Help me r/EDH, you're my only hope. (Deciding on deck/mechanic)
I apologize for how long this is, but I'd also appreciate help. I've been struggling to find an EDH deck to build;
Backstory: just before summer my local group complained about a deck I just picked up and adjusted (Arcane Wizardry) into a wheely draw matters, (mostly just for me and they were a side-effect), and it made them hesitant to play anytime soon, and that hurt. I admit Inalla enabled a strong accidental combo board-state that was very flashy and explosive, but I hadn't even upgraded it much, just what was lying around, let alone the $40 I was planning to tune it. During summer, we were short on cash (college town) and I was a bit depressed, so I took apart most/all of my commander decks, putting aside most of the $2+ cards and sold about half of those. So I don't have a deck I like, aside from scraps of a Giant Tribal Kalemne that plays too Timmy for me. Now that I've had income and my group and family are getting back into EDH, I'm stuck without a deck and with a conundrum.
Problem: I have 2 (two) playgroups I'd play with,
- Local Group : Mostly Casual, Some Jank. Includes recent C18 decks (unedited so far), Azorius "Cops" Gimmick (12 Boardwipes and a lot of Detain), Oona Faeries, Ephara Blink/Goodstuff, Boros Angels, and 70-Mountain-Ashling.
- Has shown issues with long turns, "instant-win" combos, mass discard (even on wheels with redraw), etc. Typical casual play like no land destruction, few counterspells, and no infect.
- Generally durdles around for an hour, but alliances are common.
- Family : I'd say 60%, hovering between Casual and Focused. Includes Olivia Vampires,
Oloro Goodstuff, Windgrace Lands-Actually-Matter, Kumena Merfolk & Card Draw, the C14 decks, a developing Traxos Artifacts, and a developing Skullbriar Voltron with every Vraska. The Boros Angels mentioned before also often plays here (she's my fiancee, so this is her family. Cool right?)- Has had issues with graveyard-matters cards before, so generally runs 1+ graveyard hate per deck, and I'd rather avoid Voltron here since Kumena and Skullbriar do that well enough, also avoiding Vampires due to Olivia being commonly played.
- With new fixes to old decks, they can combo off by turn 8-10, but alliances are less common.
Deck Ideas: That aside, unless I put aside any Spike I have, I only have the budget for one deck ($50-200), ideally for use in both. I'm also fairly Johnny, so some decks are gimmicky, and ideally use Black and/or non-Blue. Most have decklists but some are so prototype it would be more of a wish list of themes. Ideas I've had thus far:
- Mimeoplasm Eldrazi - "The strongest EDH colors" plus the inclusion of a sideboard made me hesitant for casual play, but only using new-drazi for the (Cult of Emrakul)[https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/mimeoplasms-cult-of-emrakul/?cb=1543121663] made it budget enough.
- Werewolves - Both under Ruric and Ulrich, I think it's too dependant on seating to be useful for Focused play, even with a focus on flipping and Humans.
Scarecrows- Colorless or "Colors Matter" or even Scythes Tribal, too much of an on/off switch of no fun for me into no fun for anyone else.- 3C/4C Morphs - Still tempting, as the colorless bears pose less threat in the casual table, but the flip shenanigans can pull some weird stunts at the focused table? Either Animorphs or TwinBroDads with touch of Manifest.
- Ib/Wort Auntie Goblins - Red and Black are my favorite playstyle colors, but they might be too strange/combo for the casual table and run out of steam too much for the focused.
- Bolas Tribal - Less budget and less nice than wanted, maybe just embodying my Spike cruelty can win out? I've debated (pure Bolas)[https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/nicol-bolas-tribal-insect-gods/] or if Bolas / Niv-Mizzet (Spellslinger/Dragons)[https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/ancient-wyrms/] would be better.
- "Let's Make a Deal" - Rakdos the Defiler leading (Demons, Devils, and Imps)[https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/02-09-18-lets-make-a-deal/] with Tempt, Offering, "unless pay life" cards, and probably add back in Curses. It might play like a political deal-with-the-devil or just bomb because everyone just pays the life to cancel the card draw or other non-Rakdos conditional spells.
- Queen's Knights - (Marchesa)[https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/benevolent-queen-marchesa-long-may-she-reign/], Decrees, Offerings, and other political attack-inducing goodies with Knights Tribal. Has a good theme and might actually make the casual group productive and not take so long. Might even add Sunforger.
