Vision and storytelling - a struggle?

Straight out the gate, I'm new to photography. I started about 9 months ago and got addicted, well the day I got my DSLR and kit lens. Over the months I've got some basic lenses, spent nearly 150 hours watching YouTube tutorials, read 12 books and scoured countless articles and blogs, taken thousands and thousands of photographs, (5265 to be precise) most of which I've come to conclude are bad, some of them 'ok' and only about.. 50 I really like.

Recently I've been thinking about how I can make my photos better, more interesting.. Something other than just 'a nice photo'. Over the past few weeks I've been on a binge reading David duChemin's books and I think I finally understand why my photos are (or as least those 50 I'm quite proud of) nothing more than 'nice'.

They lack what he describes as 'vision' or 'story' which I completely get now. My photos don't speak to the viewer, they're just nice..

I've been trying to change that, take photos which can tell some sort of story, display emotion of some sort or make the viewer care/feel something.. And I'm struggling.. Really badly.. I can't seem to even come up with a story to tell, let alone tell it (which thinking about it might be the easy part)!

I don't know if that's because I'm still of a generalist of sorts, I've been shooting anything that really interest me, from mountains to beaches, portraits, animals, cityscape.. Everything.. I haven't found my corner or niche if you will. Maybe the 'vision' part will get easier when I do?

For now, I'm just gonna keep on trucking, practice more, read more, talk to other photographers and hope things will eventually click into place.

Do you shoot with a feeling or a vision in mind? Or just go for a nice looking photo? Have you felt a bit lost as to storytelling with your photography? Lastly, any suggestions/tips, anything and everything is appreciated!

Thank you!

Posted Dec 17, 2018, 8:24 AM UTC · edited

3513
lilgreenrosettahttp://www.davidcohendelara.com•

They lack what he describes as 'vision' or 'story' which I completely get now.

The word 'storytelling' is a bit overused and catches a lot of flack here, but I think it's probably the most useful concept in all of photography as long as you don't take it too literally.

When you break photography down to its most basic level, it is very similar to speaking. You make something, the viewer sees it, and it elicits a thought or feeling from them. It's communication. You're telling the viewer something, or merely suggesting something, or asking a question. You're talking to your audience through images.

If you think about it like that, the most important thing is that you have something to say. You can find words that sound nice or work on your diction and tone of voice, but none of that matters unless you know what you want to say. This is how a lot of photographers get stuck; they work on their technique instead of figuring out what they are trying to say.

Conversely if you DO know what you want to communicate, then suddenly everything makes sense. What you want to say will inform how you should speak. Some things are communicated better when said loudly, some things when said softly. Some things require complicated words and sentences, some things are better said simply. Sometimes you want to be clear and explicit, sometimes you want to be poetic.

Where it goes wrong for a lot of people is that they think that what they need to say has to be complicated or profound. That makes it difficult or scary, so instead they say something like 'I just want to show beauty' and avoid the question altogether.

But what you say doesn't have to be deep or complicated to be interesting. All that matters is that you choose what you want to talk about. What are you interested in? Which emotions or concepts live in your head? Which places or people are important to you? What would you like to share? What would you like to learn more about? Start there and the rest will follow.

And as you do this, try to think in terms of longer projects rather than single images. A story often takes a lot more than a single image to tell. An example I heard from a teacher was an assignment they gave about doing an intimate portrait, where you pick a subject you are close to and shoot them for an extended amount of time. Think about who they are, what they mean to you, what you would like to know or say about them. Do 200 photos a week for 3-4 weeks, pick out the 10 best a week, analyse them, get feedback from a mentor, then shoot more. Maybe combine portraits with stills or close ups of body parts or whatever you feel the story needs. By the end there should be dozens of good photos to choose from, but you pick 10 or 12 to tell the story. The result will be a body of work that is worth showing people because it's about something - the polar opposite of the meaningless pretty pictures you are struggling with now.

31
LostinGoido•

Thanks for this write up. Even though I'm not the OP, it has helped me a lot with understanding how I feel.

For me, it's just a feeling that I want to communicate. Almost like a spider sense, I feel something and want to capture it so that I express it to someone else.

I see it as prelinguistic. As soon as I try to describe it with words, it the feeling disappears. That's why I need a photo to communicate the feeling, because words will not suffice.

3
Mrcphoto•

The idea of speaking through your images seems much less daunting when you frame it as a series of images rather than trying do do it in one perfect image. A few notable photo journalists have done it as well as the usual masters of the art. Thanks for planting that idea. It's going to help me going forward.

