r/FanFiction•
ootcs

Do you use a beta for your explicit fic?

That is to say, of course, smut. I've been using beta readers more frequently recently, but I can't bring myself to ask someone to go over my written porn and tell me that this word should be another word, or that a certain sentence is awkward or whatever. Anyone manage to get over that embarrassment?

Posted Nov 8, 2018, 4:25 PM UTC

1218
SilentJoSilentJo on AO3 & FFN•

I've had my husband beta for a couple of my smutty fics. I don't get too embarrassed when it's him reading it for some reason. I like his reactions since my latest stuff has been slash/yaoi. I get a few eye rolls from him but he's fairly professional when he gets in beta/edit mode.

9
a_karma_sardineIt's not easy having a good time•

Sounds like a good guy. :)

5
SilentJoSilentJo on AO3 & FFN•

Yeah, he is. Although I am slightly hesitant to have him edit my first omegaverse story, lol.

3
deathbyhumidity•

Why are you embarrassed, though? I mean I guess it can be awkward because sex, but do you feel less vulnerable opening up your non-smut stuff for a beta? Or is it because you know these people IRL? Also, when you asked them in the beginning to beta for you, did you know that you would be writing smut at that point? Sorry, lots of questions, but I'm just genuinely curious!

Edit: Forgot to answer your question. Never had any of my stuff beta-ed, smut or otherwise.

7
ootcsOPI'm not obsessed, you're obsessed•

No, I don't know any of my betas in real life, I just feel like it's awkward to into an in-depth discussion with someone over what the exact most arousing wording is for genitals in a certain context. No?

2
deathbyhumidity•

I don't think I'd feel particularly awkward being either the beta or the writer in that specific case (as in with the wording, etc.). If anything, my hesitation would be more from the narrative impact rather than the details--and that's not specific to smut, just my hesitation to get beta-ed at all. Hmm, maybe you could ask them if they'd be okay with it, and if they are, maybe you'd feel less awkward too?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
HeadmistressNatsurPlot? What Plot?•

I write exclusively smut, and have bounced ideas off of a few people regarding characterization and plot - what little there is - but I have yet to share full stories with people to beta.

For me, it's not a sense of embarrassment that holds me back. It's that it can already be exhausting to find a beta who is cool with your fandom, plot, offers up useful suggestions, and doesn't ghost. To add on top of that finding someone who is cool with every weird kink and fetish I throw into my stories? I'm sure that person is out there somewhere, but I'd never have time to write if I tried to search for them.

On the flip side, if you need someone to exclusively go over your smut and beta it, I'd be happy to help.

5
musicmage4114•

I don't know if we have any fandoms in common, but I would be more than happy to beta any kink you can throw at me. As someone who also has kinks that tend to be considered "out there", I totally get where you're coming from, so I'd be delighted to help!

3
HeadmistressNatsurPlot? What Plot?•

Awesome! I'll send you a message soon.

1
musicmage4114•

Sweet! I’m looking forward to it!

2
raunchyandpaunchysmut peddler•

I have three! I was explicit (heh) with what my fic was about (eg porn with very little plot) when I sought them out, and to my delight, they were still up for it. Bear this in mind - if betas are offering to beta smut, they know what the content is. It’s not going to be awkward or giggly for them. I know it might be a hard thing to get over, but there’s no need to feel embarrassed about it.

Side note: I write smut that would make a sailor blush, so if you’re looking for a beta, I’m happy to help.

5
AllHarlowsEvexoHarlow on AO3•

I write high kink incest half the time, so... it's not a big deal to me, lol.

I beta all my best friend's work, typically, and she writes a lot of dubcon wincest angst, so... yeah. It's not a huge deal to me, but I also subscribe to the mindset of "If you can't talk about sex, you shouldn't be doing it."

4
a_karma_sardineIt's not easy having a good time•

Sure, as I only write slash. Just be upfront when you first ask for help. Then you're guaranteed she'll be up for it.

Someone IS going to read it when you post it anyway, it's not all that different (but remember to tag and warn, to make it fun for everybody).

3

Yes, I have a beta reader for my Explicit fic. We both gush over the character in question and I feel it makes it easier.

Also, I came to realize that if I felt embarrassed writing and sharing smut, I wasn't mature enough to be writing it. From there I can detach myself from the contents of what I'm writing and do it more objectively.

Now I have no problem writing and posting naughty stuff, lol.

3
hellxxfirewedgetail on FFN/AO3•

It depends on the beta really. I have never used betas for fanfic, but I have encountered similar issues with original works. Two critique partners I had no concerns about and just sent the chapter over. The third I gave a warning about the content and a chance to opt out of reading this section. She was a more conservative person, who couldn't stand seeing a swear word, so I didn't think she would appreciate the flashback to my MC having sex with a stranger in a nightclub bathroom.

One other thing to be wary of - is your beta over 18? I'd cringe at sharing explicit material with a minor

2
greenaleydis•

I’ve just warned the beta before I send the chapter to make sure they are comfortable editing smut.

Writing smutty scenes for me is already such an intense process of overcoming embarrassment or nervousness with the piece, that by the time I’m ready to share it I feel like I’ve expended all that nervous energy.

1
Antaste•

I don't find that embarrassing at all 🤷. Like, my current WIP is a very explicit fic with lots of different kinks and fetishes and I have four different betas. To me smut scenes are no different than 'normal' scenes.

1
musing_amusesariaadagio on Ao3/FFN•

Look at it like this. Would you rather a beta privately tell you how to fix those scenes, or would you rather have untold numbers of readers read the mistakes the beta would have caught? I choose the former.

1