Welcome Christmas TAC Honest Review and Newcomers Tips

Hi everyone, 
(I'm not a native speaker please excuse my language)

Veterans leaving, newcomers arriving... the wheel of life keeps on turning, such is the law of the gacha. I wanted to take some time to greet the newcomers during christmas. I initially thought about making a review of the game to balance the salt a bit, but recently positive opinions have been downvoted on sight so I decided to write something I'd like to see if I connected for the first time now : a mish-mash of personal opinion, tips and merry christmas wishes. As an introduction, I'm a fairly dolphinish player, with a budget of 100 to 150€ each month, and the capacity to play ~50h each week with various levels of attention. I'm also a fairly obsessive player which makes me a prime target for gachas, lootbox & MM, my only "safeguard" being the fact that I tend to get bored quickly once novelty wears out, which is between 6 months and 1 year for MMO or good gachas. Also I'm a heavy player on all supports since the mid-eighties, so I'm not strictly a gacha player (I typically finished all the Final Fantasy main games and spinoffs)

WHAT YOU SHOULD EXPECT FROM TAC

  • TAC is a very deep SRPG. You name a mecanism, it's probably implemented : elemental priorities, improbable jobs combination, backstab, height management, unit throws, block creation, shields, flying units, time walk or time skip, unit switch, kiting, silencing, stunning, mana stealing & transfer, buffs & debuffs. Although some mecanisms are less used, occasionally some of the hardest maps will make use of it and then, it feels extremely rewarding. UX 3.0 is expected next spring TBD along with long-awaited Kaigan (additional limit break)
  • TAC has millions of storylines : a deep solo campaign with 3 intertwined stories, 2 additional solo campaigns (Magni Historia & Sacred Stones), seasonal short stories adding various flavour to story protagonists. Although main story line first chapter is the weakest, it gets better and while it stays within usual anime tropes, it's perfectly comparable to a standard Final Fantasy game. New chapters are added every other week, giving you incentives to come back. At that point, I'd say you have at least 30 to 50 hours of solo gameplay just for the storyline, without any excessive grind.
  • TAC has lots of game modes : manual or automated PVP, cooperative PVE with 3 other players (my favorite), various challenges such as 85 floors Veda Tower and various milestones with color or unit constraints which are among the hardest challenges in the game even for the best players.
  • TAC is fairly grindy, but not maddingly grindy except on very rare occasions (777 armor of wrath shards). Auto-mode is here, which will enable you to run through 99% of the grind provided you can click every 1~2 min for an hour (typically while watching a TV show with your waifu), and concentrate your attention on hardest challenges. To fully appreciate the game and get most rewards you will need at least 30 to 60 minutes of play everyday. But this game can provide hours of varied gameplay everyday for minmaxers. It would like to remind people that TAC is exceedingly generous in term of free stamina, meaning even F2P can play several hours without hitting a stamina wall.
  • TAC is very successful in Japan and on Global Server (GL) we have roughly a major collaboration every other month : Final Fantasy, Disgae, Full Metal Alchemist, etc. each of them comes with special units, storyline and challenges. Although TAC is far behind games such as Brave Exvius or Azur Lanes, its population is comparable to Honkai 3rd impact and regularly break top 25 grossing apps in some countries. GL population is roughly stable since 6 months.
  • TAC has long been considered among the most F2P games around, but acquisition phase is now mostly over, meaning editor is tightening monetization (alienating part of the community) : a good reroll and solo content rewards will enable you to plow through most of the game, however the hardest milestones/maps (such as current "Challenge of limits") will require shelling some cash. Basically here is the progression you can expect given the cash you put in the game, provided you have a good starting roll
    • Stricly F2P : 100% of the solo game now, 80% of optional maps within 6 months. Earn a major carry unit (SS) once or twice a year, in addition of starting roll. S units will come quickly though.
    • 7€/month suscription : 100% of the solo game now, 80% of optional maps within 3 months and remaining 20% within a year. Earn a SS unit every quarter.
    • 7€/month suscription + 50€ one-of : 100% of the solo game now, 80% of optional maps within 1 months and remaining 20% within 6 to 9 months : Earn a SS unit every 3~4 weeks.
    • 50 to 100€/month : 100% of the game accessible within 3 to 6 months. Earn a SS unit every other week. This is typically my budget and I feel anything above is luxury for now for challenge purpose (for collecting or maxing all units this is obviously too little, as costs increase exponentially : I suspect a budget of at least 1000-2000€/month would be the minimum to get & max everything)
  • Manual PVP is only a few days old and not well balanced at all, mostly due to a recent unit called "Roxanne". The good news is that you can currently reroll for her, which you definitly should if you've just started.
  • Community is great and helpful, and current rants are mostly due to veterans being burned out and purely F2P players feeling gumi's grip tightening. Personnally I've spent 300 hours on the game so far and I don't really understand how people who don't pay at all for a game can complain, but some sure do.
  • For obsessive personalities like me, you should however be aware that all freemium games are designed to exploit human weaknesses and this one, especially from now on, is no exception. Obviously players expectations vary but even the lowest subscription (7€/month) might be frustrating unless you play only on your way to work and are patient as an oak. The sweet spot for me would probably be around 50€/month and I'm quite a bit above, which brings me to saying that the game is not F2P friendly anymore, although it is still in the lower range of most gachas aimed at hardcore gamers.