- Ramos Lucky Charms - I like the idea of spells fueling a voltron-y dragon engine that can spew mana, but I don't want enjoy Control too much and like full cycles too much to cut down on bad Charms/Confluences/Commands.
Gitrog Dredge- Always wanted (Dredge)[https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/toad-dredge/], but likely too over budget, not enough game-plan to end games, too long of turns, flashy turns even when not doing much, so on and so forth.- Brudiclad/Breya Myr - I hear Myr can be quite casual fun. (Brudiclad)[https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/engineer-of-myr/] seemingly ends games with Incubator and would likely include Stations/Living-Weapons, but (Breya)[https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/myrtificers/] seemingly wants so many accidental combos in the deck she'd explode out of nowhere every game.
- Yidris 4C Devoid - Newdrazi are all cool, and such a gimmick would surely make it casual, but could it win against focused decks...probably not without Titans.
- Kozi Eldrazi - (Colorless Eldrazi)[https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/the-titans-4/] (mostly new) with a lot of ramp and multi-mana lands makes for a neat deckbuilding challenge but likely linear gameplay at twice the budget when using the 3 new Titans and colorless staples.
- Famine - (Torgaar Triskadekaphobia)[https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/horseman-of-famine-1/] with weird loss-doublers and other life-control, I feel I'd be target number one at the casual table, and Big Black eats the budget.
- Apostles - (Black)[https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/have-you-heard-of-the-cult/} or "Mardu" under (Kaalia)[https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/politicult/], this would certainly be over budget with 30x Shadowborn Apostles (so ~$90 on those alone), which always intrigued me but I feel would be too samey, even if under the guide of Demon toolbox.
- Luxury Buys All - My most recent brew that adjust to power-level, ("5C" Black Gonti)[https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/gonti-buys-all/] theft deck, with subthemes of Riches/Underworld/Draw-Burn/Demons. I hear theft leaves many very salty, so I'm hesitant here even though it factually adjusts to the power level of the group(s).
- Jodah, Time Wizard - (Jeskai Suspend)[https://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/archmage-eternal-time-wizard/] splashing GB, with thematic time/suspend manipulation cards, as well as finishers like Elder Dinos, Newdrazi Titans, and Myojins. I'm worried suspend would make me a target since my plays are so open, but Jodah lets the finishers come in fast and there is a Maze's End alt-win for longer games.
Conclusion/Request: So, I come to you all for your wisdom. Do any deck ideas stand out as being suitable for casual-focused playgroups? Any worries I have that you can quell about certain mechanics? Should I take the eraser to some decks to budget them down enough to buy two lower-scale ones, or bite the bullet and save enough to buy two decks (if so, which to prioritize)? Do you recommend a budget size for certain power levels?
My current favorite ideas are 5C Black Gonti, Jodah Time Wizard, Brudiclad Myr, Queen's Knights, and 4C Morphs; Bolas Tribal will likely be made sometime after the new set comes with hopefully yet another Nicol. Apostles sound cool but are likely just too far out of budget to try.
I am most curious to hear about Suspend, cards like Browbeat/Dash Hopes, Theft (mostly playing opponent's cards but some graverobbing too), Morph/Manifest, and Werewolves in different EDH environments.
P.S. Working via new reddit...I can't seem to hide links in words anymore. Sorry. If any links are private, let me know and I'll fix it right up.
EDIT: I've asked the saltiest of the local playgroup, and he's "okay" with Gonti, but agrees I'll be a prime target at the table from Theft. He thinks Suspend and Morph should be fun but maybe hard to balance. (Those 3 were the most discussed and encouraged from comments thus far). Brudiclad still sounds neat but should end up with very sudden salt-inducing wins, and Queen Marchesa has oft been encouraged to become Black Rose Marchesa, a card that previously caused groans at the casual table.
EDIT 2: Getting some feedback on the popular 5 from a good friend in the local group, he thinks all are a bit too competitive (read focused) for the level of jank sometimes seen in the group. He thinks Morph/Manifest with TwinDads would be cool, so I should focus my efforts and budget for the family group/deck.
Posted Nov 25, 2018, 4:34 AM UTC · edited