Essay I wrote on Kendrick Lamar for Freshman Writing

here's the essay. what do you guys think?

​

To Change A Mind

In 2015, my music taste was rather unsavory–my palate was attuned to formulaic pop hits on the radio with a slight predilection for alternative rock. My music taste reflected my \sanitary upbringing and general my world view; I grew up in a well-off suburb of Boston, isolated from poverty, hardship, and social decay. While I would not have been considered naive, I had nevertheless unconsciously developed a view of America as a forward-progressing nation. America, I believed, was built on riches of stolen land and slavery, and after centuries of active resistance and moral courage, the nation fought a civil war and engaged in mass protests to bring its black underclass to a position of equality. I was sympathetic to the view that in 2015 Americans had ushered in an era of post-racialism by electing a black president, righting the wrongs of their ancestors. Race no longer mattered; if you were not successful in this nation, it must be a result of laziness or moral depravity.

This facile and somewhat ahistorical worldview was reflected in my narrow music taste, but most notably in my dislike for the music of the underclass–black or white–in hip-hop. My exposure to hip-hop music was limited, consisting of the few rap songs that charted each year: old Eminem songs, and my friends’ predominantly rap playlists. From my view, hip-hop indulged in hedonistic tendencies, glorifying drugs, money, women, violence, and materialism. Gun toting and chain-donning rappers could not add insights into human nature, recount any experience pertinent to my life, and as a result could not create quality music. My entire perception of hip-hop and America was fundamentally altered when I was introduced to Kendrick Lamar’s To Pimp A Butterfly, an album which, in vinyl form, now hangs above my bed, as a tribute to its political message, lyrical dexterity, and its role in changing in my politics, perception, and understanding of black culture.

At a glance, To Pimp A Butterfly is a dense, complex, jazz-infused hip-hop album which features long form poetry, political messaging, macho-boasting, and complex metaphors. When I listened to the album, I was acutely aware that I was listening to the work of a true artist, with much of the album going over my head. Lamar’s hard-work and dedication was recognized at the 2015 Grammy Awards, where he was was nominated for eleven categories, one short of Michael Jackson’s all time high of twelve, and more recently when he won the 2018 Pulitzer Prize in music. To Pimp A Butterfly is, at its core, a story detailing Lamar’s rise through the music industry from a talented black teenager in Compton to worldwide rap star, and how his outlook on life was upended after visiting South Africa and engaging with his ancestry. Lamar recounted: “I’m not on the inside looking out. I’m in the dead fucking center, looking around… I’m not the next pop star. I’m not the next socially aware rapper. I am a human motherfucking being over dope-ass instrumentation” (Nielsen 16). The album is brutally honest, as it deals with his depression and insecurities, lusts and youthful urges, and the layers of institutionalism which trap black youth, both psychologically and structurally.

The first track, “Wesley’s Theory” introduces characters played by Kendrick Lamar in different voices which feature recurrently throughout the album. A youthful Lamar, born in poverty and gang violence, recounts on what he wants to do as soon as he makes it in the rap industry, or “get signed”

When I get signed homie I’ma buy a strap

Straight from the CIA, sit it on my lap

Take a few M16s to the hood

Pass ‘em all out on the block, what’s good? (Lamar, “Wesley’s Theory”)

Lamar’s impulse to burn all his money on guns, builds off the stereotype of rappers deeply ingrained in his mind. He does, however, remind the listener of CIA’s involvement in the crack epidemic, infusing guns into urban communities and impressing this stereotype into the minds of young black men (Nielsen 79). The character of Uncle Sam, which later in the album is known as Lucy/Lucifer as an allusion to the devil, entices Lamar to indulge in materialism:

What you want you? A house or a car?

Forty acres and a mule, a piano, a guitar?. . .

So you better cop everything two times

Two coupes, two chains, two c-notes (Lamar, “For Free?”)

