Explanation for Vettel's reprimand and fine

Posted Nov 10, 2018, 9:01 PM UTC

Posted Nov 10, 2018, 9:01 PM UTC
The rules are:
29.1 a) After any free practice session or during the qualifying practice session cars will be weighed as follows:
i) When signalled to do so the driver will proceed directly to the FIA garage and stop his engine. A reprimand will be imposed on any driver who fails to stop when signalled to do so, provided the car is then brought back to the FIA garage without delay and that the FIA technical delegate is satisfied the car has been brought back in exactly the same condition it was in when it was driven into the pits. Any driver who fails to stop when asked to do so, and then fails to bring the car back to the FIA garage, or if work is carried out on the car before it is returned to the FIA garage, will be required to start the race from the pit lane.
If FIA wants to be really strict about, they should change the rule to be more specific on when to turn off the car and have to mention that you cant drive off the scale on your own.
Doesnt said that in the rules now, so i dont see anything VET did that breaks the rule really. The hurry up was the heat of the moment, everyone knows that.
So the only requirement is to get weighed.
How many 'heat of the moment' tantrums are we going to let this guy have just because he's a 4-time champion?
Yeah, I bet every other competitive driver on the grid would not only calmly do what they're told, but also go for a drink when they shut down their engine because what's the rush, it's not like rain was possibly a few seconds away at that point.
Yes but the officials showed no sense of urgency at all they, weren't even ready at an arguably crucial point in the quali session I believe Seb Was quire justifiably hurrying them up. The fine is acceptable but they need to sort this weighing lark out; have the officials behave like a pit crew and have the bloody scales bolted down.
were i a weighing-guy, i'm not sure i'd be in too much of a hurry if the driver almost ran one of the guys down either.
If they were ready to receive the car by showing some intent or as I said a sense of urgency Seb wouldn't have been so wound up. Watching live it was very frustrating, timing was crucial throughout qualifying due to the weather conditions and traffic... Seb's a hot head yes but the officials were going on like it's free practice
They were ready for him to stop in front of the cone, not run over it. From there on they were probably extra careful not to be run over like the cone.
Edit: he started driving towards the official with the "brakes on" sign picking up the cone shouting "go away go away" so he did not follow instructions
They can’t touch the car if the ERS light is red. Which it was until after he drove himself onto the scales. It’s all his own fault.
On the other hand, they were waiting for him to turn his engine off so they could start their procedure. From the on-board it looks like nothing is happening but there was a guy standing by the orange cone ready to move it before he hit it and from the spectator video you can see that there were guys at the rear of the car ready to push it onto the scales. While you can certainly understand the frustration, it's entirely possible that it all would have happened faster if he had followed the regular procedure than with all the gesticulation.
[deleted]
So does Vettel know the written letter and saved himself from a stricter punishment consciously while living on the edge, or did he get lucky?
Yup, that cleared it up. For the future, the weighbridge scales should be linked and/or connected to a plate to prevent such moronic decision: even if the procedure is to push on and off, one would assume that in case of miscommunication, misunderstandement or Vettel, they should be able to stay in place. There is might engine on top of those, just the electric power alone is enough to cause problems. But even then, i do agree that the engine has to be off before and the officials need to push the car. Unless they can make the scales flush to track, then they can drive to and out.
For the current system, this procedure makes sense and is the only one that works.
after reading this and watching it again i do fined some issues.firstly i fined it odd that a driver has to do this in a session when time is very limited( i think it might be because they don't want teams to be doing illegal stuff in that session, not entirely sure). along with some other issues of course but they are very minor
i think overall the weighbridge procedure would benefit with further development. aside that the was sebs fault 100%
Because teams will probably try to cheat and run an underweight car. They need to streamline the weighing process so it takes only a few seconds, none of this stop here and we push BS.
Pull up to a plate, switch off engine, takes 5 seconds for a reading, drive off.
Random weighing has been part of the sport for a very long time.
Yeah ik but i just think it needs abit of a update evident from today as it can mess with the teams stratagy when it comes to changeble conditions
If F1 teams had demonstrated the ability to not cheat it wouldn't be needed. Until then, random checks.
These cars represent billions of dollars in R&D. I don't give a fuck about your scales FIA. Build better ones.
Be able to weigh 200Kg with a tolerance less then 0.00001Kg and be robust is outside what scales can do. It's just easier to have a convoluted weighing system.
Why are we still discussing this and not the fact that Hamilton nearly killed a man?
bruh
duh... have some chill
yes we need investigation and therefore a penalty
Because he didn't lol
How about when seb used his car as a weapon?
Second person this evening I've seen use the word weapon. Don't you think it's a gross exaggeration?
He got a penalty for it didn't he?
Vettel is very lucky here. He almost hit a FIA official on purpose with his reckless behavior. A DSQ would have been a good signal.
Hereby you have been DSQ‘d from this sub
They can also ban him forever from the F1. No, sorry, I’m a stupid. They should ban him from the earth, from tomorrow he can live only on the ISS.
I think he knows his big his car is Sir that he wouldn't hit anyone when going 5kmph.
Don't act like a child lmao. Have you never driven a car? 'Almost hit an official' yeah right man, he literally crawled up the scale. All he did was force the dude to gtfo of his way.
I agree.
Clear and sensible imo, I like it. Thanks for posting.
"you broke our expensive weight sensors - give us money to replace them."