r/btc•
bitsko

'Code obeys hashpower' -Javier González

Posted Oct 9, 2018, 12:25 PM UTC

2322
wndrkd•

And hashpower obeys price.

7
BTC_StKNRedditor for less than 6 months•

This has shown to be critically important.

The users and community set price, hash follows price.

6
JavierGonzalezGRedditor for less than 30 days•

A distinction must be made between types of power and the times.

The hashpower is an executive power, it can act. In the hands of the miners, it is like an instrument. The markets do not act, they react when it has already passed, some time later.

But due to the cost of mining operations, the action of the miners needs a guaranteed success in medium and long term. Weeks or months. Not years. This is good, because it prevents the miners from doing crazy things. But they allow them to direct the fate of the blockchain, with much prudence.

That's how Bitcoin really works.

6
m4ktub1st•

There are ideas that future markets could be used to direct the executive power. In your model, that would give a more active role to the market. I'm unconvinced since futures attract risk takers, a minority of the market. An interesting idea, nonetheless.

1
JavierGonzalezGRedditor for less than 30 days•

In my opinion the future markets are basically gambling, like casinos.

The skin in the game more intense is the skin of the miners.

They receive 100% of the incentive, control the blockchain and have the safest voting system in the world.

4
TiagoTiagoT•

Why not years?

1
JavierGonzalezGRedditor for less than 30 days•

Electricity, mining is expensive.

1
JavierGonzalezGRedditor for less than 30 days•

Not always.

Not on August 1, 2017 (the birth of BCH). That day, there was a rebel hashpower ignored short-term profit in the search for a bigger one. And that is business creativity and it can change everything.

And neither will the hashpower follow the market price next November 15 if there is hash war (BCH-BSV).

More info: http://virtualpol.com/Miners_are_the_executive_power_of_Bitcoin_EN.pdf

2
silverjustice•

Not necessarily. Hashpower follows expected future return.

If hash strictly followed price BCH would be dead. BTC is generally more profitable. But the expected future return has miners committed to BCH.

2
JavierGonzalezGRedditor for less than 30 days•

If hash strictly followed price BCH would be dead. BTC is generally more profitable. But the expected future return has miners committed to BCH.

In fork.lol the DARI ratio is nearly always balanced.

The markets have been wrong for more than a year supporting the artificial 1MB limitation.

I think that creativity and innovation are not born in the markets. Markets don't act, they can't. Humans act.

Markets evaluate, they judge time after time. In the medium and long term, of course, users and adoption is the most important thing.

1
silverjustice•

The DARI is nearly balanced because of the DA. But it is still less on BCH. BTC is more lucrative.

1
timepad•

I like the follow-up quote too (from https://virtualpol.com/BMP_EN.pdf )

Users, through non-mining nodes, have zero power.

Users, through the markets, have a lot of power. It is the greatest power in the medium and long term, which will prevail over all others. But it's not executive. It doesn't act, it reacts. Influences, but indirectly.

The developers propose the rules of consensus, but the ultimate decision is enforced with hashpower ​ . The miners are competitive, they have all the incentive, they totally control the blockchain ​ and they have the most secure voting system that exists.

Therefore, the miners do not have absolute power, but they do have executive power, with the responsibilities that this implies.

6
MalkavianBilbao•

Sure, Bitcoin was designed giving the power to miners as a trustable team, componed by maybe not trustable individuals.

2
bitskoOP•

the solution to the byzantine generals problem means that bitcoin is trustless. trusting the incentives to bind individuals to a set of behaviors.

5
markblundeberg•

Considering that SHA256 miners can trivially switch mining between multiple node implementations, there is no hard connection between code and miners anymore. Code and miners both follow the market:

  • Market sets the value for each incompatible ruleset.
  • Each ruleset has a chain that is secured by a majority of honest miners, or alternatively it is insecure due to being overwhelmed by malicious miners.
  • Mining on an overmined chain is lost opportunity.
  • Code is just code. Miners don't bother to run your code if it doesn't correspond to a ruleset with market value.
2
JavierGonzalezGRedditor for less than 30 days•

there is no hard connection between code and miners anymore.

Open the mind. Empty blocks against minority blockchain. No TX, no market, no split.

https://twitter.com/JavierGonzalez/status/1036996206373863426

1
e7kzfTSU•

Mmm, hash power chooses among code to define Bitcoin, assuming all chains in question are still valid (have followed Nakamoto Consensus throughout their histories).

1
Dumbhandle•

So wrong.

1