Why do boxed cakes taste different from scratch cakes?
Aside from the additives in boxed mixes that enable a particularly moist, fluffy cake, I vaguely recall reading that there's another factor at play. I want to say it's because most American scratch cakes are butter cakes ("cream the butter together with the sugar"), but boxed cake mixes are based on a different type (they have oil, so maybe chiffon cakes?). Kind of like the fact that canned frosting is based on seven-minute frosting, which is why some people like it better than scratch frosting (which tends to be buttercream). Edit: Whoops, seems my post is just full of misremembered misinformation. Thanks for pointing out that they're both American buttercream, u/MrE008.
I've been googling and I can't find anything to back up my vague memories, though.
Posted Dec 20, 2018, 5:29 PM UTC · edited
Fat is the main part of the story, but for non-chocolate cakes the powdered eggs, powdered milk, and bleached cake flour also contribute to the flavor of boxed cake.
Edit to add: canned frosting is mostly American style buttercream, which to many is overly sweet. Italian and swiss buttercreams don't can well, as the emulsion is much more temperamental.