Rebel Creamery - Pretty disappointed after all of the positive posts
So I ordered a case of the Mint Chip after all of the positives posts and reviews I've seen.
Received it yesterday and eagerly waited for it to melt a bit so I could taste.
Frankly, the taste is just not good. I guess I understand now why Halo Top and other brands use some amount of sugar, with just the erythritol and monkfruit extract it tastes weird / artificial. It's edible, but only because I'm determined to finish it. My wife (who loves Halo Top) took one bite and refused to eat anymore after that.
I also thought the texture was a bit chalky/off although I expected it to be much creamier than Halo Top since it has more fat. Not the case.
If I could give Rebel one tip - you DESPERATELY need to source some allulose and add it to the mix to fix the taste. A combo of allulose + erythritol + monkfruit would probably result in something tasting fairly close to regular ice cream.
Anyways, just a warning to anyone thinking about spending a lot of money on a case, be careful. I'll probably wait until the other flavors are in local stores so I can try one at a time.
Posted Sep 27, 2018, 6:54 PM UTC
Make. Your. Own. You'll never go back to eating store bought. Pick up an ice cream maker on Amazon for $40. Get some allulose while you're at it (it makes the IC actually scoopable once frozen). Follow the directions on the recipe booklet, subbing the allulose for the sugar and half & half or almond milk for the milk (My favorite blend is two cups cream, one cup almond milk).
[deleted]
No problem!