r/btc•
3lusive

SV replay protection and the hash war being “over”

Today I saw a few times in the media that the hash war is officially over because SV announced they’re implementing replay protection - can someone redpill me on why replay protection seems the way being over from the SV camp perspective?

Posted Nov 27, 2018, 2:28 AM UTC

312

They removed replay protection from the SV client to start the 'war' in the first place. Adding it back is admitting defeat.

7
3lusiveOP•

thanks for the insight - I'm still trying to gauge what to make of the whole SV situation, on the one hand I'm glad all of the people who I don't agree with (CSW followers) are all together now, but on the other hand I hate seeing delays in progression of the BCH community as a whole, solely because of political dick swangin. But alas, I'm just 1 satoshi among the sea of all the others.

6
etherbid•

He asked for the Red Pill perspective, not the Blue Pill.

Think for a moment what were their actual goals vs. their publically stated goals

0
Liiivet•

Coingeek has begun secret mining of bch now?

1
hawks5999•

CSW makes the claim that Bitcoin forks, doesn’t add replay protection and only one chain survives.

If you add replay protection, you are creating a new coin that is no longer the original chain, but something new.

When BSV adds replay protection, it is an acknowledgement that it is not forking, it is splitting; is not bitcoin and has lost.

https://cdn-images-1.medium.com/max/2000/1*5eHZlmq0U_1yTCRWMbDkRw.png

4
3lusiveOP•

Thanks for linking, it's insane to me how much CSW says one thing and does another, and many people don't seem to mind it.

2
phillipsjk•

Their hash-rate has gone down considerably.

https://cash.coin.dance/blocks/hashrate

They could be trying to re-org the BCH chain after declaring the war over. It would kill what ever credibility they have left though.

2
hawks5999•

CSW said in his drunken interview on hashwars live that when they took hash away from SV they would be mining on BTC to sell for funding the hash they used on SV. He said ABC thinks they are secretly mining to re-org and so add hash when SV hash drops. He was so pleased with how sneaky he was being he didn’t notice he was basically giving away the scam. Too much scotch will do that I suppose.

1
phillipsjk•

I checked fork.lol

That blip was not there an hour ago. I guess the lag is at least 90 minutes.

1
etherbid•

You still don't get how badly everyone was played.

Think about it for a moment what happened and what SV got

1
hawks5999•

Ah yes. Only you enlightened few can see the true 7-D chess that SV is playing. The rest of us looking at outcomes and comparing them to earlier promises and threats, and seeing obvious failure are totally missing the truth.

I bet you’re a Scientologist too.

1
rinexc•

Both chains are now being mined at a profitable hashrate. I believe they had a change of heart and decided to split ways for good.

1