r/Physics•
Neil1815

[Question] black holes, infinite time and Hawking radiation

Question

[removed]

Posted Nov 7, 2018, 3:52 PM UTC

123
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
Neil1815OP•

For a big black hole, hawking radiation is not intense at all for a far away observer. Say we have one far away observer, and one observer sufficiently close to the black hole that dτ/dt = 0.01. Suppose the far away observer measures that in one second, the black hole emits n particles of Hawking radiation with average energy E. Now should the close observer do a measurement of the same kind, he would find that in one second the black hole emits n / (dτ/dt) = 100 n particles with an average energy of 100 E, right?

Now according to the Schwarzschild metric, dτ/dt --> 0 as r --> 2GM/c^2. So at some point before the falling observer reaches the event horizon, the intensity of Hawking radiation becomes arbitrarily large in the reference frame of the infalling observer?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
WikiTextBot•

Kruskal–Szekeres coordinates

In general relativity Kruskal–Szekeres coordinates, named after Martin Kruskal and George Szekeres, are a coordinate system for the Schwarzschild geometry for a black hole. These coordinates have the advantage that they cover the entire spacetime manifold of the maximally extended Schwarzschild solution and are well-behaved everywhere outside the physical singularity.


^[ ^PM ^| ^Exclude ^me ^| ^Exclude ^from ^subreddit ^| ^FAQ ^/ ^Information ^| ^Source ^] ^Downvote ^to ^remove ^| ^v0.28

1
Neil1815OP•

The event horizon in Schwerzschild coordinates is just a coordinate singularity without physical or invariant meaning.

Use the maximally extended spacetime in Kruskal–Szekeres coordinates and you will have no such problem.

I know this, but doesn't the schwarzschild solution assume a time independent field, whereas if the black hole evaporates, it is changing? I.e. classical GR doesn't take into account QFT effects?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2