The verse begins with Uncle Sam’s traditional temptations into material culture, but continues by comparing this with “forty acres and a mule,” a reference to Union General WIlliam T. Sherman’s proposal to provide recently freed slaves with “forty acres and a mule” following the civil war. (Nielsen 80) Uncle Sam, according to Lamar, is luring young rappers into pursuing materialism, in the same way he did centuries ago. In his view the legacy of slavery lives on; not much has changed. “Wesley’s Theory” builds the central metaphor of the album: how successful black artists are “pimped” to benefit of the entertainment industry and Uncle Sam.

Lamar responds to the lurings of Uncle Sam in “For Free?” with a vulgar repeated chorus “this dick ain’t free,” in essence sticking it to the man.

Livin’ in captivity raised by cap salary

Celery, tellin’ green is all Ii need

Evidently all I seen was Spam and raw Sardines. . .

“I need forty acres and a mule

Not forty ounce and a pit bull . . .

“Oh America, you bad bitch, I picked cotton and made you rich/

Now my dick ain’t free (Lamar, “For Free?”)

Lamar compares his upbringing in Compton to being raised in captivity, where his salary is effectively capped by the lack of job prospects and he is left eating cheap canned food, but continually is seduced by the lure of “green” or money. Instead of a fresh start in self-determination, offered in “forty acres and a mule,” Lamar is captured by drugs and violence, evidenced in “forty ounce” and a “pit bull.” His ancestors built the cotton riches of the America and now he is being “pimped” in the entertainment industry. “This dick ain’t free” is a phrase of resistance, saying in a purposefully masculine manor that he will no longer be used for others’ benefit. Moreover, it is a reference to slavery: “unlike enslaved blacks, Lamar’s dick isn’t free for the slave owners to do whatever they want with it, including breeding him so the population increases” (Nielsen 16).

“Institutionalized,” one of the more politically charged tracks on the record, exposes the level of psychological entrapment which results from institutional racism. Lamar explores the corrosive effects of wealth and the “getting rich” have on himself and his friends. The track begins with Lamar admitting that although his newfound music success has provided him the money to leave the “hood,” it is the only world he knows and is trapped.

What money got to do with it

When I don’t know the full definition of a rap image?

I’m trapped inside the ghetto and I ain’t proud to admit it

Institutionalized, I keep running back for a visit” (Lamar, “Institutionalized”)

Lamar then hypothesizes that if he were president the first thing he would do is “pay [his] mama’s rent” and “bulletproof [his] Chevy doors.” He is fundamentally unequipped to deal with with a world of luxury and stability, and stardom cannot erode the years of psychological scarring of life on the streets. His friends, whom Lamar brings to the BET awards, do not fare any better. Surroundeding by the extravagant wealth of “private jets and passport, presidential glass floor,” his friends think about stealing jewelry, as their hustler impulses are activated. Growing up poor, the obscene level of wealth deeply bothers Lamar and is friends who are “looking at artistses like they’re harvestses.” (Lamar, “Institutionalized”) Lamar presumably pronounces artist and harvest incorrectly to allude to Gollum’s manner of speaking in Lord of the Rings, adding the additional “es.” Gollum’s sole purpose is to capture the ring and pursue power, thematically equivalent to Lamar and his drive for wealth, which he admits eats at his soul.

While Lamar’s album is politically charged and thematically dense, he does not refrain from the macho-boasting central to the roots of hip-hop built in competitive battle rap. In the track “King Kunta,” Lamar declares himself king of the rap game and in “Hood Politics” he revisits his time as a gang member, proving that he can accomplish anything he wants. Even “King Kunta,” an upbeat, funky sounding track more suitable to mass consumption, has a layered political message. In the novel Roots: The Saga of an American Family, Kunta Kinte was a runaway slave whose foot was cut off for leaving the plantation. Lamar raps

Bitch where you when I was walking?

Now I run the game got the whole world talkin’, King Kunta

Everybody wanna cut the legs off him, Kunta

Black man taking no losses. (Lamar, “King Kunta”)

Lamar creates the conflict between “king” and “slave” which both describe his position in American society. He declares himself the “king” of the rap game, but is still oppressed like a “slave.”

