Bottom of the Barrel. It's a common phrase for something that is crappy. Instead of a bucket, you could find a small barrel as a prop.

I’m planning on starting a new series where I pick a video game out of a bucket and do a review on it w/ live commentary. The gimmic is the games I’ll be picking aren’t necessarily good. Whether it had bad reviews, it’s publicly hated, or it’s blatant at how bad it is. It could be a pc game, or console of any variety. Thanks to anyone who has any ideas!

INAN for my new YT series