Looking to get into the Edge Line for More Complex Configurations

I've installed lots of UniFi stacks, and for the most part, they get the job done and fit my needs for the install I'm doing, but I want to look into using the edge line for more complex configurations.

​

I'm planning on buying some Edge Line Routers and switches to set up a lab to test features and, I had some questions about the different models they offer and the software they use. I assume from looking over the product documentation that all the devices are capable of the same features, UI, and Commands. Except for hardware differences like SFP ports and the packets per second throughput. Can anyone who has used several different models confirm this is the case?

​

Thanks in advance.

Posted Oct 2, 2018, 4:17 PM UTC

26
UBNT-Jordan•

This is true, all EdgeRouter models run the same EdgeOS software and the software feature set is the same. The inexpensive ER-X is a good way to get your feet wet with the UI and CLI. We have a lot of useful guides in our help center like this Beginner's guide and this article that explains hardware offloading and how offloading differs between models. The ER-4 is our newest model that is about double the performance of the old ER-Pro and about half the cost.

5
bherrin26•

EdgeSwitch Model Differences:

  • Different PoE options
  • Different port densities
  • Fanless or fan...ful?

EdgeRouter Model Differences:

  • CPU/RAM - this translates to higher bandwidth limits as well as higher packets per second
  • SFP or no SFP
  • PoE or no PoE
  • Switch vs Bridge - the X line of EdgeRouters (ER-X, ER-X-SFP, the still-in-beta ER-10X) and the still-in-beta ER-12 have built in switch chips, meaning they have true switches and switching isn't CPU bound. Other models don't have switch chips and instead bridge router interfaces together creating a CPU-bound bridge instead of a true switch.

Why does it matter if something is CPU-bound or not? Simple. Say you have an ER-Lite. It can do near-gigabit routing at first. Then you set up QoS and bridge two interfaces together into br0. QoS and bridging are both CPU-bound so you can no longer do 900+ Mbps routing.

​

All that said, the GUI is pretty much the same from router to router and from switch to switch. I won't say exactly the same as there may be some deeply buried minor differences I am unaware of, but if you bought a single ER-X and a single ES-8-150W you'd be able to become comfortable with the entire line of EdgeMax products.

2
imjustmatthew•

I would also point out that some of the EdgeRouters use MediaTek chips and some use Cavium chips. It looks like Cavium is the future, so it might make sense to focus on labbing those. The ER-4 is really a standout value on that side right now, especially for the lab.

1
mafulynch•

You are also going to have different bandwidth limits if you use QoS. ER-Lite does up to 100mbps with QoS I think

1
gumpy_gimpOP•

Physical limitations I can see I just dont know if they limit some of the OS features from lower models and I would need to get something in the middle range for the lab.

1
imjustmatthew•

The only differences are the architecture and CPU power/RAM. I would suggest getting something on the Cavium side unless you really, really need to built-in switch on the MediaTek routers. This page breaks down which EdgeRouters use each of the two CPU platforms: https://help.ubnt.com/hc/en-us/articles/115006567467-EdgeRouter-Hardware-Offloading

1