For a big black hole, hawking radiation is not intense at all for a far away observer. Say we have one far away observer, and one observer sufficiently close to the black hole that dτ/dt = 0.01. Suppose the far away observer measures that in one second, the black hole emits n particles of Hawking radiation with average energy E. Now should the close observer do a measurement of the same kind, he would find that in one second the black hole emits n / (dτ/dt) = 100 n particles with an average energy of 100 E, right?
Now according to the Schwarzschild metric, dτ/dt --> 0 as r --> 2GM/c^2. So at some point before the falling observer reaches the event horizon, the intensity of Hawking radiation becomes arbitrarily large in the reference frame of the infalling observer?
In general relativity Kruskal–Szekeres coordinates, named after Martin Kruskal and George Szekeres, are a coordinate system for the Schwarzschild geometry for a black hole. These coordinates have the advantage that they cover the entire spacetime manifold of the maximally extended Schwarzschild solution and are well-behaved everywhere outside the physical singularity.
The event horizon in Schwerzschild coordinates is just a coordinate singularity without physical or invariant meaning.
Use the maximally extended spacetime in Kruskal–Szekeres coordinates and you will have no such problem.
I know this, but doesn't the schwarzschild solution assume a time independent field, whereas if the black hole evaporates, it is changing? I.e. classical GR doesn't take into account QFT effects?
[deleted]
For a big black hole, hawking radiation is not intense at all for a far away observer. Say we have one far away observer, and one observer sufficiently close to the black hole that dτ/dt = 0.01. Suppose the far away observer measures that in one second, the black hole emits n particles of Hawking radiation with average energy E. Now should the close observer do a measurement of the same kind, he would find that in one second the black hole emits n / (dτ/dt) = 100 n particles with an average energy of 100 E, right?
Now according to the Schwarzschild metric, dτ/dt --> 0 as r --> 2GM/c^2. So at some point before the falling observer reaches the event horizon, the intensity of Hawking radiation becomes arbitrarily large in the reference frame of the infalling observer?
[deleted]
Kruskal–Szekeres coordinates
In general relativity Kruskal–Szekeres coordinates, named after Martin Kruskal and George Szekeres, are a coordinate system for the Schwarzschild geometry for a black hole. These coordinates have the advantage that they cover the entire spacetime manifold of the maximally extended Schwarzschild solution and are well-behaved everywhere outside the physical singularity.
^[ ^PM ^| ^Exclude ^me ^| ^Exclude ^from ^subreddit ^| ^FAQ ^/ ^Information ^| ^Source ^] ^Downvote ^to ^remove ^| ^v0.28
I know this, but doesn't the schwarzschild solution assume a time independent field, whereas if the black hole evaporates, it is changing? I.e. classical GR doesn't take into account QFT effects?
[deleted]