[Discussion] views on hotrail pickups

DISCUSSION

Just curious to see what the community thinks of them and who prefers them to a humbucker. I'd also like to know what bands have used them in their songs. So far the only one I know is Iron Maiden.

Posted Dec 23, 2018, 4:47 AM UTC

311
guitarparty•

Some people say they sound a bit shrill, I’d tend to agree with that but they’re not bad pickups by any stretch. At the end of the day, I’d personally go with a full-size humbucker.

2
Grizly2000•

I think in my axe it comes down to the height of the pickup. If I want it to sound dirtier I increase the height.. I currently have it as low as it goes and sounds great

1
CilariousHunt•

I think they sound fine for rock and heavier music, my problem is I think they look stupid

2
blessed_anarchy•

I totally agree, I can’t get past the look of them, regardless of how they sound!

1
Koleon5•

On a clean amp setting they sound a bit shrill for my liking. Been playing a telecaster lately with one in it and I find myself using the neck pickup more than the hotrail for that reason. But in any rock/metal playing it sounds full like a humbucker to me. Not as deep of sound as a humbucker but it's got the same amount of balls to it I'd say.

1
Grizly2000•

I bought a SSS strat. I thought I wanted that classic sound. I was wrong. I put a hotrail in the bridge and I love it.

1
itsallgonetohell•

I have one in the bridge of my Mexican Strat. It's as full and as ballsy as any other Seymour Duncan I have, including a Nazgul, a JB, a Full Shred, a Distortion, and a Custom Custom. People say (I think it's more like 'they've heard') it's 'thinner,' or 'shrill,' etc. but I don't agree. I don't like ice-picky gain sounds, and the Hot Rails doesn't do that. It's plenty warm and ballsy. I dunno, maybe I just have a really bitchin' Strat. But it's fuller sounding than the Duncan Distortion, and it has less high end than a JB.

1
Hudson1•

They have their place. I would never put them on all of my guitars, but I have hot rails installed in a favorite Stratocaster and love it.

1
DigitalDamageOutputOP•

I was going to get a new ax but decided just to keep my strat that already has 500k pots with all hotrails configuration. I'm not too keen on how hot these sound. They are very bright and treble heavy. I might just get a pickguard loaded with 250k pots and single coils and replace the bridge with a hotrail but I'm not sure if I'll be missing out on anything if I do. I play a mix of music from metal to just chord stuff. I do like using my neck pup for riffing too but at this point I really don't know which direction to take.

2
Hudson1•

Mine is special purpose. I call it my "Pumpkins" guitar since it lends it's tone very well for playing Smashing Pumpkins and getting those overblown almost buzzsaw-overdrives and super fuzzy Mig Muff tones. They're also good for those sonic-bomb Grunge-era songs.

I have another Strat that I've got rigged up for a more "Jimi" sound, and then another one for Clapton/Gilmour. Like I said, I'd never run them for all of them, but I think they definitely have their place.

1
flekkzoJackson,Fender,Chapman,Ibanez,Fender,Chapman,Jackson,Jackson•

Go big or go home. I like them on my HHH (Dave Murray sig) and they sound great. I would consider them a type of pickup unto themselves the way single coils are separated from jazzmasters or p90s.

I think I might be an odd bird at this point, but I prefer to not mix pickup types. I prefer HH over HSH, HHH over HSS, etc. I have a full-size H, small H, small H (maybe Hhh would be a good way to describe it) and I find the setup oddish.

Gotta treat the tone differently than SSS and HH, can’t just plug in without changing something around.

1