Can I shadow ban someone from a sub?
is it possible for me to shadow ban someone on my subreddit? I've been wondering for a while. Thanks in advance.
Posted Nov 15, 2018, 2:43 AM UTC
is it possible for me to shadow ban someone on my subreddit? I've been wondering for a while. Thanks in advance.
Posted Nov 15, 2018, 2:43 AM UTC
You can, but generally not recommended by the Admins.
I would only do this for a troll that you have solid evidence of repeat ban evasion, not a ‘normal’ user that breaks a rule or two.
There was quite the drama a few years ago when large subs were encouraged to change automod ‘shadow bans’ into normal bans. So I wouldn’t recommend this as general policy.
Mod guidelines:
Secret Guidelines aren’t fair to your users—transparency is important to the platform.
Healthy communities allow for appropriate discussion (and appeal) of moderator actions. Appeals to your actions should be taken seriously. Moderator responses to appeals by their users should be consistent, germane to the issue raised and work through education, not punishment.
The Admins don’t even do it themselves for humans anymore:
https://www.google.com/amp/s/techcrunch.com/2015/11/11/reddit-account-suspensions/amp/
Reddit has replaced shadowbans, which made posts from users who broke the site’s rules invisible, with account suspensions. The community, which had 202 million unique visitors last month, implemented shadowbans to hide spam quickly, but the system was frustrating for individuals since they often had no idea if they had been shadowbanned
Admin absolutely still shadowbans actual people. Since theres no explanation given to mods or to the user about why they have been shadowbanned you have to use your own discretion to decide if you want them to post. Adding them to an "always approve" list in automod does the trick
Accidentally sure, but generally once they become aware it is a human they reverse.
I alert the user (if they are acting like a normal user) and they can ask the Admins.
It is very easy as a mod to tell the difference between human and bot spammer / spam rings.
I wouldn’t auto approve as 75-90% or so is true spam.
I've seen them reverse once, and can think of at least 2 users where they didn't reverse. Out of over 400k subscribers we have one shadowbanned user being auto approved, so certainly not a huge amount but admin still does shadowban humans instead of banning.
Given they say they don’t I don’t know what to tell you - our sub has had good experiences.
Message them and inform them that the user appears to be a human and not a bot. Most shadowbans are done via an auto-detection algorithm.
Also be sure to tell the user they are shadow-banned (if they don't already know, of course).
transparency is important to the platform.
Lol and yet the admins and their default mod buddies are never transparent about themselves. Although they aren't really as secretive about covering up the fact that they moderate and censor based on their personal preferences as they used to be ever since the banout, they still circlejerk together in private chats about what kinds of excuses they should make to ban a subreddit or user they dislike.
Aside from the short rant, I'd recommend only doing shadowbans for obvious spam bot accounts. Real users deserve to know about their ban. I suspect I'm shadowbanned from r/gifs because a moderator didn't like one of the posts I made there, and they were too ashamed to admit that they banned me for posting something they didn't personally like, so they shadowbanned me hoping that I wouldn't notice. Disgusting behavior from any moderator, let alone a default mod (which unfortunately, despite their position of great responsibility, tend to be the some of the worst of all kinds of mods, because the only reason they are mods in the first place is because they were personal friends with the admins when defaults were created; their behavior shows they are not at ALL fit to moderate). So yeah, real users should always know they're banned and why.
Hugs. As you clearly need one.
You cannot actually shadowban a user, that's an Admin only feature. However, you can "shadowban" using u/AutoModerator, by having it silently remove all of their content from your subreddit, essentially functioning the same way.
Here, I have a wiki exerpt from one of my subreddits about this:
"Shadowban" a user: this script allows for AutoModerator to silently remove each comment or post of a user. This is usually used to combat ban evasion, as the user does not immediately know they are banned, so they will not attempt to circumvent for a while. Replace user placeholders with the user you'd like to shadowban. You may add additional users by separating the usernames by a comma and a space.
---
#"SHADOWBANS" A USER
author:
name: ["user"]
action: remove
action_reason: Automatic removal of shadowbanned user.
---
That should do the trick!
You cannot actually shadowban a user
But that's what you just showed him how to do. Also, you don't need "name". This will work just fine:
author: [name1, name2, name3]
action: remove
You can use automod to automatically remove all their posts and comments, that's the closest to a shadowban.
Is there a resource for all the things automod does?
r/Automoderator - especially the links in the sidebar there.
You’re a saint, dunno how I didn’t know about this
And in the full documentation is the script to use
It's exactly the same thing.