r/keto•
64robots

Rebel Creamery - Pretty disappointed after all of the positive posts

So I ordered a case of the Mint Chip after all of the positives posts and reviews I've seen.

Received it yesterday and eagerly waited for it to melt a bit so I could taste.

Frankly, the taste is just not good. I guess I understand now why Halo Top and other brands use some amount of sugar, with just the erythritol and monkfruit extract it tastes weird / artificial. It's edible, but only because I'm determined to finish it. My wife (who loves Halo Top) took one bite and refused to eat anymore after that.

I also thought the texture was a bit chalky/off although I expected it to be much creamier than Halo Top since it has more fat. Not the case.

If I could give Rebel one tip - you DESPERATELY need to source some allulose and add it to the mix to fix the taste. A combo of allulose + erythritol + monkfruit would probably result in something tasting fairly close to regular ice cream.

Anyways, just a warning to anyone thinking about spending a lot of money on a case, be careful. I'll probably wait until the other flavors are in local stores so I can try one at a time.

Posted Sep 27, 2018, 6:54 PM UTC

1018
velvetv•

Make. Your. Own. You'll never go back to eating store bought. Pick up an ice cream maker on Amazon for $40. Get some allulose while you're at it (it makes the IC actually scoopable once frozen). Follow the directions on the recipe booklet, subbing the allulose for the sugar and half & half or almond milk for the milk (My favorite blend is two cups cream, one cup almond milk).

10
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
velvetv•

No problem!

2
FedEx_Potatoes•

Never had Rebel before. Been sticking to Enlighten since it's the only creamy low carb ice cream I could find locally. It blows Halo top out of the water.

3
Averen•

I don’t buy either anymore, but I thought enlighten was WAY better than halo top. Plus they have a flavor that’s crazy low carb, like 3 carb per serving

1
FedEx_Potatoes•

The chocolate with peanut butter I got today is 3 net carbs per serving. 1/2 of the pint just 6! I'm in heaven~

1
Averen•

Haha yea that’s the one. They have a similar flavor that’s higher carb to make sure you like for the Same red carton next time

1
KetoCaTx•

yikes. Sorry you were disappointed. I had the vanilla for the first time yesterday and really liked it.

3
bufftreefarm32 M 6’1” SW:455 CW: 341.4 SD: May 18’•

That’s too bad I really liked the Pb choclate flavor. Did you let it thaw? I microwave for 30 seconds.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
selene1123•

I'm glad I wasn't the only one who didn't get what the hype is about... Our Central Market just got it in and we tried the cookie dough flavor. The texture was so artificial. Definitely sticking to Halo Top or making my own.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
rebelcreamery•

Trust me, we haven't given anyone anything. I think it's just a matter of people just having different taste buds. Some will like HT better, some Enl, some Rebel. We publish every positive and negative review on our website, and there are certainly quite a few that don't care for it (and many more who don't feel the need to vocalize it). Ours is certainly not as sweet as others, and that is by design. We do want to explore allulose (to improve the scoopability) once the FDA stops classifying it as an added sugar and price goes down. But we totally get that many won't like it - it will always be this way, especially when you're working with sugar substitutes! Thanks for your honest opinion, we want to hear every single one!

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
rebelcreamery•

Haha, good to hear that.

The biggest reason we aren't using allulose is the cost. Our product is already really expensive. But saying "No Added Sugar" is an important claim we'd like to continue to make. I hear the FDA will change the classification, but you're right, it's not the end of the world if they don't. We also have concerns over gastrointestinal impact of allulose. Some have said it's one of the worst sweeteners in that regard. The biggest thing allulose would improve is the wait time for it to soften. It would also help us make a Smores flavor. 😉

1
tiempo•

I wouldnt buy Wink frozen "desserts" either then. Such a big disappointment. Exactly as you describe. I honestly dont understand it. For $5-6 a pint, I am bewildered as to how people continue to buy these products. I bought a Wink "mint chocolate chip", and quite honestly, it was terrible. The fake smell permeated the room and the texture was more like frozen ice water, chocolate flavor was "fake" as well. In the garbage it went.. 2 spoonfuls. Ive heard rave reviews about the pistachio flavor, but quite frankly, I would just whip up some heavy cream and throw in some sugar free pistachio pudding. Throw it in the freezer for 5-10 minutes (about the time it takes to actually takes to get a spoon into these "ice creams") and enjoy something that tastes like food.

1
tacosowner•

We've had the same experience with the exception being chocolate. Chocolate is actually really good once its nice and soft (sitting out for at least 30 minutes).

0
j4jackjgoal weight: whatever brings me to being not-underweight•

or drop the monkfruit and add stevia extract

0
HolycrapwtfatheismM/34/6'1" | SW: 298 | CW: 197 | GW: 195•

Making your own keto ice cream (or any ice cream) is stupidly easy.

0
oboboy1430/M/5'8" SW: 308 CW: 292 GW: 185•

I agree, I won't buy it again unless they change something.

0