobbies. Good players get a delay so that bad players have a better chance against them. It's just another skill based system on top of the SBMM and team balancing. I bet BO4 will be no different when it releases. Letting skilled players stomp noobs and make them stop playing out of frustration is not good for business. Activision wants to keep the majority (bad and average players) happy.

3
robcoreOPGalatians 4:16•

You know, I've fought with you tooth and nail about this but it's not like I have any evidence to go on other than Condrey's insistence, so what do I know? Maybe there is an element of sbmm enforced by Activision and the studios aren't allowed to talk about it. That said, I DID test a dummy account and the mechanics were similar, but it may take ip or xbox hw info into account. Dunno.

Ping and bandwidth, however, are definitely factors that are taken into account and my testing confirms this. Google (with the quotes) "tc qdisc add dev eth0 netem delay" and you'll know I'm not messing around. Apparently if one adds 150ms of ping, matchmaking goes into a frenzy and places a western Canadian player in a Lobby from Qatar.

Nothing in this circus of a corporation makes sense anymore.

2
Cipher20•

I know what netem is. When you added 150ms latency you got put into a p2p lobby because the matchmaking couldn't find you a dedi with a decent enough latency.

2
robcoreOPGalatians 4:16•

Ah yeah it was a wild test to see if it would even let me play. Lol a 300+ round trip ping is ridiculous but I believe their cut off is 900 or so? Haven't gone that far but I am starting to buy into your conspiracy theories more and more after these experiments.

2
WhateverSource:Xbox: :PrestigeMaster:•

I think you forgot to add the /s.

1
robcoreOPGalatians 4:16•

Love you buddy :) Good news and bad news, codblock works but is useless because every server seems to guarantee either someone from Alaska, Brazil, or both.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ThatsMyPsychic•

Rob, you're angry, but please stop raging on SHG and telling new players not to get online. Not a good look. I mean that, it's not ok for you to judge who buys this game and gets to play and from where. Maybe the netcode is shitty but it's not exactly keeping you off of the completive circuit, just handle it dude.

1
robcoreOPGalatians 4:16•

Listen. I may be harsh, and i may use explicit language to express my points when frustrated, but I'm not wrong.

I'll always rage at corporations and those who carry out their greedy and unethical methods for ripping off loyal consumers, and nothing will convince me not to. Actually, one thing. I will shut up if I'm offered a full refund for a product that personifies the worst case scenarios in their terms of use agreement. Until then, it is my right as a consumer to fight back against people who are kindly and quietly screwing me over because they know they can. I'd rather a direct "fuck you" instead of their junior high bullshit.

Secondly, I've not mentioned a word about prospective new players, though I'm under no obligation not to.

As far as who gets to play and where: if people are going to be so selfish insofar as to knowingly exploit the flawed networking at the rest of our expense, I'm going to call it what it is.

Polite assholes are still assholes. At least I don't try to sugar coat what I am.

2