The album is entrenched in black vernacular, initially alien to my me, with references to words I didn’t know and a slew of what I perceived as grammatical errors. Many of the tendencies of generally black (but there is a lot of overlap) lower class English are catalogued in Eminem’s discography:

[Dropped s] “Everybody want to run”…

“They” for “their”; for example: “they kids”. . .

“Ain’t” used for “didn’t”; for example: “I ain’t have to graduate”. . .

Double-negatives with verbs; for example: “nobody couldn’t see.” (Flynn 73)

When I first began listening to hip-hop, I found these grammatically incorrect uses of language to be jarring and cheapening the quality of music.. However, as I listened to more and more hip-hop, my mind acclimated to the styles and tendencies of the lower classes, and I stopped noticing the errors. I realized that what I believed to be “correct” grammar, simply conformed to my own manner of speaking. It just happened that as a upper-middle class American, my manner of speaking was codified in the Merriam Webster Dictionary. The poor and disenfranchised have no representation among the stewards of language, and thus their speaking is deemed “incorrect.” With newfound insight, I shed the linguistic elitism which had clouded my judgement and delved deeper into Lamar’s album.

While the first half of To Pimp a Butterfly describes Lamar’s impulses, drives, and entrapments, the second half features an enlightened Lamar who has returned from a trip to South Africa, who has rediscovered his ancestry and has knowledge to disseminate to his Compton friends, and by extension the world. The dual tracks “Complexion” and “The Blacker the Berry” directly address race in America with conflicting themes. “Complexion” spreads a message of peace, love, and positivity, preaching that the color of your skin color “don’t mean a thing. . . [and we should] let the Willie Lynch Theory reverse a million times…” (Lamar, “Complexion (A Zulu Love). The Willie Lynch Theory refers to a speech by Mr. William Lynch, a slave owner, who developed a theory to conquer slaves and reduce insurrections by pitting slaves against one another on the basis of color; hHis theory is a reformulation of the old adage “divide and conquer.” He writes, “You must use the DARK skin slaves vs. the LIGHT skin slaves, and the LIGHT skin slaves vs. the DARK skin slaves” (“Willie Lynch Letter”). While “Complexion” is an appeal to remove the racial lens from our perception of human beings, “The Blacker the Berry” points out the obvious hypocrisy of Lamar’s position on race. The third verse begins with Lamar extolling his racial pride:

“I’m African-American, I’m African

I’m black as the heart of a fuckin’ Aryan

I’m back as the name of Tyrone and Darius” (Lamar, “The Blacker the Berry”)

The song continues with Lamar revealing how he engages in stereotypically black activities

Or eat watermelon, chicken, and Kool-Aid on weekdays

Or jump high enough to get Michael Jordan endorsements

Or watch BET cause urban support is important (Lamar, “The Blacker the Berry”)

The ending of the song reveses the entire message of pride to that of hypocrisy:

So why did I weep when Trayvon Martin was in the street

When gang banging make me kill a nigga blacker than me?

Hypocrite! (Lamar, “The Blacker the Berry”)

In essence, Lamar admits he has fallen for the same pitfalls that he blames white America for. He admits to killing, an admission he has made multiple times in previous albums, so how can he criticize police officers for shooting Trayvon. He also mentions the idea of “blacker,” revealing that he has accepted a hierarchy of color, with black at the bottom and shades of blackness progressing to whiteness at the top, fully contradicting the message of the previous track “Complexion.” These two tracks together are quintessential Kendrick Lamar, as he truthfully the the internal conflict and hypocrisy of race in America. He does not pull punches or make excuses for his beliefs; he is in the “dead fucking center” (Nielsen 16).

