r/homegym•
catict

Please help with New Rack decision: Titan X2 24" or Titan T3 36"?

I'd like to ask a question about these racks and feel like I should preface it with some info about my situation. But I'll ask the question first and tell the need for it at the end so no TL/DR issues.

I'm looking at two racks: they're the short versions version of- T3 36" deep and X-2 24" deep.

Any advice or suggestions, constructive criticism? Even if it's to say buy from "x manufacturer instead" or buy a different model or anything. I've never had a 24" deep rack so my main question is the 36" depth of the T-3 rack worth an extra $100 dollars in spite of it's all bolt together construction and lighter weight? Also will I be able to box squat inside the 24" rack or will I need to do that outside? Shoot, I just thought of that because I need to or very much want to box squat with bands.

​

Again, Thank You All for reading this. I could be wrong or stupid about some of this. I actually had a nice body solid rack for years that went with an ex (why she needed it I don't know, or didn't want me having it I guess) that was probably 36" deep and I box squatted in it.

​

FYI here are my reasons for the T3- more room to squat. Reasons for the X-2 I see- almost all welded and heavier (band squats/benches will be done so heavier is better. The T-3 has 2x3" uprights 11g and the X-2 has 2x2" uprights that are 9guage so IMO it cancels out. X2 advantages - almost entirely welded,heavier, comes with band pegs and I think plate holders. Also the X2 is 100$ less. They seem to both have similar accessories for sale but band pegs, a dip bar and maybe a landmine attachment are all I foresee using. I have their landmine and love it/the 3 attachments I have (Viking press, t bar straight and v-handle row)

​

The "situation"

I need a rack soon and cannot go to a commercial gym as I'm immunosuppressed (transplant) to the point I'll catch an illness and get very ill as gyms are germ centers. Also, I have a garage gym minus a rack or squat stands. Recently made a purchase of the CAP 0B-86PBCK power bar for 170 and love it. I bought it bc my generic fake chrome bar bit the dust (posted here a week or so ago). Unfortunately my cheap squat rack broke (one of the upright/base welds bent enough I can't use it again). So need the rack now and can afford the Titan brand ones soon- I couldn't afford the Rogue (I would rather have a Rogue but I am not well off financially- I hope to be in a position in the next 3 years to afford Rogue and EliteFTS everything but alas today is not that day.

​

If you got to this point, thank you very much for reading and you are truly awesome.

​

Posted Dec 15, 2018, 7:25 PM UTC

622
kneejuice•

I just got the Titan T3 space saving wallmount, not sure if its an option for you but i’m getting ready to set it up, ill post pics..$160.00 18” depth version

3
catictOP•

I actually didn't look at that closely. Thank you, my fiancé would love not walking out and seeing a power rack in the garage taking up a 48''x50'' space lol.

​

edit: I looked and saw there's a 41" deep one which woudl be perfect but I don't think they have safety arms/pins, do they? That is something I need as I lift alone and have to bail out of a failed squat or bench(spotter arms). I wouldn't want to bail out by the wall. My decision for a full rack was also to minimize squat bailout damage and bench stuckage.lol

​

Thanks again though.

2
RedThain•

I have the x-3 flat foot which is 30” deep and it’s plenty for me, I can squat and deadlift in if fine. I don’t know about the box squats. It if you have the room I’d go 36” I believe they have the same weight capacity and I believe the t3 is higher actually

And as for Titan racks mine will last me my and my sons lifetime I don’t see anything I could do to damage it that would require me to want upgrade it. I saved around 60% off rouge. And I had no quality or shipping issues at all.

3
catictOP•

Thank you for the input, sincerely! I agree about Titan- I've never had any shipping or product issue with them (I've only owned their landmine and 45deg hyper but everything is good ESPESPECIALLY the 1.3" wide landmine rowing handles with the laser etched holes/name.

I decided against the 24" deep bc I chalked 2 lines behind my squat racks- a 24" and 36". I held the bar on my back and pretend unracked it, took 3 short steps and my heels were real close to the 24" mark. I'd feel uncomfortable free squatting or doing good mornings in a 24". I want to box squat in it bc the band pegs are in the bottom sides so I'd need to squat in the rack to use bands. Looks like I'll be going with the T-3 shorty unless I can find a better option because I have the room (have enough for a 4x5' rack space, once I buy some plate holders I'll have more.

​

1
onsite84•

I have no problems at all with my 24” but if I had the space, 36” would be a nice “luxury” that I would spring for.

3
catictOP•

Thank you- you're right, it IS a luxury to have 36" space. If I'd not asked Reddit, not gotten advice about racks- I'd have bought the 24" X2 and maybe not have been satisfied. I'm sure I would have made it work for squatting freely inside. Unfortunately the luxury of doing banded box squats is something I feel like having.

​

Appreciate the feedback and help.

2
OptimusPrice91•

I have the 24” X2 and if I were to do it again, I’d get the 36” T3, for a few reasons not necessarily related to the depth. But for box squats, I do have to do them outside the rack with spotter arms. It would be nice to be able to do them inside the rack but it’s just not enough space for me to sit back comfortably without hitting into the rack. But other than that, the 24” depth feels fine for most everything else, including squats without a box.

3
catictOP•

Thank you firstly,

Secondly you iterated exactly why I believe I need 36" of rack space- I do box squats with chains but have used bands before and plan on using them in the rack, and I'd need to be inside to do that. So I'll get the T3 or similar deeper rack.

