Katabaticgear liteskin 50L or MLD Prophet CF 48L. Which one will you pick and why? (Thru-hike or 7-day trip)
Posted Oct 20, 2018, 4:25 AM UTC
Posted Oct 20, 2018, 4:25 AM UTC
I would get the Katabatic because they deliver quickly. Also because I'm very happy with the Knik I already own. MLD's gear is great but I'm never putting up with their lead times again.
I'm never putting up with their inaccurate lead times again.
FTFY. Me either.
I'm ordering the Knik on my next paycheck!
Nice! I'm really happy with mine.
Prophet for sure between those two, but SWD would be best because you can get all of what the prophet is and more/less depending on what you want. Only thing you can’t get are those plush shoulder straps from MLD. They are amazing.
You don't think they would make them for you? I bet they would (unless you asked already)
I’ve asked. Their shoulder strap and hipbelt system is pretty fixed.
Interesting thanks. For what it's worth I found their straps to be quite comfortable.
me too! But I think MLD is just a TAD more comfy. both super comf.
Get the Katabatic Knik! It's 40L but if you can dial your gear down to all fit in that, that is an amazing pack.
Love this pack! It's relatively (16 oz) heavy in the V40 I chose but super burly. After my last pack ripped the entire side out while scrambling it's really great to have this. Straps are most comfortable of any pack I've used. Came quickly too.
MLD takes forever and I had bad customer service, never again. The straps were not comfortable at all on my bag.
Appreciate you sharing your feedback. There is something special and beautiful about the products from Katabatic. I can't wait to see the Knik and person and put it on.
I'm actually in the market for a new shelter right now and considering an MLD Solomid XL. But you are not the first person I have seen recently complaining about the lead times and dishonest behavior from them.
The fit of the XPac Knik did not work at all for me. The waistbelt is placed far too high and the pockets were a very loose fit with a single 1L Smartwater bottle.
The Prophet appears to be a delightful pack. I always wanted to try one but never pulled the trigger because I assumed it would be too large. I got a great deal on one recently and I find it to be a very reasonable size.
Pack fit is highly individual so you might prefer the Katabatic but I’m really excited about my Prophet. I can’t wait to get some trail miles on it.
Is long-term durability a priority to you?
Is long-term durability a priority to you?
I do worry about the longevity of the two packs I mentioned after reading debates about xpac/LS/DCF. I probably shouldn't have read so much into it.
VX07/21, DCF50 and 150, and LS07 and 21 are plenty durable for on trail hiking. The 150 and 210 variants will get you longer wear. But even the 50 and 70 variants will get you multiple years of on trail work.
Durability in pack fabric isn't typically necessary unless you are going off trail significant amounts, are scrambling a fair amount and using your pack as part of a leverage system, are going into canyons, are using it haul loads in excess of 30 pounds regularly. In those cases the extra durability is needed.
But if you're on trail predominantly, or if you do only minor off trail, or if you get out less than 30 times per year the above fabrics are plenty.
This has been my own experience as well as the general idea shared by pack manufacturers I've talked to.
Thanks for the info and insight on fabrics that helps a lot! :)
The waistbelt is placed far high
I want to be a bit nit-picky about this claim and I hope I don't come off like a jerk. But I've seen a few people talk about the belt.
It's not a belt, it's a strap. A literal strap smaller than the strap on a bicycle helmet.
A huge motivation for me (and others) for getting their weight down this low is so that hip belts/straps aren't needed anymore! #FreeTheHip my friend. The strap on the Knik is removable and should only be used if you need to ratchet your pack down to your body more so that it doesn't move. But otherwise, my base weight for cold weather is 8 pounds, I don't need a hip belt and it's soooooo much more comfortable without one!
Hi. I’m glad it works for you but it didn’t for me. I was trying to offer my firsthand experience and mentioned that pack fit is highly individual.
I go without a hipbelt/waistbelt/bicycle helmet strap/whatever most of the time myself however I like to have just a little weight transfer once I hit 18 or 20# when I’m carrying more food/water/bearcan. I don’t need a big padded waistbelt (or even MLD’s wings) to get a little bit of load transfer.
I probably would have kept the Knik if they sewed the belt on an inch or two lower.
YMMV/HYOH/etc.
Two entirely different packs. Did you want framed or not? Your answer to that will dictate which you should go for.
This point seems to be under appreciated in this thread. Before choosing one of these two packs, one should decide on frame / no frame. Each of these has some serious competition in their class, but they are not exactly competing with one another.
I've tried framed and frameless pack before and with 20 or so lb the difference seems small. Probably why I can't really decide between the two.
If you are always under 20 total then go frameless. Thats a no brained for me.
So one of these is frameless, and rated for 18-22 lb loads, max 25; the other has a framesheet and stay, and a max load of 35 lb. Different beasts! What's your TPW for a thru/7-day?