r/mtgfinance•
MTOB

Which ~$50 staple should I purchase from UMA from an investment standpoint?

Hello,

I'm typically a somewhat budget magic player that plays mostly kitchen table and modern formats, but with UMA coming up I have about $200 in my "mtg budget". I plan on getting a bit more competitive with modern down the road and enjoy decks with Green and/or Blue in them so as a result of this I plan on picking up a playset of one of the following modern staples:

  1. Goyf
  2. Snapcaster
  3. Noble Hierarch
  4. Cavern of Souls

From purely an investment standpoint, which card do you think would prove to be the best investment?

Posted Dec 6, 2018, 2:15 PM UTC

011
Euphyllia99•

Definitely not Goyf as its currently not well positioned in the Modern meta and has been reprinted at least 4 times. it used to be a 150 dollar card 2 years ago and you will have time to pick them up. the other 3 options are solid and recovered quickly from their reprints. Hierarchs less so and especially since its a rare itll stay low for longer than the other two. probably dipping down to 35 bucks like it did last time it got reprinted, less so if this is the large print run people expect.

I'm not an expert but I would default to Cavern as its a land that can slot into any deck that wants its effects. after that I would prioritze Snapcaster and then a toss up beteween Goyfs and Hierarchs with an edge to the latter.

​

you might even get away with a playset of nobles and 2 copies of one of the others with the way prices are going.

​

10
First_Revenge•

As investments(I.E. something you expect a return on) they're all pretty lousy. I mean you could speculate on some cards in the short term, but with only $50 to throw around it just isn't going to be worth your time. In the long run all these cards will lose value so they aren't something you should be considering as investments.

​

Better advice, buy what you want to play in mid december-january. Prices will be low and you can save some $. Or if there's nothing you want just save the money and you'll be better off.

4
Jimisdegimis89•

I would go with the Nobles, they are more likely to snap back to a higher price point faster than snaps or caverns right now. Caverns would be number 2, than snappys then goyf. There's a good chance if you dont mind burning some time browsing that you could get a playset plus a couple others.

3
bennynshelle•

Cavern is by far the best choice, it has massive commander appeal, much more so than hierarch. After that I like Snapcaster because it's a mythic and after that Hierarch. I think you should expand your options to the mid-tier box toppers that are going to dip towards the $50 range, and scoop up the ones that have real Commander demand.

3
rizzeedizzee•

Skip those and go for cards whose first foil is in this set. Foil Containment Priest (yes, I realize it has an invocation) and foil Temporal Manipulation, for example.

2
naturedoesntwalk•

first foil is in this set

Temporal Manipulation

[[Temporal Manipulation|J15]]

1
ikariw•

Purely as an investment I would say any card not on the reserved list is inherently risky. It's impossible to know what cards might be printed that may raise or lower the value of any of these, what cards may get banned that could affect prices in either direction, whether or not any of these may get a reprint (in standard or a supplemental product) or any other information pertinent to value. I'm not sure it's possible to pick one of those four and say that that particular card is more likely to go up in value than any of the others.

If you're buying them to play then my advice would be to wait until you know what deck you want to play and then buy the ones relevant to that deck - it's likely that prices will be lower in a few months once more UMA has been opened. Alternatively if you are pretty sure you want to play blue green then maybe fetches / shocks in those colours (particularly if you wait until after the next set is released with Breeding Pool presumably included which should make that cheaper)

1
hp94MOD•

Removed: Rule 4.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
mtg_teacup•

none. Look at birds of paradise. if you buy, buy first prints or reserved list. WotC has had quite a reprint mania in which I have sold most of my modern collection as it doesnt make sense from an investment point of view. I like the game,I just felt this Hasbro Earnings per share improvement with more reprints that my wallet cant keep up with.

​

I dont know what you are playing, but if it is control go for snap. If its aggro go with goyf and cavern. And if its infect go for noble hierarch.

​

P.S. Buy what you will play and play with it. Dont buy as an "investment" as none of these will give you what you look for.

1
YisanTiger•

Reserve list or special foils like Masterpieces.

1