r/DnD•
Boolean_Null

3.5 Paladin build help

3rd/3.5 Edition

My experience with D&D has been exclusively with 5e.

This will be my first time with 3.5, I'm going to be playing in a short campaign for 4-6 sessions, I decided I wanted to play a Human Paladin of Heironious, my friend is going to be a Cleric of the same god and my wife is going Halfling Ranger. We're starting at level 6 with 16k starting gold.

​

We rolled for Stats and the way the DM had us roll really pushed the numbers up, 5d6 re roll 1s and 2s add the highest 3 together, I rolled 18,17,16,15,14, 13. I was going to place them as Str 18, Dex 14, Con 16, Int, 13, Wis 15, Cha 17.

​

I'm looking for help in how I should build my guy, it doesn't need to be 100% optimal I think we're working mainly out of the phb/dmg but was told as long as it's 3.0/3.5 then it should be fine.

I'm not sure if we're going to level up at all during this I'm assuming not. The feats I was considering were Weapon Focus Greatsword or Combat Expertise, Power Attack, Cleave, then either Greater Cleave or Improved Trip if I picked up Combat Expertise.

Also what Weapons, Armor, Magic Items should I be looking at? Stuff with Undead bane (we were told we will probably fight some undead but not exclusively) or Keen seemed obvious choices.

​

Smiting in 5e is amazing for extra damage in Paladins but in 3.5 they don't get much in the way of that so not sure if I just swing my stick and that's it or is there more? Any advice or tips are appreciated.

Posted Oct 12, 2018, 11:09 PM UTC

016
Iridos•

I usually pull my paladin inspiration from this build compendium, which has a lot of ways to approach paladin and some really good commentary on things to watch when building. If you want something a little more focused on analysis of the class features, along with a nice list of acfs and substitution levels, check out this handbook.

Personally, I'd be looking at Power Attack, Battle Blessing, and possibly Sacred Healing (depending on your group) or something supporting intimidate use for feats, and consider the Divine Spirit ACF if you want something more useful than your mount. Your stats look good, although I might swap Str and Cha.

Fearsome is a great armor enhancement if you're planning to use intimidate, animated shields are always a legitimate investment, and called is virtually mandatory for any character wearing heavy armor in a longer campaign... yours sounds short enough that it may not be worthwhile, but cutting your armor don time from several minutes to a standard action is awesome. For weapon enhancements, keen isn't great unless you're doing something with crits... probably better to get holy. (Most undead are also evil, which makes holy even more likely to be high value.)

Other gear... belt of battle or magnificence are always high value, armbands of might are really nice for paladins, amulet of retributive healing can be really great as a way to double your lay on hands healing value, and a reliquary holy symbol is a really cheap way to pick up more divine feat fuel. Oh, and the universal recommendation for the Heward's items.

3
Boolean_NullOP•

I was going to leave str and cha mostly because I haven’t taken the stat increase I get at level (4?) so both str and cha will be at 18. But curious if I had to have the 17 in str isn’t having a better to hit better than the increase to cha?

Does fearsome work against the undead? I know undead are immune to more things than they are in 5e like sneak attacks and crits wasn’t sure if they could be panicked or frightened in 3.5?

I’ll take a look at those other items when I’m able, I really appreciate the help.

1
Electric999999Wizard•

Undead have blanket immunity to anything mind affecting, which does include fear.

2
Iridos•

Eh... it's probably a matter of personal preference, but for me, a straight paladin usually isn't a huge damage dealer unless they're doing a specialized build like charging, so I tend to prioritize Con and Cha... tankier in hp, AC, and saves, more healing, more turn attempts, and so on. (Also, while I'm thinking about it, I forgot to mention Divine Shield as a good feat option if you use a shield... turn attempt to get Cha mod bonus to shield's AC for rounds equal to half character level.)

Fearsome is strong because it allows you to demoralize opponent (combat use of Intimidate skill) as a move action. The result of demoralize opponent is a fear state, which is mind-affecting... and unfortunately undead are immune. So indirectly, no, it does not. There are ways around this, most notably the Dread Witch PrC... the 4th level allows you to ignore fear immunities... but I don't think you'll have access to any of them at level 6.

1
Electric999999Wizard•

Core paladin is pretty rubbish, but if you're allowed anything 3.5 then we can make something work.
The Alternate Class Feature: Charging smite (Players handbook II) replaces special mount, it gives you extra damage if you smite on a charge, and also means you don't use up smite if you miss while charging, which helps a bit.

The battle blessing feat (Complete Champion) makes buffing yourself with your spells in combat much more practical.

Power attack is obviously your level 1 feat.

Divine might (complete warrior) can give a bit more damage.

