r/wow•
Maxread86

How does it make sense that a 17-year old is leading one of the largest factions in all of Azeroth?

Discussion

This is mind-blowing to me. 17 years old and he is in charge of the entire Alliance? How is this not brought up more?

Tyrande Whisperwind - General of the Sentinels for 10,000 years & fought in multiple world-ending wars. Seems like a reasonable choice to lead the Alliance. Nope.

Malfurion Stormrage - First ever Druid. Mastered the art of Druidism. Fought against the Burning Legion multiple times. Nearly unparalleled power & wisdom. Great fit to lead the Alliance. Nope.

Prophet Velen - 20,000 year old Prophet with wisdom that probably exceeds Stormrage. Has the power of "sight" to see beyond the scope of man. Seems like a good choice in times of war. Nope.

Jaina Proudmore - Ever powerful sorcerer. I dont think I need to explain why she would be a better fit than Anduin. But nope.

Alleria Windrunner - 10,000 year old war veteran. I'm getting tired of explaining. Anduin is 17 & barely started puberty.

Literally any of the other leader of the Alliance - Just seems more reasonable than Anduweenie

Someone please explain to me why Anduin is leading a war that could decide the fate of the world.

Posted Nov 24, 2018, 6:07 PM UTC

047
mackpackowes pixelprophet a beer•

Children leading massive kingdoms isn't unheard of in real life.

20
Zeydon•

OP is not debating why Anduin rules Stormwind/humanity, but why other races not a part of the human monarchist rule chose him to be at the head rather than one of their more experienced leaders.

11
Maxread86OP•

I think its unheard of when the kingdom is being faced with annihilation.

1
madatthings•

You’d be surprised how young some of the greatest leaders were in our history lol

4
Maxread86OP•

Give me a few examples. Not trying to downplay your point, but I'm curious as to whom you're mentioning

-2
madatthings•

Alexander the Great is most notable

9
Snugglebull•

Is he actually 17 or did you just pick a number

4
Maxread86OP•

I believe he's actually freshly 18. My mistake. I stand by my point though

-1
Snugglebull•

he has smoked weed

1
LoquaciousLamp•

Because the humans use a monarchy?

11
Maxread86OP•

I understand the Monarchy, but why would they have Anduin, the least experienced leader, be the military commander of the entire Alliance

0†
nzothbestloa•

I understand the Monarchy

You clearly don't.

7
Maxread86OP•

I think you're missing my whole point. That's fine.

-3
madatthings•

Because monarchy

4†
Zeydon•

OP is pointing to how the alliance consists of more than 1 race.

So yes, Anduin leads the humans because monarchy, but why is he also at the head of the alliance with purple elves, smurfs, blue elves, stumpy humans, fun size humans, puppy humans, etc.?

Wouldn't night elves prefer a leader with more experience? They're not humans, anduin does not lead their race, so why do they not suggest a more experienced leader to guide the coalition of races, rather than the least experienced leader in the alliance?

4
Sayaka_best_meguca•

Other races were taken under Human Alliance.

1
Infernobeckons•

Because this is a fan fiction written by bunch of fanboys.

8
akkadiansteel•

Alliance military is made up largely by Stormwind soldiers. Stormwind is a hereditary monarchy. Varian Wrynn died and his son is Anduin. What do you not understand?

8
Maxread86OP•

So as a leader or military figure in the Alliance, you would trust a young man with next to no war-experience to lead you against the Horde over any of the other leaders I listed?

2†
kejartho•

While the Humans make up the majority of the Alliance population, you also need to keep in mind that leading the Alliance does not always mean leading the war. He was involved in some pivotal battles but he must also be involved in intrigue and negotiation amongst the other races. All of the forces trust to work with the Humans as they are the most populous and he is the most trained in diplomacy, not to mention being the son of a popular king.

Leading a war is not the sole thing you need to look at for a good leader. Think of Robert Baratheon, a terrible ruler of the 7 kingdoms but a great warrior. Anduin trusts his commanders and allies to help him with war while he seeks out a better solution for all of the Alliances problems.

6
sglee442•

He’s the heir of Varian who led the Alliance well and held the respect of the other factions leaders. If they challenged Anduin’s seat, it might splinter the Alliance which would lead to a weaker Alliance and the Horde gobbling up the now-lone faction.

Tyrande is already going to disregard Anduin’s authority in 8.1 after a disagreement (keeping spoiler free here) but it’s not like she’s challenging to take the throne. Alliance gotta stick together.

8
Tezraen•

Tyrande Whisperwind - General of the Sentinels for 10,000 years & fought in multiple world-ending wars. Seems like a reasonable choice to lead the Alliance. Nope.

Also abandoned all her troops & civilians in place of just healing malfunction erm malfurion. Makes sense that she won't be leading anything.

7
Chazman_89•

Can't forget that her initial reaction to meeting new races was genocide.

14
Teragus•

It's simple, he doesn't lead it alone

6
Zeydon•

Why doesn't Malfurion or Velen lead the alliance "not alone"?

