r/yubikey•
162bfizzy

How Long Before We Fully Go Hardware 2FA?

I don’t expect anybody to know the answer, but would love to hear some opinions in terms of when most major websites will have something like Yubikey be the primary access method. It’s a little sad that the only services that I use that support Yubi are Facebook, Google, and LastPass. The vast majority of banks are still using SMS or email 2FA. Some don’t even do that.

How many years are we looking at?

Posted Dec 1, 2018, 5:07 AM UTC

411
a_cute_epic_axis•

that support Yubi are Facebook, Google, and LastPass.

Uhh, what? Assuming you mean support U2F, there are lots of websites that support it currently. Dropbox, GitLab, Salesforce, Dashlane, Twitter, AWS, login.gov, Okta, Bitwarden, etc are all just a random sampling of sites that support U2F. A whole lot more run OATH currently which you can store on the Yubikey as well, though it obviously lacks the phishing protection of U2F. If you don't happen to use other products, that's not U2F's fault all that much.

I will say that the fact that basically no banks support either U2F or OATH is very disappointing.

3
162bfizzyOP•

I will say that the fact that basically no banks support either U2F or OATH is very disappointing.

That was more or less my point.

I appreciate that a lot of sites are supported, but nowhere near enough. I don't use Salesforce, Dashlane, Okta, Gitlab, or Bitwarden.

I'm sure it's great if you do.

Also, AWS only allows you to register one key so no backup keys. Same with Twitter (only one key can be registered).

​

3
a_cute_epic_axis•

Also, AWS only allows you to register one key so no backup keys. Same with Twitter (only one key can be registered).

Yes, this is a major flaw at the moment, as they need a non U2F way to deal with the loss of the key.

2
ffxsam•

You can log into the AWS root account without U2F if you lose your key.

1
a_cute_epic_axis•

Yes, which is undesirable

1
UnityIsPower•

Not a bank but I think Vanguard also has hardware key support.

2
candb7•

Yeah but they require SMS backup so it’s moere for convenience than security.

2
snakerjake•

Decades is my guess

2
162bfizzyOP•

You’re bumming my high, man. :-)

1
Cinderbike•

Serious question to your question: can you really expect the average person to carry a yubikey everywhere? Even using unique passwords everywhere is too much.

The only way this would work (IMO) is if companies banded together and straight up forced consumers.

1
162bfizzyOP•

To be honest, when people first started talking about using unique passwords on every site, I wasn't too interested. Even though I work in an industry where security is taken somewhat seriously, I just couldn't be bothered to do that. I might have unique passwords on my really important stuff but Reddit? Nah. Too much trouble.

I even tried doing some sort of code where first and last letter would be the first two letters of the site name, plus the number of letters in the URL of the domain name, plus . . . you get the picture.

Just way too much trouble. Especially when some sites say you have to use a special character and some don't, some sites have a maximum number of characters, etc.

I used early KeePass for password storage but it wasn't really integrated into browsers so it was more or less a backup in case I forgot a password.

But 1Password and LastPass and the like really changed a lot of that for me. I've gone though hundreds of sites (over a long period of time) and created unique passwords for every site.

Most of the people that don't use password managers, don't know about them or don't understand them well enough. Even my 71 year old dad uses a password manager, even though he uses the same two passwords for every site, haha.

So, I think password managers will catch on and once they catch on, people will realize that they don't need to know the password. They can leave that job to the password manager.

We've been trained for years to remember our passwords, it's a habit that needs to be broken over several years as well.

And I really questioned whether or not YubiKey would be a pain in the butt. I had the same reservations I had about password managers, "What if I get locked out? I can always trust my brain, but what about some piece of software?"

Now, when I buy a stock or I transfer money in brokerage or banking accounts, I'm thinking, "Man, this would be a good place to require me to insert a YubiKey to verify my identity."

It's funny because I have a bank account from when I used to live in Asia and I use that to send money to people from time to time. And they've had 2FA on transferring money for 7 or 10 years now. Granted, it's still SMS, but still probably more secure than most US banks.

1