Souls and the trapping thereof
So, I recently got into a discussion about the morality of using black soul gems in Skyrim, and in the process I did a lot of research. The overwhelming consensus seems to be that black soul gems in general send souls to the Soul Cairn when trapped (and presumably forever thereafter given that Jiub has been there for hundreds of years), both speculated in "On Soul Shriven" in ESO and inferred by dialogue with Jiub in Dawnguard saying that he was soul-trapped prior to death by a dremora assaulting Kvatch during the Oblivion Crisis (so, in service to Mehrunes Dagon, not the Ideal Masters). There are a few things I'm confused about relating to this, but first let me lay out the things I'm going to referencing:
"Arkay the Enemy", seemingly written by Mannimarco, says that: "Arkay's Blessing prevents the souls of men, beastmen, and elves from being used without consent. ... As you know, my children, Arkay's Blessing is flexible to those with daring..." and "Necromancer's Moon" says this: "His Form, ascended to Godhood, has taken its rightful place in the sky, and hides the enemy Arkay from us so that we may serve Him. ... Grand Soul Gems offered to Him will be darkened, and can be used to trap the souls of the unwitting; a feat even the great N'Gasta would marvel at." So, Arkay's blessing prevents the souls of the intelligent races from being used without their consent; trapping souls of the unwitting is normally not possible, but black soul gems allow it; Mannimarco creates black soul gems when a ritual is performed to him on nights when his moon hides the necessary performer/altar from Arkay. From all of this, it seems fairly obvious that black soul gems are specifically defeating Arkay's Blessing. Additionally, "Will of the Master" says that souls in general are sent to Oblivion while trapped in a black gem, though it's worth noting that it doesn't specify where.
So, this kind of makes sense so far. One wonders why soul gems Mannimarco creates would also send souls to the Soul Cairn when the Ideal Masters would seem to be his rivals, but maybe he just doesn't have his own realm of Oblivion to rule over. Or, hell, maybe they're his benefactors too, given that they achieved godhood long before he did... maybe we have the Ideal Masters to thank for the blight of the Worm King! But I digress: there are a few outside factors that I just can't get to fit into this interpretation of soul trapping; for one thing, Mannimarco seems to be credited with inventing black soul gems, and it's said to be a great feat to capture unwilling souls. However, in ESO black soul gems are unnecessary for this, and in fact there's a book in ESO, "Guild Memo on Soul Trapping", where Vanus Galerion addresses the practice of trapping black souls (which had become commonplace) before Mannimarco had even ascended to lichdom, let alone godhood. But, if black soul gems aren't necessary to trap sentient souls, why the ritual? Even if the Mage's Guild refusing to teach people how to trap black souls worked to prevent the average mage from ever learning how to do it, it was evidently a very simple thing so I don't understand why Necromancers wouldn't simply know the 'real' Soul Trap spell and use that, rather than going to the extent of performing an elaborate ritual to create a very limited resource for the same purpose.
And to take it a step further, in Skyrim there are geodes tucked away in Blackreach that can be mined for various gems, including all sorts of soul gems - yes, even black ones. But, the Loremaster's Archive entry, Maelstrom Arena Part One, tells us that the Ideal Masters were once mortals, and additionally that, "They entered Oblivion as immortals, selected an area of chaotic creatia, and crafted it into a pocket realm ideal for their purposes as soul merchants." But if black soul gems are naturally-occurring, and they send souls to the Soul Cairn by default, how could this make sense? Wouldn't they predate the Soul Cairn? Perhaps sending souls to Oblivion is an artifact of the created black gems and these naturally-occurring ones don't have such a side-effect, but that seems very unlikely since "On Soul Shriven" was written before black gems had been 'invented', during a time when sentient souls were trapped in any manner of gem, and says this: "I pored over the scriptures given unto me by the Master to determine the nature of the Soul Shriven, for their very existence seemed in defiance of the accepted theory that all stolen souls travel not to Coldharbour, but to Soul Cairn. Nevertheless, in the confluence of events that followed foolish Varen's bid for Divine investiture, it seemed that all souls taken from that moment forward went not to Soul Cairn, but to Molag Bal's own clutches." And even if it were true, it still doesn't explain how naturally-occurring gems would somehow defeat Arkay's Blessing...
So, is there something I'm missing here, that would explain these seeming inconsistencies?
Posted Sep 25, 2018, 3:08 AM UTC · edited
Considering the only place you can mine black soul gems is close to a major dwemer ruin could have something to do with it. Maybe the dwarves had a way to grow soul gems and had discovered a way to grow even the black ones by doing something similar to what Mannimarco does. Afterall, they were known to give a big middle finger to all the aedra and daedra so i wouldn't put it past them to manipulate Arkay's influence.
As for Mannimarco crediting himself with the creation of black soul gems could just be his huge ego. This is all my speculation though so i might not know what i'm talking about.
I don't really understand why he would need to do so in the first place though; he undoubtedly is the person who popularized soul trapping to begin with even if he didn't invent it, but he may have done even that. So why not teach his supplicants this cool spell he (could claim he) created for them to use indefinitely, rather than make them a completely unnecessary tool that can hold exactly one soul before being consumed?
Could be consolidation of power. Why teach your followers all your godly powers when you can subjugate them with said powers? If i was in Manni's shoes i wouldn't want to risk an underling becoming too ambitious for their own good and killing me and taking my spot with the very tools i gave him.
I guess, but it's a pretty odd thing to be stingy about I think. They can do the same thing as having the true spell just by collecting a bunch of black soul gems, it just takes a lot more work. But, oh, maybe it's more of a forced dependency sort of thing? Giving them what they want but making sure they'll have to come back for more. I dunno if he actually gets anything from the ritual since in Oblivion you just pop a grand gem on the altar and cast soul trap and poof, it's black, but if nothing else it keeps people bound to him. Though it is predicated on nobody else ever figuring out how to do it, which seems pretty (extremely) unlikely when it was almost ubiquitous back in the Interregnum at least.