r/socialism•
bleer95

How to socialize a military?

I was thinking this over recently, and one of the biggest issues with militaries (not just the American military, but most, if not all, modern militaries) is that they fall into the same capitalist/proletariat relationship that many jobs do: the means of production (service) are owned by an elite few and the structure of the military is (at least to my knowledge) anti-democratic. I'm not saying a socialized military would fix all of the issues inherent to a military, but I was curious to see what R Socialism thought of how one could socialize a military and make it's membership more democratic: military referendums on wars/campaigns? giving the MOP (weapons, uniforms, rations etc...) to soldiers? Abolishing the general and political class? Superior transparency over campaigns? Better healthcare/wages etc...?

​

Moreover, do you think this would make a change to the culture of a military for the better or worse?

Posted Dec 20, 2018, 4:58 AM UTC

812
rjbradley•

Community self-defense militias replacing the military

The imperialist military we have would disappear in a socialist country, as would the military-industrial complex creating this forever war

ThEre are also anarchist militias in Rojava in which units elect commanding officers

7
LungsOfKeif•

Your first sentence forshadows your last sentence, neat.

4
bleer95OP•

Community self-defense militias replacing the military

​

interesting. I'd imagine there would have to be a centralized coordination center in case a large scale threat emerges which individual self-defense militias cannot handle.

​

The imperialist military we have would disappear in a socialist country

​

I wonder what allowing soldiers to vote on wars (IE: military referendums on campaigns or wars) would do. Most decision making is made by generals and politicians detached from the concerns of the soldiers themselves. No guarantee that the soldiers vote the right way every time, but it might be enough to avoid invasions like Grenada or Nicaragua (1912-1933) which presented little in the way of a credible threat to the US and had essentially no reward for Americans. It would make American warmongering more transparent too, which would allow for more effective public mobilization against a war.

4
ShittyInternetAdviceSankara•

I think there is a middle ground between a reactionary imperialist army and decentralized community militias, which I do not see how they would be adequate to defend a revolution particularly over a large territory

3
Trashcan_Gourmet•

A military represents the class interests of whatever the dominant class in their society is. In capitalist states, this means the military serves the class interests of their national bourgeoisie. In most countries, this means that the military serves mainly as an internal security force to repress dissent. In imperialist countries where superwages funded through exploitation of the global working class have created a mostly placid labor aristocracy, they advance imperialism abroad. The key task of a socialist government is to ensure that the military serves the interests of the working class instead. Any socialist government that fails to do that will be overthrown by the military, like Chile in 1973. Conversely, any socialist government that renders the military ineffective because they think they don’t need it or implement the kind of idealist proposals kicking around in this thread will be overthrown when they lack the means to defend themselves against internal and external reactionary forces. So a socialist gov needs to make sure that the soldiers are properly educated and reasonably paid, and make sure that officers are representative of the larger force instead of being an insular upper class enclave as they are in many capitalist countries.

That’s pretty much it though. All the ideas about voting on campaigns and community defense forces kicking around here are idealist and naive, to the point that they would pose severe threats to the survival of any socialist government that tried to implement them. This was the lesson the Bolsheviks learned in the Russian Civil War. Early on, the Red Army tried to operate in a democratic manner with elected officers. Turns out that was a terrible idea and a clear chain of command was needed to have an effective fighting force. When Trotsky became military commissar, he rolled back these reforms and the Red Army was eventually able to defend the Russian Revolution from the Whites and foreign interventionists. That’s how a socialist military will work.

4
Berlin_CommuneRote Ruhrarmee•

You could look up the Hamburg Points from the German Revolution. They handled it pretty good back then.

3
venasabiertasMLM•

Look into the changes in the PLA in China during the socialist era

2
0†
leninism-humanismLeninist •

Shouldn't we learn more from the Red Guards(later Red army) that consisted of workers and peasants which managed to crush both the White Army, Makhnos peasant bandit army, the "green armies" lead by the "social-revolutionaries"(which belonged to the old state which wanted to continue the war and oppression) and so on?

4

I think there is a lot to be learned from all revolutionary movements and armies. There is a lot to be said for the Black Army's horizontal organization, with soldier's councils and elected commanders. It must have been good because some 40,000 members of the Red Army defected to join the Black Army. In any case, what good is it to compare who beat who? The real enemy is fascists and bourgeois governments today, not different stripes of leftists from a century ago.

0
Trashcan_Gourmet•

We’re talking about socialist militaries here, not murderous gangs of reactionary bandits

3

Your name is quite apt. I believe you have been eating at the trashcan of ideology.

0