2
Boolean_NullOP•

Yeah core Paladin wasn’t seeming that great but I assumed it was lack of familiarity with the system oh well it should be fun for a short campaign if we play again maybe I’ll just make a straight fighter or something. Thanks for for the suggestions on charging smite and battle blessing those seem very helpful especially BB.

1
DannyAcme•

The problem with the Paladin in 3.5 is that, beyond 5th level, it's severely diminishing returns. All those first five levels skills are juicy, but beyond that he gets outclassed in melee by the Fighter and in divine spellcasting by the Cleric. However, if you multiclass right and/or start dipping into prestige classes, you can make a pretty formidable character with Paladin as the base class. Paladin 5/Cleric 5/Gray Guard 10 is AWESOME.

2
Iridos•

Lol... if you find core paladin underwhelming, you will find core fighter to be mind-blowingly awful. Barbarian's the core melee that's straightforward and decent. Paladin's not bad per se, either... especially with your insane stats, as paladin benefits from boosts to pretty much any stat.

1
DannyAcme•

The main problem with the Fighter is that it's crap if you only use 1st-party stuff. If you get your DM's blessing and dip into a lot of the 3rd-party stuff, you can make a formidable fighter with the right archetype and feats. Of course, then you get the problem of your character sheet turning into a goddamn tome, but what can you do.

1
Clockwork_Sphinx•

If you want to try a Gish, sorcadin is famously popular in 3.5 as a full spellcaster and solid melee, with that stat block, you would do well.

If you want to melee, look up how to optimize power attack and then tone it down for your group.

If you want to try ranged, that gets very tricky due to feat investment.

Martial classes, which paladin falls in, as well as stock gishes, were very poor in 3.5 until almost the end of the game. Tome of Battle could have some fun things for you, with crusader being paladin 2.0 in many ways. Also, cleric/crusader into Ruby Knight vindicator does a lot and is pretty much paladin 3.0

1
Boolean_NullOP•

Yeah I’m starting to realize that they aren’t super great but I’m a little surprised all martials weren’t great until the end seems strange to me

1
DannyAcme•

My suggestion: level up you Paladin to at least 5, get at least one level of Cleric and then take Gray Guard as your prestige class. That is RIDICULOUSLY badass.

1
Boolean_NullOP•

What’s the reason for the one level dip into Cleric?

1
DannyAcme•

Every even-numbered level, the Gray Guard goes up a level in spellcasting from a previous class you've had. You don't get any extra skills, but you do get the spell allotments and stuff. If you dip one level into Cleric, and level up to Gray Guard 10, it means you're casting equivalent to a Cleric 6, which OUTCLASSES THE FUCK out of a Paladin at equivalent level.

If you go nice and square and have a Cleric 5/Paladin 5/Gray Guard 10, you basically have a Paladin with all the standard Paladin skills except Remove Disease and no Paladin's Code restrictions (no need to Attone, AT ALL), who can: -use Lay On Hands to Sicken or directly inflict damage, -can use and has a modifier on Bluff, Intimidate and Disguise, -can Smite WITH NO ALIGNMENT RESTRICTIONS (Yes, Smite EVERYTHING), and... -casts like a Cleric 10.

Yes, Gray Guards FUCKING RULE.

2
Boolean_NullOP•

Well I’m not sure if we’re going to level up at all as this is supposed to be a fairly short campaign. But if we do I just may take your advice I appreciate the response and the enthusiasm.

1
DannyAcme•

Just ONE level in Gray Guard already gives you Sacrament of Trust, which opens the floodgates for what your Paladin is capable of. Lemme explain: Gray Guards are basically a church's special forces. Sacrament of Trust is basically your Paladin taking an oath to not break the Paladin's Code unnecesarily. However, it effectively gives the Paladin permission to do ANYTHING as long as it's not a blatantly evil act and it's in the service of Good, the people and your church. Mechanically, it eliminates the XP cost for an Atonement spell, and allows a Paladin the freedom to get his hands dirty if its justifiable.

Example: Your party has captured an enemy agent and are questioning him for information critical to your quest, but the agent is not budging. Lives are at stake if that information is not obtained. A Gray Guard can punch the shit out of the prisoner's face, Lay On Hands on him to heal him and then punch the shit out of him AGAIN until he's a blubbering mess in a puddle of his own piss and confesses. He broke the code by torturing the guy, so he'll lose his Paladin status, but because it was with the purpose of saving lives, he just needs to have a Cleric cast Atonement for him, with no XP cost for him, and he's back to normal.

Here's the juicy part: once he reaches 10th level, then the Gray Guard earns Sacrament of The True Faith. Once he reaches this level, A GRAY GUARD DOES NOT NEED TO ATONE. As long as any questionable action he commits is in service of Good, the people and his church, it's allowed. Period. Lying? Sure. Intimidating? Yep. Poison use? Knock yourself out. Ganging up on people? Do eet. Sneak attacks? They won't know what hit them.

1