Why Are There a Disproportionately High Number of Gay Men That Restore?

Question

I've been on restoration forums for over a decade, and I've noticed something (I'm sure that I'm not alone). There seems to be a disproportionately high number of gay men that restore. As a straight man, this has always puzzled me since I've never seen restoration as a "gay" or "straight" thing, per se - simply a topic that centers on a man's desire for genital wholeness.

I use the term disproportionately from a statistical standpoint: i.e. the gay men that restore seems to be numerically higher than the gay men in society at large. I have no numbers to back this up, of course (empirical evidence being lacking in this regard from what I know). So my assessment comes from the "eyeball" test...the noting of a general pattern.

Every theory that I've hoisted forth is quickly rebutted in my mind. For example, I once postulated that gay men have a greater desire to be physically equal to their partners - and yet, a similar claim could be made about a straight man: i.e. he could/should want to experience the same pleasure that his wife feels. I then postulated that gay men were more hedonistic; and yet, this can also be easily applied to straight men as well (straight men being no strangers to sexual hedonism).

So after 10 years, I'm still stumped. It's curious to me since most topics that I ponder for this long - if only periodically - will eventually reveal themselves. And yet, I'm still unable to come to an answer on this.

Thoughts?

Posted Nov 23, 2018, 3:43 AM UTC

3914
Dellone•

I expect that gay men might encounter a wider variety of penises. This might increase the chances they question their beliefs of what is a 'normal' penis.

52
Dellone•

I am a 24 year old straight man, I have seen maybe 4 penises besides my own in person and I can't remember any of the being uncircumcised. I only stumbled onto restoration because of a r/whatisthisthing post about a DTR that made it to the front page.

21
restorepenRestoring | CI-1•

Did you sucked them ? If your answer is no, thats why

-4
lengthyounarther•

I think the answer has one primary cause. Gay men are going to be vastly more familiar with cock, both cut and intact, and thus be more likely to be aware of any differences. Most straight men don't even see intact cocks more than at infrequent intervals. Sure in some gyms or the military where communal showers are widely used and there are a decent proportion of intact men, there might be some exposure, but most men don't live in circumstances like that. Even if they see the occasion intact guy, they probably are not sucking, playing or comparing it. Gay men are.

Speaking as a gay man I can say that my first hand experiences with intact cock is what got me interested in restoration. I had read some anti circumcision literature in college but at the end of the day I was happy with my cut cock. I "felt fine". I had only ever seen one intact cock in my life and had no first hand experience to refute the anti foreskin claims of the pro circumcisionists. After I started meeting intact men, talking to them, and playing with their cocks, I quickly realized two things. A: The claims that uncut cock was dirty and prone to medical issues were exaggerated out of all proportion. B: There is a clear qualitative experiential difference with intact being far superior.

The second reason is that gay men are probably much more comfortable expressing and discussing cock, both generally and personally. Straight men are burdened with the fear that to much penis talk could make them seem gay. Gay men don't have to worry about that.

The third reason is related to the first. Surveys have routinely shown that familiarity with foreskin is the experience that correlates most with being anti circumcision. Intact doctors are far less likely to recommend circumcision. Intact men are far less likely to circumcisize their sons. Gay men who have experienced foreskin first hand are much more likely to see its value. Its true that you can find strong logical and empirical arguments against circumcision and showing the value of foreskin, but hundreds of pages of well written text isn't going to have the visceral effect of seeing intact cock in action (I'll spare you a more detailed description of what I mean). Straight men are rarely going to get anything more than internet text. Gay men usually are exposed to far more and thus will value foreskin more and be more interested in restoration.

40
wheatfields•

Circumcision is a cultural norm. It’s not logical, it’s not even rational. But it’s done simply and only because it’s done.

That can be highly frustrating to hear, but the truth is there are many cultural norms we don’t question as society to provide “short cuts” to solutions so we literally don’t have to question everything and literally reinvent the wheel every generation. Which is useful, but causes a lot of bad stuff to get passed down as well as good.

Gay men are in a unique situation in that they have good reason to question cultural norms, as many of us have experienced hate, struggled, and challenges brought about by the cultural norm “straight is normal, gay is bad.” So you have a whole group that has had it burned deep into their life experience that cultural norms can be wrong.

So it’s FAR easier I think for gay men to question circumcision as they are more likely to be questioning norms than a straight guy who has less of a reason to do so.

Why do you think so many men don’t speak out against circumcision? Who never even question or think about it? Because it’s FAR FAR easier to accept than it is to challenge, challenging is painful, it’s journey of self discovery that can take you anywhere. That’s scary, complicated and why do it if can ignore and live in ignorant bliss?

37
toomuchscrotalskin•

For me personally, being in a relationship/having sex with an intact guy is basically what led me to restore. When you're gay, you get to know dicks on a completely different level compared to straight men. How they work, feel, taste, etc. Everything is directly intimate and first-hand, whereas for straight guys (aside from their own dick), they only know what they see in porn or hear from buddies/internet. When I got together with my intact bf, I did not know anything about foreskin/circumcision aside from what you hear in the media/culture. Honestly, I found it a bit off-putting at first. But I liked the guy, so I just went with it.