1
borntobechubby•

I personally like to set a theme and try and follow it. That said, hoot for yourself. Just because your shots may not tell a story there’s always a story. To you at least.

3
Benlikesrocketsinstagram @bensheil•

To me, photography and storytelling isn't just about the photo. I always tell myself that my photography doesn't happen without the adventure. It's equally as much as about how I get to where and what I'm shooting than it is the photo itself. If there's an interesting story behind how I "got to" the photograph, the story of the photo will come naturally.

My piece of advice would be to find a passion that isn't photography and pursue that. Don't overthink the photography, just let the photography be a product of whatever it is else you're doing. Personally I love outdoors/travel/adventure - so I'll go out and do just that, explore the outdoors and go on adventures. I don't stress about the photos, but at the end of it I'll still have many and some great ones, and with them there'll also be many stories to tell.

Hopefully you get what I'm saying and I hope it's helped!

3
umutstreet21https://www.instagram.com/demigohan•

This sounds like me in the moment, I go out at least once a week to do street photography, but I just don't see "it". I feel like my "vision" is broken somehow, maybe it is because of the season maybe because I'm not so focused anymore.

I have this feeling since a few weeks and only yesterday I really started to think about why this is happening and I think it is because I have no project or as you said a theme when going out.

Maybe self-assign yourself a project? I'm also looking for ideas on what kind of project I should start...

2
FlorissVDV•

I'm by no means perfect with this but something I generally try to keep in mind is this: when I look back at some of my favourite photos I've taken, they all have a story or memory behind them. They're objectively nice photos but what makes them more special than other photos I've taken that aren't my favourites is how they remind me of that day or the way I felt in that moment.

When I go out shooting I try to reverse or pre-empt that. Why am I out shooting right now? How am I feeling in this moment, this day, this week or this stage in my life? And then, how can I best convey that feeling in just one photo?

For me, my favourite memories often revolve around the people that were there with me. Therefore, I'm trying to incorporate a subject into my photos more when I can (easier said than done usually).

Sometimes this works well, other times that's really difficult to do. This is both the beauty and challenge with photography: all you have to tell your story is one frame. I'm still on my path to get better at telling a story with a photo and it seems like you are as well. Stay curious to learn, read/watch other photographers that inspire you and talk to others for tips/tricks they use. Try to relish the challenge and enjoy that journey. A good photo is better than no photo at all and when I look back at photos I took when I just started about 2 years ago, I'm still really glad I took them no matter how imperfect they are.

2
cholley_doo•

probably one of the best things that helped me is using a 50mm lens or similar.

it will force you to compose more and be more in tune/involved in the shot.

all of these modern cameras and lenses have a lot of training wheels that can lead to bad habits or prevent users from learning anything.

the local college makes photography students get a camera similar to an AE-1 for this reason. some of my favorites were shot on my AE-1 and a 50.

2
hi-im-that-guyinstagr.am/lucancoutts•

There's a saying - your first 1000 photos will be your worst

I'd go so far as to say your first 10,000 will be your worst

You've learned a lot, but you're only about halfway there. Personally, I've shot hundreds of thousands, but the more I learn about photography, the more I realize I know absolutely nothing

Keep pushing through man, you'll notice the pieces will start to fall into place

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
hi-im-that-guyinstagr.am/lucancoutts•

That's valid, and I have some favourites from when I first started out, but it personally pushed me to try way harder and learn more. Everyone is different but my comment was intended to be motivational.

2
anonymoooooooose•

There's a saying - your first 1000 photos will be your worst

The saying is your first 10,000 photos, and it dates from the film era when people took a lot more care and didn't spray and pray, the modern equivalent is a lot higher than 10,000.

2
dddreck•

Some years ago there was always one short film playing before every screening at my local cinema. It contains only mundane exterior shots of supermarkets, banks ect. from my city, with original sound. In the end the viewer was spotlighted that all this were locations of former cinemas, which are now closed.

I think that film was a good example for your problem. Without context the shots would be bland and dull, but with this little information in the end it become something you could call a story. The unspectacular nature of the shots fitted exectly for the topic of the film. Places of culture changed into places of daily routine.

What I want to say with this, that context and the movtivation why you take a picture of something matters, and as others in this thread said, it helps to thnik about a series with a overriding topic.

2
ChristopherMarv•

context and the movtivation why you take a picture of something matters

Not to someone looking at your picture. It has to stand by and for itself.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0