2
OptimusPrice91•

Yeah I mean I was planning on maybe getting these:

https://www.titan.fitness/t3rkft.html?gclid=EAIaIQobChMIlr2Lqfai3wIVDsDICh3_Cg5gEAQYASABEgLvpPD_BwE

It doesn’t say they’re compatible with the X2 but I don’t see why they wouldn’t be. But that way I would be able to use bands when squatting out in front of the rack. I’m just worried about tripping over them lol

But I think the 36” T3 is a solid choice. I kind of like that it’s bolted together as well compared to welded on the sides like my X2. And sometimes having a 9 gauge rack feels like overkill, the 11 gauge steel on the T3 is enough for probably 99% of people.

3
catictOP•

Huh, so Maybe those will bolt onto the X-2 or could be modded to fit (grinder.) That is a great solution for band squats. Not to sound elitist but until someone does a few waves of box squats with accommodating resistance- particularly bands- they won’t quite understand how strong they can make you. My squat went from 405 to 475 in 9 weeks using 3 week cycles of 275+light bands, 295 + light bands and 275 + average bands for 3 wk waves the first time I used them. Heck with band pegs banded deadlifts may be possible in these racks (never done them). . Can you say why you like the bolted rack over the mostly welded one? I figured it’d be nicer to have a more welded one but mine have always been bolt together. And I agree the X-2 and T-3 are probably overkill for most people- Rogue and EFS DO make nicer higher quality racks but for the money Titan will do it for me. I read there’s a top level PLer who did or does a lot of training in s titan T or X series rack.

The other reason I want 36” now is I’m thinking about bow chain suspended good mornings or good mornings in general will probably be a lot easier in a deep rack. Again, very heavy and suspended GMs aren’t extremely common though I know plenty of guys around here are strong AF.

Thanks for the suggestion/input for a potential inexpensive banded squat option if I do end up with an X3 or X2 or even the T3.

1
OptimusPrice91•

I really fail to see why they wouldn’t fit the X2, the hole size and spacing are the same.

I’m a big fan of using bands on bench and squats (never really used them on deadlifts), I just can’t use them on box squats due to not being in the rack. I know they’re great for strength and speed but I mainly use them because I prefer the feel of using them for heavy work and having a more consistent resistance throughout the whole range of motion. Im weak in the hole in the squat and and off my chest for bench. So without accommodating resistance, a heavy weight for me feels very difficult in the bottom but extremely easy once I get a few inches out of the hole. I like the feeling of it being heavy at the bottom and also at the top.

As far as the bolted rack goes, it’s mainly due to the welds on it. If it was a Rogue rack with nice, solid looking welds I’d prefer that to a bolt together rack. But the welds on my X2 look terrible. Like not just to the point where they don’t look good but are strong, but it’s to the point where I don’t want the crossmembers bearing any weight knowing those horrible welds are the only thing keeping it together. I wanted to hang these spud straps for safeties, pin presses/squats, and also for good mornings:

https://www.spud-inc-straps.com/suspension-straps.html

But I don’t trust the welds on the side beams to bear all that weight. I’d put a hell of a lot more trust in 5/8” grade 8 bolts than I do the welds on my X2. But as far as structural integrity and adding rigidity to the rack, they serve their purpose: the rack is extremely solid.

The way I see it, I’ve seen a few people say they bought a 24” rack and wish they’d gotten a 36” rack (myself included), but I don’t think I’ve ever seen a person say they bought a 36” rack and wish they’d gotten a 24” rack lol.

2
twoforme2•

"I really wish I had less room inside this rack!" said nobody EVER!

3
catictOP•

Haha! Very true. I will admit I tend to overlook very easy to see things more often than I would like.

I mainly saw $price$ and full welds on the X2 but quickly realized I’d rather pay another $100 due to many reasons others here pointed out and it looks like I’m going to do just that.

1
maansmit•

I would get the 36” rack. I bought a 24” recently and wish I had gotten a deeper one.

2
catictOP•

That is a real concern of mine as it doesn't seem enough to box squat in, I appreciate it because it could be make or break.

Edit: Thank you- I just lost a lot of love for a 24". The X2 was in the lead. I take 3 steps back for my squats.

1
westcostrong•

36” without a doubt. If you don’t get a rack extension kit, the plates on the plate holders will eat up some of the workable space inside the rack.

And this may not be an issue for you, but the main reason I went with a T-3 is so that all of the accessories are compatible with my Titan yoke, which I use as a secondary rack.

2
catictOP•

Thanks for the suggestion- totally agree and that’s what I’m going with. I love the titan yoke idea and it wold be good to have that as squat stands plus a huge total body strength builder/conditioner.

I’m definitely buying the T-3 rack 36” and I didn’t think about plate storage taking up too much space but it will get in the way and I haven weight trees so I don’t really need them.

Thank you for your help and all others who chimed in and offered great advice or info. I’m happy I made this thread because there was a lot I assumed wrong and a lot I didn’t take into consideration. By far it appears the T3 cage is going to be the best one for me. So just thank you everyone.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1

T3 36 inch. Easy

1
elviscaprice•

24" is all I need. No sense in eating up valuable space with more. Plus moving the safeties is much easier on a 24".

0