Overall, TAC is one of the best SRPG I've ever played in term of overall package : content, gameplay, storyline, characters, production value and community. While I rate it slightly below tenors of the genre such as FFT or Disgaea, I feel the constant stream of additional stuff to do is really worth the "sweet spot" of extra cost, eg the price of a new game every month, while fun lasts for you.

​

NOW IS A GREAT MOMENT TO START

You have probably found lots of guides and resources online. On the right side of reddits, precious links such as alchemistcodedb.com , the wiki and the discord with lots of friendly veterans whales to get advices or specific mercenary. Read those to get a glimpse of the complexity of the game, this message is no substitute for beginners guides. However as the game is overwhelming at first, I wanted to focus on the essentials.

  • The most precious resource in the game are "elemental shards", used to limit break your best units. Solo mode will give you quite a bit but then it will be the draught forever. Always give them to a SS not-farmable unit (ideally only on MH/GLEX/SSM best units) and when in doubt, ask on the megaquestion thread.
  • You have another 8 days to reroll for Roxanne, the best and most versatile attacker in the game. Ideally since we are in Magni Historia month, try to gun for Minerva as well, which is among the best support in the game. If you had only ONE job to keep you busy during the long wait of Christmas, this would be it : Shadow Broker.
  • Clear at least the 2 first chapters (logi/dias + edgar story) asap for 10K+ free gems and lots of equipments, bonus and hard quest unlock. You can skip story while reading beginners guide and auto every level with a good carry, and catch up story later (thru settings).
  • Take at least 1 key tank and 1 magic or support unit from each color and START FARMING their 3 Shards (hard quests) FROM DAY ONE. In about 2 months you will be able to put up a good rainbow team for hardest content and some of the monocolor challenges (like Veda tower) ​

That's it ! Enjoy the game, share your enthousiasm and achievements on reddit ...and spend time with your family :-)

​

Merry Christmas fellow alchemists !

PS : I dedicate the thread to $hamu, Zakfarias and Vorce without whom I wouldn't have been able to clear Challenge of limits monocolor challenges. Thanks mates your mercs rock !!

Posted Dec 25, 2018, 1:35 PM UTC · edited

5463
Shaiandra•

While I agree with a number of your sentiments, I personally wholly disagree with the amount of money you need to invest to enjoy the game. Admittedly I've been playing for a long time, so I'm not sure how much money you need to catch up starting now, but based on experience I'd say a Pact (or even f2p) player doesn't need anywhere close to a whole year before they can clear all PvE content.

I don't know about others, but if anyone tried to sell me a game by saying "Oh you 'only' need to spend $50/month to have fun!" I wouldn't even look at that game.

21
hav00xno need to cook, babe•

Same. I'm a 1y1m old player who only bought a pact once, and i can clear any content. I obviously don't have all the units but as a F2P you can really get far. Whaling is only for those who like to grind on pvp.

11
stewart0•

I've been playing since week one, and spent a good amount. Still can't clear all the PvE content. FMA EX+ missions will forever haunt me.

4
EvyxedFluffy•

I made my new account on the anniversary and have been able to clear all pve content (excluding challenger of limits ultrahard) as strictly f2p.

my old account which was only 5 months old would've been able to auto all the challenging content, still strictly f2p, spending money in this game is entirely optional unless you're a completionist.

4
eltsyrOP•

thanks a lot for your feedback, having played only 3 months I lack a bit of perspective. Congrats to being able to clear all PVE as a pact player, this is awesome !

3
Liesianthes350 coins ticket = ROY!!•

and current rants are mostly due to veterans being burned out and purely F2P players feeling gumi's grip tightening.

kek. Say that to the ones who are known to the community making tier list, guides, even a regular here but leave the game.

