Rotating disk electrode equipment

What options are there for a basic rotating disk electrode setup? I'm looking into attempting some kinetic studies for an organometallic catalytic cycle and the literature I've found seems to show almost exclusive use of chronoamperometry at a rotating disk electrode. I'm trying to get an idea of how much an RDE setup would cost (rotating disk electrode + motor, I already have a potentiostat and reference electrode) to pitch to my PI. Pine Research seems to run on the order of $5k, which seems like a lot. I found some older papers (circa 1970s) describing how to make your own, are there any more modern examples or does everyone just buy one?

Posted Dec 15, 2018, 2:22 AM UTC

13
burakulgut•

Everybody buys one and PINE is typically the first place to look. Yet, companies like Metrohm Autolab and Origalys have their own rotators.

I would not advise making your own, making electrical contact to something that is rotating multiple krpm is not straightforward at all.

2
EsmyraOP•

Yeah, there’s no way that I’m going to make one myself, but the machine shop that’s part of my University is much more mechanically capable and the people there have made instruments before (including power supplies I use for other research). I’d just like to know if there are modern examples I can discuss with them to get a sense of the level of difficulty.

1
social-insecurity•

I have looked into this too and haven't seen any recent publications mentioning 'home-made' RDE setups. As already mentioned, Pine is the leading brand.

The older publications (also, check out The Rotating Disc Electrode by Pleskov and Filinovskii; the last chapter has details on fabrication) describe the essentials. There was some research done at UC Berkeley (I think under Newman and maybe Tobias?, 1970s as I recall) where the authors made careful studies on the effects of errors (such as eccentricity) on the accuracy of measurements, which would be useful in making a robust design.

As u/burakulgut stated, a significant issue will be the rotating electrical connection. This is often a source of electrical noise. I think modern designs use carbon-silver brushes; mercury used to be used but of course now we absolutely minimize its use so that's a non-starter.

In the end, considering the time to design and possibly debug, you will probably be further ahead with a commercial unit. You might be able to sell on a used equipment site after you are through with it if your lab has no other use (I've searched such sites for RDEs and haven't seen any the times I have looked - so maybe there would be a demand for used units?)

But if the machine shop has the right experience, the description in the older literature along with the papers I mentioned above would be your best bet if you must build.

2