Has anyone on JRE or anywhere ever addressed concern about how easy it is for Twitter and Facebook to make the opinion of a handful of people appear to be the opinion of the masses?

I’m mainly talking about twitter and it’s “Moment” feature which posits a narrative then shows a few tweets of people who agree with that narrative while ignoring the thousands of tweets who disagree.

The recent Kevin Hart situation highlights this even more.

Posted Dec 7, 2018, 5:43 PM UTC

6867
ArcaneUX•

whats hilarious is that reddit is the worst case of this. Promotes an echo chamber with the up/downvoting system. Reddit is an internet safe space

48
BEASTIN-25-8I have a pulsing effect•

And when an unpopular opinion gets traction, mods delete/ban just because they don't personally agree with it.

25
PikeOffBerk•

Ah, but votes don't always represent popularity when you factor in outside groups with political agendas who brigade.

9
brokedman45•

And keeping the opinions of that "outside group" away. Is creating safe spaces echo chambers.

4
whatsinthesocks•

That's not always true as those outside groups don't always come in to have legit discussions

3
prodigy2throwOP•

Plus in most subs if you ave too many downvotes your ability to reply is throttled thus silencing one opinion more

13

The upvoting and downvoting system itself, is a brilliant part of reddit. The issue arises when Reddit users misuse the buttons. The buttons are designed to say:

Upvote: Your comment is relevant to this conversation whether I agree with it or not

Downvote: Your comment doesn’t add anything relevant to this conversation. It doesn’t belong in this particular thread

But instead, it’s mainly used like this:

Upvote: I totally agree with your comment

Downvote: I disagree with your comment

I’ve said this before and I will keep saying it:

The downvote button is not a disagree button

I guarantee if reddit users used this feature correctly, the quality of threads on Reddit would be much higher

10
ArcaneUX•

No its really not brilliant. It just creates an echo chamber. Why? Most people are biased towards whatever the subreddit’s general consensus is. You need conflicting viewpoints to challenge your bias. They typically get downvoted. For example: if i make a post praising joe rogan’s podcast, it will get upvoted. If i make a post objectively criticizing the podcast and pointing out its flaws, it may get some upvoted but a lot more downvotes. Theres nothing wrong with conflicting viewpoints.

8

You’re absolutely correct. The reason why you’re correct however, is listed in my comment. The echo chamber, biased nature, of the downvote system, is a direct result of users misusing the feature incorrectly. If it was used correctly, the people who disagreed with the flaws you point out, would simply upvote you, and reply their reason why they disagree. But instead, they just slap a downvote on you and call it a day. It’s not how the original system was meant to be used. It’s a shame that users on Reddit don’t know how to use reddit effectively. Unfortunately, the Reddit population has grown substantially after the era of using the downvote system properly. That resulted in this massive increase of people who joined reddit with the understanding that the upvote means agree and the downvote means disagree, which is just simply not the case. The downvote system is actually used effectively in some threads. It prevents hardcore trolls from corrupting an interesting thread. Where it fails, is in threads, like I said, where people use it to disagree. People on here hate my opinions, and they all just downvote me, instead of talking about why they disagree. It’s a real shame

6
geddyleembaugh•

The fact it's easy to misuse, and more importantly, abuse and game is what makes it not brilliant.

I thought Slashdot's moderation system was better. It gave intrinsic value to the vote by making it limited in number. People are less prone to misuse valued resources.

3
NotDanBennettSausage Maker•

Again, it's called 'the downvote arrow' and not the 'disagree arrow'. You're not supposed to downvote things you disagree with, you're supposed to downvote things that don't contribute to the conversation

2
ArcaneUX•

Youre not supposed to? Lol well problem solved people definitely wont do it now. Thanks for clarifying

0†
Just_Try_lt•

The amount of times I've seen irrefutablely true statements downvoted into the dirt simply because the truth doesn't coincide with the subreddit's narrative/general disposition is insurmountable. I look at each subreddit as a complete circle jerk of whatever material it pertains to.

A majority of users in most subreddits are looking for justification in whatever it is they're following, not necessarily to discuss it, and most certainly not to be critical of it.

2
halfpastnoonan•

like tweaking the algorithms so t_d posts couldnt hit the main page?

1
WickedTriggered•

Dude you’re so right.