The more we had sex, the more I noticed how different our dicks were (he was my first, so I only had my own to compare with). Let me tell you something, reading about/watching gliding action doesn't compare to how it actually feels. All that skin moving up and down the head and shaft feels so natural and comfortable compared to a tight cut with lube. I remember that aspect being really eye-opening for me. Then there were other things, like the ridged band, frenulum, glans texture, moistness. I didn't know what they were until I later researched, but what I did know was that he had them and I didn't. These things are very noticeable when they're in your hand and in front of your face! And he always seemed to feel a lot much more pleasure than me.

So yeah, just that direct physical experience of sex was enough for me to figure out that something was wrong with circumcision. I imagine that many other gay men have had similar experiences. We are definitely "exposed" to cock a lot more than straight men, and a lot more comfortable with exploring the subject, so even if not having sex, would be more inclined to look up differences of cut/intact. I think a lot of straight guys have probably seen an intact penis/know about foreskin but just don't care to explore the subject any further, since well, they're not really into dicks.

19
TwiceFused•

I talked to Ron Low about this, I think he said that about 70% of restorers are straight. I think maybe gay men are generally more comfortable talking about their junk and more open to sharing things like pictures online. I’m straight and have not shared anything about or relating to restoration with anyone in my life.

I think there are a lot of people that are following along, but aren’t necessarily very vocal about doing so. I know that is the case for myself.

14
waraukaeru•

I bet the percentage is fairly accurate. However, 30% of restorers being gay is much larger than the percentage of the general population that is gay.

11
[deleted]•

[deleted]

9
Simdustries•

Non-straight men have a greater interest in penises and have more exposure to the variety of penises out there (whether from firsthand experience or from pornography), including noticing that not every penis looks like theirs. This leads to exploring WHY one’s penis is different , and eventually restoration for those who think it’s necessary.

9
[deleted]•

[deleted]

8
BlueCollarLawyer•

I’m not sure this is true. It could be that gay men are simply more comfortable talking about penises in general, theirs and others’. But I also think that up close experience with an intact member will cause a circumcised man to question it. I suspect few gay men in regions of the country were intact men are rare have thought any more about it than straight men in the same areas.

3
director87Circumcised•

Yea, I've noticed this too over the years. On this sub and other forums there are a lot of gay men who restore (me being one of them). I don't know why but I think it has a lot to do with exposure.

A lot of straight men, not all obviously, will never intentionally look at other male genitalia either because it doesn't interest them or because they fear being called out as gay. Exposure to seeing other genitalia is, in my experience, the number one cause to ask "now why is that different?" and to question their own bodies.

I really think it boils down to seeing more penis, in real life and online porn. There are more chances for a gay man to compare himself with other guys because in general it's a very body conscious community (unfortunately).

Either way, I wish more straight men in the U.S. etc. would find their way onto these forums, as they are the ones who end up having children and cutting their own kids. I would really love to see that practice take a dive in the next decade or two. I have talked to a few of my close straight male friends to convince them to restore and they simply won't because "they like their penis the way it is." Which I respect.

3
Ed_from_Iowa•

My guess is because they see more penises than the average straight man. I started talking about circumcision with all my gay friends first. They were the first to bring up the topic and be so passionate about it. It opened my eyes and made me even more passionate. I had no idea so many people were hurting from this surgical theft.

On a side note, learning how many potential mothers blindly support circumcision is mind boggling. Pregnant women don’t want to be told their ideas might not be correct and if they want to cut up their babies, they will fucking fight you to be able to do so. I think a lot of it has to do with hormones but circumcision is a topic many pregnant women won’t even discuss unless they already have a strong negative stance against it already.

3
MajorStylesOPRestoring | CI-6•

Lots of great answers out there...much thanks.

3

Maybe gay men are more comfortable talking about dick? Could be same % of straight and gay men are restoring, but straight men are flys on the wall lurking for info? Gay male here. Started restoring this year because I've been with uncut before and I prefer the look. Current partner (of 4 years) is circumcised and not interested in restoring. To each their own. A dick is a dick, once you've seen enough of them they all start to look the same anyway. Especially when hard.

3
TheBlueDolphin94Restoring | CI-3•

I’m gay in my mid-40s, and I admit I’m obsessed with penis. I always have been. I’ve probably seen thousands of dicks over the years (mostly old school university locker rooms and YMCAs with gang showers and open nudity, but also JO parties, gay nudist events and sexual encounters). TBH, I love the look of a cut dick. Seeing a huge mushroom head with pronounced ridge on a big, fat cock is so sexy - even better if he has a full, natural bush. Anyway, the reason that I am restoring (started at CI-2.5 and now approaching CI-4) is about sensitivity and sexual feeling. Circumcision is barbaric and should be banned. The number of nerves that are cut and destroyed is insane. A man never experienced the same sexual pleasure after being cut, but restoration helps by covering the glans, and eventually restoring to CI-8 or 9 provides the foreskin required to slide up and down over the head during sex and masturbation, which is what intact men get to experience. I want that! I want to experience that skin gliding action. I started to restore in 2004 but quickly chickened out because there was not much of an online community of restorers to discuss the topic and encourage each other. Now that I’m getting older and finding groups like this online, it is really helping my progress! I hope that I have full coverage in the next 2-3 years. I also want to be able to go nude in the locker room and get some looks like “oh wow that’s a hot foreskin!”

2