The first results from a study of the "gilets jaunes" is out and they are interesting
franceculture.fr/sociologie/gilets-jaunes-ce-...Posted Dec 11, 2018, 10:04 PM UTC
444
Posted Dec 11, 2018, 10:04 PM UTC
That is interesting. Certainly counters the perception of rioters as young hoodlums.
Absolutely. Those are demographics you need at large actions like this, too - from the way it sounded, a lot of these folks have jobs that can really derail shit if they shut down. They're talking about the state's disdain for the working class and economic injustice... I dunno, it may come out down the line that there are problems with them, but from where I'm sitting the yellow vests are totally on the right path, and could actually execute a full general strike if they can snowball a little.
This is starting to look really exciting!
[deleted]
[Thanks to r/france for bringing this up](https://np.reddit.com/r/france/comments/a5a437/gilets_jaunes_ce_que_la_toute_premi%C3%A8re_enqu%C3%AAte/).
Here is a quick and rough translation by yours truly who thought it would be of interest, with some help from DeepL. Please excuse the errors (such as in the title ¬_¬) and weird language, it is getting late.
Gilets jaunes: what their very first study tells about the revolt
December 11, 2018
Chloé Leprince
Through 166 evaluated questionnaires, the first field study of the gilets jaunes tells who they are, from what position they are talking and what it is they want, they for whom it is their first participation in a social movement. Here is a summary of the main results from the study.
The gilets jaunes' past month of mobilization has contributed to bringing class back into the middle of public debate. The movement has however also had the effect of making two distinct categories of people more heard than prior:
People of, one could say, "modest" means that are in fact either from the working class or at the poorer end of the middle class, who have long been invisible in both the media and political debate and now suddenly regain in visibility.
Sociologists and social science researchers in general, who have been numerous in coming up with contributions aiming at shedding light on a movement that surprised many with its vigor, but also with a novelty that had to be deciphered - and it had been a long while since the media fed that much off social science, often aided by the viral potential of social networks.
After four days of mobilization, the first field study on the gilets jaunes was published this Monday, December 10, through an article in Le Monde - or at least, its first conclusions since its authoring collective of more than 60 researchers in sociology, political science and geography has announced it intends to keep the study going. Their intentions are to better define the profile of those we have gotten used to naming, in their own words, "the yellow vests", and to analyze as finely as possible the way they mobilize, especially as the movement has the pecularity of having emerged in a manner that was simultaneously broad, fast, and outside of all organized structures such as parties and unions.
Questionnaires, yet true encounters
This first report on the work of the collective of researchers (mostly federated around Sciences-Po Bordeaux, the INRA and the CNRS) harks mostly on a study conducted by thirteen of them through the use of questionnaires. Note however that "questionnaire" does not signify "write-in form": to obtain "richer" answers and "longer" testimonies, researchers put these together from live, face-to-face interviews obtained by meeting the gilets jaunes where they were mobilizing - essentially "in traffic circles" and in the street during their demonstrations.
Of the twenty-eight questions asked to all interviewed, five were so-called "open questions", but even so-called "closed" questions (theoretically calling for short answers), the interrogated have occasionally given answers that were more detailed than anticipated. "Concerning the subjects touched, 15 questions were about the participants' motivations, the reforms they desired, their preferred modes of action and their attitude towards the political; the last 13 dealt with the sociodemographic profile of the demonstrators", the researchers add.
All in all, 166 questionnaires were analyzed between November 24 and the publication of the results on December 10. These questionnaires were handed out during the second and third days of the gilets jaunes' mobilization, sometimes called "Act II" and "Act III" (November 24 and December 1), in six geographic zones:
"For this study, we decided to concentrate on persons active in the movement who participated in at least demonstration or blockade", the collective adds. What emerges from these questionnaires far from invalidates the first outline for an analysis that was formulated during the very first day of mobilization on November 17. Field work makes it even clearer instead.
Back then, many a researcher that attempted to analyze this peculiar movement underlined the necessity to take time for a proper analysis, as well as to listen to what the interrogated had to say (and the way in which they would). A hundred and sixty-six questionnaires and three weeks laters, the collective of thirteen researchers publishes not the composite picture of the "archetypal gilet jaune", but rather an X-ray of the collectives of which they could observe the mobilization in the six zones that they researched.
These are the main lessons they have learned:
Who they are
These gilets jaunes are on average 45 years old, with a mobilization that is substantially equivalent in the age ranges from 35 to 49 and from 50 to 64. A large majority of them work, and when they are senior citizens, they are retirees who have worked in the past.
55% of the 166 gilets jaunes met via questionnaire are men and 45% women, but this female ratio is much larger than the historical participation of working-class women in such movements. The researchers underline that the absence of established leaders has brought women to a broader and unprecedented prominence within a heterogeneous movement.
Among [the gilets jaunes], white-collar workers are overrepresented: 33% in total if one takes retirees into account, but 45% if not - even though white-collar workers make up only 27% of the broader French working population. Other overrepresented category within the mobilized gilets jaunes: craftsmen, shopkeepers and business owners - 14% of the working people questioned for only 6.6% of the entire French working population (and it is all the more interesting that they had not been pillars of social protest until then).
Conversely, blue-collar workers represent no more than 14% of the 166 gilets jaunes interrogated via this questionnaire even though they represent one out of five workers in France (and even one out of three if only men are taken into account). Executives are in turn half as numerous in the traffic circles and demonstration than they are within French society as a whole (13% of the interrogated workers vs. 26% of the working population in general).
"Non-workers" (the unemployed and retirees) make up a quarter of the mobilized people who answered the questionnaire.
What they think
For half of them (47%), this mobilization within the fold of the "gilet jaunes" is a first: if four out of five had already been in a demonstration, only 44% had previously been in a strike.
A third affirm, by the way, being "neither right- nor left-wing". Of the others, only 6% define themselves as centrists, 12% right-wing, 42% left-wing and 15% far-left.
The 166 gathered questionnaires within six different corners of France bring an answer supported by numbers as to whether the Rassemblement National managed to co-opt the movement: on November 24 and December 1st, only 5% of those interrogated see themselves as far-right, which concurs with the first observations that Benoît Coquard could make in other traffic circles from other rural areas during the very first day of mobilization on November 17. This also concurs with the deciphering attempt of four researchers from the LERASS, in Toulouse, who had combed through the Facebook posts of numerous gilets jaunes and shown that only very little xenophobic discourse could be found in them.
What they want
The first motive for their mobilization mentioned by those interrogated is purchasing power. Calamitous end of months and the idea of being unable to "afford indulging in anything" have been largely echoed in the testimonies gathered by the questionnaires. Half of those come from people not subject to tax with a medium income below 30% of France's average. It is however not possible to affirm that the gilets jaunes are a movement of the poorest: within the gathered questionnaires, only 10% have an income below 800€ per month.
Sixty-nine of the 166 people who answered also hinted at the heavy burden from taxes, but one out of three aggressively brings forward what they see as disdain for the working class (mépris de classe) about which the interrogated talk in terms of "arrogance" or "privileges". "May the government put itself in our shoes", say several demonstrators.
This field work echoes the notion of a "moral economy" of historian E.P. Thomson, which politologist Samuel Hayat brought forward in a blog post: almost everywhere in France, it is finally about social justice that the mobilized gilets jaunes talked to the investigators who submitted them their questionnaire. They are not fundamentally hostile to the idea of taxes per se, but figure that these taxes are distributed terribly unevenly. Among the gathered testimonies, one out of five demands a better distribution of wealth.