An interesting thought exercise
I was reading “Difficult Mothers, Adult Daughters” the other day.
Overall: would not recommend for people with Narc parents. I found a fair amount of it condescending, and the suggestion to not talk to people who validate your anger really grated on me. When your reality has been distorted, you really do need someone outside you to reassure you anger is a healthy response — evidenced by some of the recent posts asking if it’s okay to be angry about horrific violence. When she specifies difficult mothers, Narcs are a caveat and not the main focus. Wait until you’re feeling more at peace with your past before trying to read this one.
The author DID bring up a thought exercise from a different writer, and which I’m going to reduce even further because this was the part that got to me:
Imagine confronting your Narc.
Contemplate all the ways they have hurt you, the ways they have tried to control you, the ways they have accused you of not doing or being enough for them, and all the times you tried to be what they wanted and still somehow came up short.
Imagine saying to them, “Now, I abandon you. I betray you. What you accused me of doing, now I am doing for real.”
I came away with a feeling of relief and calm. Tears, too. But it was nice to have that feeling, for once, of completely validating her guilt tripping. It took all the power out of it, which took away the guilt.
I’m a little annoyed I spent money on this book, but this was one key thing I took away from it, so I’m sharing it in case anyone else can benefit from it, too. It was empowering just thinking about saying, “You know what? You’re right. I am betraying you. I’m leaving you. And I’m not looking back.”
Posted Oct 28, 2018, 7:49 PM UTC
Hmmm...I am not sure how I feel about this. I have been accused several times by nMother and siblings of abandoning her. I don’t feel I abandoned anyone. That word has such a negative connotation; it implies that once again, I am guilty and should be ashamed. She “raised” me at arm’s length or further; was not there for me, was cruel, condescending and completely invalidating. She made sure I didn’t need her, and I don’t. I also don’t want her anywhere near me, or my son. I don’t think of it as abandonment, more of self-preservation and insurance for my mental well-being. As far as my siblings, I quit trying to justify to them years ago. I’m having quite a visceral reaction to this.
Edit: spelling
Interesting! For me, it feels like act of deciding to reject her on my terms instead of being accused of rejecting her to make me meet her terms is weirdly relieving. She can’t use it to hurt me if I made the conscious decision to do it because, this time (even just in my head), I am making the decision with full awareness, not because she’s projecting onto me. If I agree that’s what I’m doing, if I make it my choice and not her accusation, then it really is about me and I can decide where to go with it.
I know what you mean, though, about her ensuring I didn’t need her. She stopped cooking for us when I was twelve. I started doing my own laundry around the same time because she wasn’t reliable about it. There were a lot of things she didn’t teach me, or taught poorly, then got angry when I didn’t do it.
For me, the idea of finally accepting the accusation and owning it is weirdly soothing. She can’t use it against me if I agree it's true — and my unwillingness to communicate with her has absolutely been self-preservational, but because she can’t see that, it's almost like it’s just easier to agree to her terms on what I’m doing. Like... fine. I accept this scapegoating. I will take it and make it work in my favor. I will make the act of self-preserving very much about abandoning you and betraying you, because you still can’t see how that’s what you put me through.
It's not an easy feeling, and it brings up a lot of weird shit, but (for me, at least) confronting that accusation and deciding to make it true feels a lot better than arguing with her in my head about whether or not she’s right.
I guess it’s about whatever makes you feel empowered. At the heart of being RBN is a need to take our power back, or find it if we have not ever had it. I’m glad this helps you, and hopefully others. However we get to healing, our individual journeys all have meaning and importance. I’m happy for you!
Whoops double post 😬