cybrian•

The ones you see on OWC are PCIe. They won’t fit inside your G4. I don’t have a suggestion, but I wanted to make sure you didn’t purchase one of those despite the price.

8
TorazChryx•

It's actually pretty egregious that it suggests them for a Digital Audio G4

Even the first gen PowerMac G5 was still AGP/PCI based.

2
cybrian•

Oh wow, the mobile site didn’t show the breadcrumbs. That’s more than just a little ridiculous.

1
dls2016OP•

Damn, thanks for that info. I trust OWC and didn't double check the suggestions.

3
Dodgson_here•

I wouldn’t worry about trying to get ssds to work. They’re not going to help that much and there isn’t support for TRIM on any version of Mac OS you’re probably going to run on it. I’d either try to find some lightly used IDE drives or pickup an IDE to SATA adapter and get some new drives. What versions of protools and Mac OS will you run?

5
dls2016OP•

Thank you. Can you suggest any adapter models? I am limited to Pro Tools LE 6.4 and OS X 10.3.

1
istarian•

You can probably use one of these:
https://m.newegg.com/products/N82E16812400465

It won't be any faster than the IDE bus can do but you can plug a regular 3.5" sata drive in and have it be seen as IDE. Drive size might be an issue.

You could also try an SD-IDE solution or an IDE/SATA flash dom intended for a thin client. Although you might want to limit that to the OS and use a conventional drive for any user data.

http://lowendmac.com/2010/sata-and-ssd-options-for-g3-and-g4-power-macs/
^ given these comments you might also consider an external FW drive if you have FW800 support and can find an enclosure with SATA support.

If OWC's card options are under $100 going for it might be the best, especially if the machine supports booting from the card. Although the linked options are PCIe cards which your Mac definitely does not support. You need a PCI sata card.

3
dls2016OP•

You're right, you can get a StarTech IDE2SAT2 and new HD for $17 each. Correct me if I'm wrong, but you can't see more than 128GB with an adapter anyway.

2
istarian•

I believe the onboard IDE is the part with the 128GB limit, my G4 quicksilver DP800 has that limit too afaik. I haven't tested it, but I'm guessing the adapter doesn't care about size, but if the drive size was never supported in an IDE configuration then the adapter probably couldn't fix that.

If you need more space getting a second internal drive or an external one might be the way to go.

2
Dodgson_here•

The other thing I forgot to mention, earlier versions of protools highly recommended having it and the os installed on one drive and recording to a second drive. So you’ll probably want a two drive setup. One for the os and applications and the other just for data.

2
Iria2•

While there is no TRIM support in any OS of that age, the firmware garbage collection built into modern SSDs will be more than fine. Even with a bunch of uneven writes, they are capable of much higher I/O rates than a system of this age will ever natively be able to handle. In addition, due to the technology of the time, you will observe much much smaller and far less frequent writes to the disk when compared to modern systems and data use cases, so I honestly wouldn't worry much unless this is about benchmark numbers.

However, if budget is your concern and you have no means of acquiring cheap SSDs, then yeah, you probably do want to find a cheaper solution.

1
foodandart•

Not really. The issue is the PCI. There's a FirmTek/SeriTek 1s/2 on E-Bay.. it might handle an SSD. I have one of these in my G4MDD for my storage drive - haven't tried to install the boot volume on it.

I think for the age of the hardware, it's getting now to the point where a lot of the fiddly bits are going to start to get pricey because they're not so common anymore.

2
dls2016OP•

So maybe give up on the idea of using SSDs?

1
Iria2•

This is the card I use: Sonnet Tempo PCI 2-Port SATA

Here's a pic.

I have tested this card to boot Mac OS 9 on a B+W, a Sawtooth, and an MDD from a Samsung 840 Evo. Mac OS X 10.2 and 10.4 also seem to boot just fine, but I haven't exactly been testing for that.

While I purchased mine on ebay, I don't see any listed there at the moment, but that doesn't mean they won't be.

Good luck on your hunt and let us know what solution you go with!

3
dls2016OP•

Thanks! I think I'm going to keep an eye out for this and/or the Firmtek card. For now I will boot off of IDE (I have a few lying around) and buy a new SATA drive + adapter for data. Along with RAM and a new PRAM battery I think I will be in for only $75.

1
foodandart•

FYI, the SATA card I have in my system is running a 500GB storage drive and even though it's in a MDD now, at one point I had it in a Digital Audio G4 which did have the 128GB drive limit on the internal controller, but the card worked just ducky.

1
speakeasyboy•

I can't recommend Sonnett enough. I used an internal SATA card in my mirror door with a 1TB drive and never had issues. Good luck finding one!

1
pibroch•

Even a base MacBook Air will stomp that machine in Pro Tools anymore. I’d forget about using it as a studio computer altogether, really.

2
dls2016OP•

For sure but the computer and the Digi 001 were paid for many years ago. The system works as-is; I thought maybe I could upgrade RAM and drives for around $100. I have no other options for an 8-track recording setup in the beer-money price range.

3
foodandart•

Awesome! Take you time and the parts you need will show up eventually..

1
j0nxed•

the good news: MacBook Air's should be under $150 in ten years from now.

1
SIN3R6Y•

Have you considered parallel scsi? I have an ATTO scsi card in my G4 Quicksilver and two 300GB U320 scsi drives. You can get SCA drives for next to nothing and pick up some 68 pin converters

2
j0nxed•

i second the use of SCA (80 pin) and SCSI-2 (68 pin) drives. ..unless you don't noise: 10K and 15K RPM drives are often too noisy for comfort. the drives are cheap/reliable and the adapters are as well.

1
leadacid44•

As others have said, your options are somewhat limited. To run a SATA drive you've got two options - first a IDE-to-SATA converter module thingy, or two, a PCI-to-SATA card. I'd suggest you check out this website for more details:

http://lowendmac.com/2010/sata-and-ssd-options-for-g3-and-g4-power-macs/

The IDE-to-SATA converter might be the better option, as they're available new now and the system would boot and operate just like before. The PCI card might be technically better, but I don't know how easily available those SATA cards are anymore. Those Sonnet cards are excellent though, if you can find one for a reasonable price. eBay prices seem to be quite high. I would suspect that there are comparable cards too, but one of my concerns would be compatibility with whichever MacOS you choose to allow it to boot from SATA.

You might be able to use an IDE-to-SATA adapter like this one here:

https://www.amazon.com/Female-SATA-Adapter-Converter-bidirectional/dp/B001PYSAJI

Some musing from the 68kmla forum indicate that some PCI SATA cards based on the SIL3112 chipset, as well as some ACARD models may work. Exact models and availability may be a big issue these days though.

https://68kmla.org/forums/index.php?/topic/31402-beige-g3-pci-sata-is-it-an-option/

As for SSDs, I'm not sure how long-lived a SSD would run in a non-TRIM supported env, however I've certainly run Windows XP on SSDs and those worked for years. And of course there are people out there running CF cards in IDE slots that have no idea of TRIM at all without any trouble at all. Your mileage may vary depending on your use case, so they still might make sense.

1
vaginaisforlovers•

If you're running 10.2 or later, this should work for you.

1
j0nxed•

those are debadged Syba SATA cards sold for twice as much as the badged ones. but it's probably still good and comes with the reassuring info (listing).

1