0
[deleted]•

The left wing bias of social media giants and the silencing of personalities they disagree with seems to be covered fairly frequently recently.

15
ashyandy•

Wtf are you taking about. Brietbart and Ben Shapiro dominate Facebook’s top stories.

5
RustyCoal950212•

And watch one Shapiro/Rubin/Peterson/Crowder Youtube video and your suggested videos are feminists getting REKT for weeks

13
lngots•

That has less to do with the topic at hand than it does youtube just assuming that if you enjoyed giving them ad money from this video, they also found that you'll continue giving them ad money from these videos also.

Just an algorithm at this point that tries to lump you in with the other dummies cause you are slightly similar to them.

The topic at hand more has to do with curated opinions, than a heartless money seeking algorithm.

4
RustyCoal950212•

Yeah but YT's algorithm gives some strange results that have a similar effect

2
lilpumpgroupie•

I'm convinced that happens because the media companies they work for pay youtube to influence 'suggested videos' like that. You watch ONE Gavin McGinnis video out of curiosity, and you're on their list.

And it probably works the other way, too, although not as much, because there isn't nearly as much money in leftist media as there is in right wing media.

1
[deleted]•

I didn't even say I agreed with it. I simply stated that it's been discussed frequently.

2
ashyandy•

Word sorry

1
halfpastnoonan•

that’s two websites - compared to all of hollywood, almost every other media platform, and 4/5 of cable news stations which are all leftist propaganda.

2
ashyandy•

In your opinion what news is news and not leftist propaganda?

1
prodigy2throwOP•

They talk about the censoring and banning of conservative views a lot but I think this Moments feature is way more of an issue which I have never heard discussed.

3
xpoepanda•

I saw a clip of Burr on Bill Maher, from a few years back, saying the exact same thing. Most outrage is perpetrated by like 50 people but once the media picks it, is sounds like there’s tens of thousands ready to hold a demonstration.

13
expresidentmasks•

They talk about it on the show constantly.

8
TD_58•

See I don’t think we should have a president to begin with. I mean, the idea of ONE person ruling over 300 million people doesn’t make any sense.

Edit: y’all never heard Rogan say this 50 times?

6
whatsinthesocks•

Except it's not a single person the rules the country. The legislative branch has more power than the executive. They right the laws we must live by. The president being the head of the executive branch is in charge of enforcing those laws

2
TD_58•

Ok Mr wet blanket

5
expresidentmasks•
  1. That is an entirely different discussion that we could have, and I am sure we would agree on a lot there.

  2. The president does not rule, and the de facto most powerful person in the world is the speaker of the house.

-1
RustyCoal950212•

He was memeing - Rogan says something similar a lot.

The speaker of the house is not even close..

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
expresidentmasks•

The speaker decides the legislative schedule. That’s the single most important power.

-1
mish15•

Yeah they talk about it all the time

3
prodigy2throwOP•

When have they talked about the moments feature on twitter?

-1
chilossal•

I haven’t heard moments specifically called out but it is dogshit. At best its a lousy algorithm. At worst it reeks of someone behind the scenes pushing a specific agenda.

1

I haven’t used Facebook or twitter for several months. It became obvious that I was getting less and less control of the things I saw on there. And of the things I did. Downloaded my data and found every word I ever typed to anybody via message, comment, etc. Every post I made and every post I “liked” was also on there. I’m not the type of guy that thinks people at Facebook HQ are looking at my stuff and giggling about it or some shit, but the fact that it’s sitting in some database didn’t sit well with me. But that’s not even the primary reason I got off of there, I stopped using Facebook simply because the heavy political stuff was getting impossible to avoid. I fucking hate both sides of politics equally. So I don’t give two shits about seeing “progress in the LGTWURNFJCU community” or seeing “MAGA HAIL TRUMP god blass him”. Both of those types of things were always coming up somehow on my feed, so I just ditched the whole thing. Reddit for the win. Everyone on here is political too but I can filter it out better

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
three0nefive•

Ironically both of those people are some of the biggest perpetrators of this tactic. In fact they've literally built their careers on it.

3†
prodigy2throwOP•

Did they talk about the moments feature? I heard that episode and don’t recall it being discussed

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
Corndogginit•

You might like Sam Harris’s conversation with Tristan Harris.

1