3
kejartho•

Both of those characters have chosen pacifism or tried to be more neutral outside of their own battles (The nightmare, The Legion). Until recently I'd say they both didn't care about the faction war enough to lead.

5
defakto227•

Henry the VI was 8 months old when he became king.

5
blufin•

And he was generally acknowleged to be one of the worst kings of England.

7
DvaJeff•

lol

1
Xynth22•

Humans founded the Alliance. They are the glue that holds it together. And Anduin is the last leader's son, who the rest trusted, so he is the leader now. Not that hard to figure out.

5
Maxread86OP•

Facing annihilation, I think I would feel more trusting with someone with a little more experience who also has been a leader of the Alliance for a longer time

2
Xynth22•

The other leaders just lead their specific races, and as such, they have no experience at leading all of the races, just theirs. So in that regard, they have about as much experience as Anduin does. And considering Anduin is a much more empathetic leader, I'd say he better for that role than any other.

Genn is too set in his ways. Velen really isn't that good of a leader. Tyrande is pretty xenophopic. Malfurion has been written to be a complete moron. Alleria and Turalyon are more soldiers than they are leaders. The Dwarf leaders mostly keep to themselves. And Jaina had no business leading anything after MOP up until recently in BFA's story due to her rage, and probably still isn't in a position to lead all of the Alliance since she'd still probably want more war rather than less.

4
AQuantumEvent•

Tyrande's first response to meeting new races was to kill them. Her response to Nightborne rebelling against Legion occupation was to accuse them of complicity.

Malfurion's purpose was to safeguard the Emerald Dream. He failed, and got his ass handed to him more than once.

Velen fled conflict for tens of thousands of years.

Jaina is ruler of nothing. The last time she was the ruler of a city, she left in a tantrum. The time before that she failed to defend said city.

Alleria is dabbling in the void. And she is the "leader" of a group of cultists who came up with their brilliant plan of delving into the void by following in the footsteps of a Scourge lieutenant and the biggest betrayer in their kingdom's history. Seems like a solid, stable choice for leadership.

The dwarves can't even keep their own clans in order. Conflict between the 3 main clans, and Moira can't even keep her own Dark Irons in check, many of whom are or were Twilight's Hammer cultists and/or followers of Ragnaros.

Greymane couldn't defend his own country, can't control his temper, and has a spotty history with supporting the Alliance.

4
GrumpyPan•

To be fair your kinda underestimating anduin. He is far more level headed then many alliance leaders(looking at you greymane and tyrande). Also in a game called world of warcraft he is one of the only driving forces in preventing conflicts through diplomacy. I know right, characters talking to one another rather than using magic or weapons unheard of lol.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
mildcherry•

I'm reminded of a quote from dragon age inquisition.

It goes along the lines of this: We don't choose our leaders by who's the strongest or smartest. We choose those who can make the impossible decisions and live with the consequences.

Anduin is the only one who places the strength of the Alliance above all else. The other characters are better equipped to be the leader, but none of them are as devoted to the concept of the Alliance as a whole.

I would bet that the long-lived characters see the Alliance more as a fleeting partnership of convenience than the future of Azeroth.

Andiun might be the only one who wants to be the leader.

1
Maxread86OP•

Thank you for your input & not lecturing me on how a Monarchy works. Although I disagree with him as the leader, I understand your opinion.

0
recklessguest•

Anduin despite his age has a close relationship with the important leaders of The Alliance. Genn is like an uncle to him and his right hand. Velen is a close advisor and trained him as a priest. He saved Morias life and was responsible for the formation of the council of three hammers. Jaina is an aunt to him and has been there for him his whole life. His father the last leader of the alliance acknowledged multiple times that Anduin would be a better leader than him. He impressed the celestials and earned their favor while taking time to speak with the leader of the black dragonflight. Since his fathers death he has shown all the qualities of a strong leader and never wavered from his duties...but he is 17 so there is that.

1
Cloosic•

OP is an idiot.

End Thread.

Seriously though, read some history or even WoW Lore before making these threads dude...

-1†
Maxread86OP•

This was a very well-constructed argument

5
Cloosic•

Your entire thread was poorly constructed so i thought it be a fitting response.. Also don't ever respond to me again don't want you dirtying me

-3
mildcherry•

Don't ever reply to me or my son again.

3
Maxread86OP•

You got it bud

2
wowmageissaru•

Monarchy

-1
sekool•

Anduin fanboyism detected. Purge protocol initiated.

Just keep roasting that guy cuz he made a fine point as to why all the Alliance follows a guy that actually didn't do nothing to prove himself. Also keep making points about RL kings younger than him, cuz Warcraft world is sooooooo similiar to ours.

​

Anduin leads the alliance, cuz Blizzard gets more brain-dead every expansion, period.

-3
Maxread86OP•

Thank you. I was starting to think I was alone in this world.

-2
sekool•

You are alone amongst alliance fanbois. Make another post claiming Sylvana shall rule the Horde, and watch them yelling that Horde shouldn't follow her ;)

-2