I'm full f2p that got ALL MAIN COLLAB CHARS (Gil, Noc, Laharl, Ed, Roy, Aranea) and even Zain with ROXANNE. Everyone's dream characters but I did quit since Gumi finally showed its true colors and it is not healthy for the future of the game, be it f2p, minmow, dolphin or whales.

This game is hit in Japan for it's user friendly to all type of users with HQ's being released as close as 2 months, nice freebies and GL overhaul that into greediness. Even whales are not happy by those changes.

Still visiting Discord and you can notice how the lively place has got less people having a chat compared to before that it was always having a nice discussion. Still even logging in to get rewards daily and log out but my ranking hasn't even dropped to 4k after not playing since 2nd week of December and that's too low for a rank down.

Edited: Checked the Discord server for gacha and rerolls. It was sad to see seeing only 2 or 3 post of people who posted their pulls compared to the usual ones of being flooded after reset knowing the 24hr free summon reset.

15
VinnyValient:Alaia:•

I disagree with the story being comparable to Final Fantasy (in particular 7, 8 and 9). Great review, very informative and useful. Thanks!

10
eltsyrOP•

thank you for your feedback ! Having replayed FF7 recently I tend to find that the [spoiler]death of A****[/spoiler] really was the outstanding element of an otherwise rather standard story. Typically I find Lost Odyssey much more audacious and well written. However I agree, at that time FF7 story was revolutionary and the overall package was stunning.

5
-Belphegor-•

fuq ff8!!!

1
VinnyValient:Alaia:•

Oh yeah, I forgot I hated FF8. (Damn that Draw system... 3 years later still drawing...)

1
DreadedZeals•

. . . Gj

9
stewart0•

Bonus tip : I personally think the current 2500 gems x10 banner with 150 shards for featured character is good. It should give you another carry unit at MLB15.

It doesn't include the unit. Better off buying 25 Roxanne or Minerva shards

7
eltsyrOP•

you're right, I'll remove the tip I had forgotten that.

1
stewart0•

I did the same yesterday and just assumed it included the unit subconsciously, cause as a holiday deal it is just too bad otherwise.

1
DeusExAcumine•

I also picked it up yesterday as a new player who assumed the 150 shards would come with the unit (like the intro unit a while back). Managed to work out pretty well fortunately as I picked up 150 neica shards which allowed me to instantly get her to LB15 (I snagged her with the free 5 star unit selector), making her the second best unit on my squad and I also pulled Gormalas who I'd been farming for and had LB12 worth of shards for. Looking again at the list of what I could have pulled, probably the best possible outcome.

1
stewart0•

Grats. I chose Neica from the 5* selector too, but only have her at LB10 from souls coins as a week one veteran lol. Hopefully she is farmable in 8 days. Probably the best one to have gotten.

1
-Belphegor-•

i had gem and pulled that banner wand ended up with 150 zofia shards... i still dont have zofia lol fuq that banner

1
stewart0•

??? Zofia shouldn't have even been possible for the shards. I'd yell at support. Though personally I'd take the Zofia shards, even though I don't own her, in the hope I pull her. Gumi probably screwed up as normal, considering the banner details are broken.

1
SuperEndriu•

So you say you don't understand f2p players complaining. I think, while there is no entitlement in a gacha game, be it p2w or f2p, complaining is not a prerogative of those who pay. All players contribute to the success of a game and f2p have all the rights in the world to voice their opinion. Negative decisions affect the whole player base not just p2w.

7
Liesianthes350 coins ticket = ROY!!•

Nah, he's just turning blind eye to those spenders who are not even happy with the changes that voiced out their disappointment. You can notice how this community is becoming silent with less people compared to months before.

10
eltsyrOP•

I understand because obviously the game is less generous now than before (or more P2W), and complaining about worse situation is very human indeed. However even now, the amount of quality playtime you get for free is staggering. That's why this review was for newcomers.

3
Kirito30The Strongest Samurai•

For the most part F2Ps keep a game afloat. They are brave souls who will do the content without top tier units and make real F2P strats.

Ushi making a video in his Whale account with multiple teddies and top tier Equips is not the least setup. Hell it is not even the optimal setup.

You really don't want a game with just P2Ps it will go down hill faster than the balance when Roxanne was in.

3
Dm042447•

Game success is not how many whale a game have... But the overall numbers of players. Keeping everyone happy should be a priority... Less players base, less community less whale... Also less ad clicking. It works for every game... For example, marvel contest of champion... It is top 24 gross iOS game... They banning whale cheater left and right... Many threaten to leave, but game still going strong for 4 years.