Pre-To Pimp A Butterfly, I viewed hip-hop as a monolithic entity; I could barely note the content distinction between Kendrick Lamar and Eminem, Gangsta Rap and Conscious Rap, or East Coast and West Coast styles. However, exposure to such a critically acclaimed, sonically beautiful, and politically charged album shattered my preconceptions. As I gained interest in hip-hop I noticed diversity within the genre that had eluded me initially. My reaction to hip-hop can be generalized to life. Nothing is monolithic, the subtleties that exist are masked by ignorance. Often, lack of exposure to a group of people or set of traditions can cause people to decry a group as a monolithic, rather than seeing each person as an individual. The most compelling feature of Kendrick Lamar is that he does not cater to the interests of the industry: he does not glorify sex, drugs, and money. Instead he raps honestly about his impulses, describing how certain substances and his environment have affected his world view. To Pimp A Butterfly directly addressed my own reservations about hip-hop’s materialistic culture, with the character of Uncle Sam. Lamar’s journey from an institutionalized Compton rapper to an enlightened conscious storyteller mirrored my own; my upbringing precluded me from appreciating and respecting hip-hop as music. To look at the culture of the underclass as a reflection of moral depravity was ignorant at best and racist at worst; it is a reflection of material depravity, a point many people on the right side of the political spectrum still fail to understand. DAMN., Lamar’s successive album directly addresses this belief that culture is the source of black poverty, quoting a Fox “News” reporter: “This is why I say that hip hop has done more damage . tTo young African Americans than racism in recent years” (Lamar, “DNA”), a point which infuriates Lamar. It was only through long-form album length musical stories that I understood the layers which institutionalized individuals into certain patterns of behavior, and could understand black culture from a different vantage point.

From skeptic to enthusiast, I learned to love hip-hop in its full form, appreciating the lyrics, language, storytelling, and messaging, and its ability question power structures and rebel. With its unapologetically black imagery and sound, its instrumental role in altering my flawed perception, and developing a passion for rap, the album hangs above my bed. Decades from now, I imagine buying a record player and putting placing the vinyl in place to sit and back and hear the faint build up of “Every Nigger is a Star” (Lamar, “Wesley’s Theory”) in the first track and appreciate the genius and power of Kendrick Lamar.

Works Cited

Flynn, Darin. “The Black Vernacular Versus a Cracker's Knack for Verses.” Eminem and Rap, Poetry, Race: Essays, by Scott F. Parker, Mcfarland, 2014, pp. 65–88.

Lamar, Kendrick. “The Blacker The Berry.” To Pimp A Butterfly, Top Dawg Entertainment, 2015. Spotify, spotify:track:5Mtt6tZSZA9cXTHGSGpyh0.

Lamar, Kendrick. “Complexion(A Zulu Love).” To Pimp A Butterfly, Top Dawg Entertainment, 2015. Spotify, spotify:track:72hFOhhhnOJZnnp6uVOgPn.

Lamar, Kendrick. “DNA.” DAMN, Top Dawg Entertainment, 2017. Spotify, spotify:track:6HZILIRieu8S0iqY8kIKhj.

Lamar, Kendrick. “For Free?.” To Pimp A Butterfly, Top Dawg Entertainment, 2015. Spotify, spotify:track:75izAeHlGuOgA865CFDyIv.

Lamar, Kendrick. “Institutionalized.” To Pimp A Butterfly, Top Dawg Entertainment, 2015. Spotify, spotify:track:4oFtLSgHyZPNYDCcANhTnO.

Lamar, Kendrick. “King Kunta.” To Pimp A Butterfly, Top Dawg Entertainment, 2015. Spotify, spotify:track:0N3W5peJUQtI4eyR6GJT5O.

Lamar, Kendrick. “Wesley’s Theory.” To Pimp A Butterfly, Top Dawg Entertainment, 2015. Spotify, spotify:track:7Ks4VCY1wFebnOdJrM13t6.

Nielsen, Jack J. The Afrofuturism Cyclicality of Past, Present, and Future in Kendrick Lamar's To Pimp a Butterfly. 2018.

“Willie Lynch Letter: The Making of a Slave.” The Final Call, 22 May 2009, www.finalcall.com/artman/publish/Perspectives\_1/Willie\_Lynch\_letter\_The\_Making\_of\_a\_Slave.shtml.

Posted Nov 6, 2018, 7:46 PM UTC

437
Loading comments…