Some players complain is understandable... Some of them are just outright ridiculous.... The numbers of ridiculous complain drown the legit one.

6
Kirito30The Strongest Samurai•

Most I agree with but can't let this slide.

Some players complain is understandable... Some of them are just outright ridiculous.... The numbers of ridiculous complain drown the legit one.

I have yet to find a complain which was ridiculous and support that by lots of other people.

I mean everyone here can't take collective responsibility for everything that is posted. However if they do support something ridiculous then do show.

1
Hour_BetStalked by Michael•

TAC is a very deep SRPG*.*

cough cough

​

You have Roxy who solve almost everything

7
eltsyrOP•

well Roxy doesn't solve monocolor challenges which are imho the hardest challenges.

8
Hour_BetStalked by Michael•

The key word is almost

1
eltsyrOP•

Any rainbow roster of free SS unit such as Shayna/Neica/Vettel which people are given when they start the game will stomp on 90% of game content if JM3.

For me the endgame is clearly the monocolor challenges and Roxy will solve only 15% of your problems.

This being said, I could clear the monocolor challenges of current 'challenge the limits' only with a Roxy Merc XD

2
Hour_BetStalked by Michael•

Since when they are free, aren't they plain gacha units. We can only call them free if there is no limit in farming them or the shards are simply given in the milestones, enough to MLB.

Fair enough that a triple JM unit can clear most content, that is some grind to do.
The problem is Roxy is stupidly strong to solo most content right out of the box with only one job mastered. It's pretty much easy mode until you can't use her.

​

Monocolour isn't that bad if you play long enough. Same origin would be hell though. The number of units from some region is so damn few.

Wait for Babel Chronicles, you have to think (and probably fail a lot) how to finish them without cheating a guide. If Gumi SG buff it, it might become unsolvable.

2
Zneger•

Tips for newcommers , Reroll untill Roxanne pop!

5
VincEndrakeOne Punch Waifu•

Extra tip; When Roxanne does pop, rush Magni Historia with a Merc until Chapter 3 and farm her equips.

8
stewart0•

Only need to farm 80 too. Game gives you one complete equipment, and a complete diagram from missions or milestones. I see them constantly as a harsh reminder when using diagram pieces in place of gold pots.

3
votris11•

One problem with that plan. Most people don't have Soren as a Merc.

2
-Belphegor-•

games cool just not much going on right now unless ur a new playa

4
scrawnypastydude•

Just wanted to add a tip for all the ones currently rerolling - it's rather hardcore, though. While rerolling I realized Roxanne is in the pool but not on focus. If you get her and Minerva on step 1 you hit the jackpot imo. I didn't and had to go the hard way of grinding another 6,5k gems from story and challenge missions. At step 4 you get a ticket which may or may not be minerva, lol. Overall I did this process three times, sigh, but succeeded on one account, pulling Minerva on 4th step and from the ticket. If you came that far it's easy going from now on, grind another 2,5 gems and do the 5th step for the shards tickets. I got lucky and pulled a dupe Klima and got 50 Minerva shards, from the selector and the ticket. Minerva is lv.70 now. At first I thought a 500gems reroll (and saving after that) would be best but I am glad I did what I did. Edit: grinding through story is time consuming. You may want to do it fast. Do it on auto and always hire Roxanne or Gilga mercs. They are free until you hit lv.50. Quests don't consume ap until you hit lv.21, start claiming story milestones for gems AFTER. Don't worry about building your units, the mercs do the job.

3
eltsyrOP•

wow you're persistent XD Reminds me when I was gunning for a Laharl when he was not on booster rates when I've started. Rerolled >100 times and almost gave up the game before even starting oO

1
scrawnypastydude•

Let me put it this way: I don't have the budget to buy any gems so I rather start strong. At first I wanted to save gems but those units seemed worth the trouble. My plan is to save 17,5k gems for an OP unit selector ticket, lol.

2
eltsyrOP•

you're off to a fantastic start then ! FMA EX+ Flame and Hawk traumatized me so much that I'm so happy to have a shielding unit of my own !

2
scrawnypastydude•

On second thought I might buy the pact after xmas - 7€ won't kill me and based on my calculations it will double my gem income. How many free gems do we get per month beside the dailies?

1
Dm042447•

Good intro for newby.. it does give a decent perspective of where the game is at. Cost factor and progression depend sometimes on luck (gacha) and how active you are in this game like many other game. A person who just login to collect daily won't advance far without doing all the quest, mp and maximize all the gears, etc. Some people even do mp for equipment, multiple gears, resources, etc... Aside from beating extremely challenging quest.

3
Hoezell•

Welp, tried spending my last gems but didn't get Roxanne.

Been lurking since Fate collab (didn't get Gil), but missed FF and Disgaea ones. Since then I've been hoarding gems and now trying but Roxanne doesn't come regardless how much I try. The fact that I need a unit to play hard content properly is kinda toxic and gives me 0 motivation to spend money in this. I'm done. Good luck to you all.

3
takato99Salt Knight•

"...GL population is roughly stable since 6 months."

I don't really think so. Last months choices made a lot of people leave, even the biggest whales / Oldest players couldn't bare it anymore.

2
eltsyrOP•

Old people die all the time but the earth population is still increasing. Personally I've started 3 months ago and 47 out of my 48 friend list have been active in the last 12h. If player average tenure on the game is say 6 months, it's perfectly normal that veteran from day one need to trim their friend list regularly.

That being said, the active players (>1h/day) population is indeed down 20% since FMA collab samsung smartphone worldwide, which should be statistically representative enough. I've compared to a few other comparable games to check for a potential christmas effect and indeed population took a hit. However Gumi is currently trying to monetize the game a bit more, which mean they might accept to loose 20% of F2P to earn 30% more, which would make the game more sustainable. I don't think anyone here can draw conclusions without having insider information on Gumi freemium model which are as confidential as they get.

3
Hour_BetStalked by Michael•

There is sales data from sensor tower. From what I gather, sales has been declining. At it's peak, gl made more money than jp but now, not even half of what jp is making.

You can estimate player counts from download counts. Although it is more likely that download count is several times larger than player counts due to rerolling.

2
eltsyrOP•

very interesting ! didn't know that site. Actually TAC is in much better shape than what I had in mind. 500k of monthly revenue should pay a few dozens people which seem largely enough to make the game sustainable at least in 2019.

For reference at 20k of monthly revenue, Fantasy War Tactics is still operating (although barely...)

Azur Lane is considered a huge success with many more players but it's actually very close to TAC gross revenue.

thanks you for the heads up !

https://ibb.co/RB2nLqq

https://ibb.co/CnMqQBZ

https://ibb.co/7GQkNZh

https://ibb.co/JtxKR3k

4
Hour_BetStalked by Michael•

Very close? It doubles. Azur Lane probably earn most from dolphins since it is very F2P friendly.

JP raked 800k from android and 1M from iOS last month, probably some hundred thousands from DMM games. A much smaller market making more profit make me question if the business practice is what make the huge difference.

It's not Gumi SG business practice that worry me the most, it is their apparent lack of concern for quality. We has been having bad and stupidly awkward translation, code appearing in text and some game breaking bug. There is also stupidly underwhelming GLEX buff that as good as nothing (what does 30 more HP does to a level 85 unit anyway?). At this point, I'm pretty sure that they don't have translator cum editor and don't do beta or playtest before launching updates.

1
SuperEndriu•

Just some minor issues: Saying there will be a draught forever for elemental shards is not really true and sounds pretty demotivating. Also, MH and GLEX aren't they one and the same thing?

1
eltsyrOP•

I wasn't sure for GLEX and MH, you're probably right !

as for the shards, what is a bit misleading is that you quickly get 80 to 100 shards of each colour when you clear the storylines milestones...then it trickles much more slowly. I'd say on average we earn roughly 10 shards of each element every months between new events and daily freebies...amirite ?

1
Kirito30The Strongest Samurai•

Nope.

That is 60 Shards a month and that is not true.

For a new player may be but for Vets no.

There is 35 from Login and 10-15(best case) from 1-2 Event so it will reach 45. There are many events now but most of the times it is just not like this. There is close to 1 Event a Month so as to make sure the content doesn't feel stale. And until now they were making content harder so FMA and others are lost for a long time(JP has a re-run so I will not say lost permanently)

2
eltsyrOP•

yeah I seemed optimistic. so let's say 7-8 shards a month by element, this is the main reason I think the game has lost its F2P friendly label.

2
Liesianthes350 coins ticket = ROY!!•

GLEX are maps specifically made for GL like EX+ on some month before.

1
SuperEndriu•

I thought it stands for global exclusive - was not the point anyway

1
illidan_1999Neica is life.•

Wait, we get a new story chapter every week? More like a month.

1
eltsyrOP•

between MH, SSM , main story and side events I'd say at least twice a month

1