S03E10 Spoiler - Theory for the next "reveal"
If this theory happens to be wrong (very likely) then treat this post as a shirtpost fan fic i guess. But I hope I'm Doug-Forcetting on this. But whatever here goes:
While making his case in front of the Good Place committee, Michael's gonna take a closer look in the Book of Doug and see that Elleanor's dad and Jason's dad (Doug Shellstrop and Doug Mendoza) both have a point total that is inexplicably close to Doug Forcett's. In fact, everyone in the book has the same score, within 5 to 10%. Doug is still an outlier but his score is only like 10% higher than the average points of all the other Dougs in the book.
It's pretty much guaranteed that the Book of Doug will be significant, as that's the title of the next episode and Michael made sure to take it with him and it was explicitly pointed out. And then why would there be two more minor characters called Dougs in this show? Can't be a coincidence.
More theory because why not:
Turns out that the Accountants really are doing a good job keeping track of the point value of every action. It's all flawless on that end. It's just that over 500 years ago, something changed, and now it doesn't really matter what you do or don't do, cause these "actual free will points" are only worth around 5% of your actual total, and the remaining 95% is all bad, bad stuff, in general. Basically, just being a human automatically makes you a scumbag. You live on stolen land, eat food that was grown in exploitation, the energy that provides your comfort is killing the planet, and everything you buy contributes to a whole system of exploitation. The morally correct thing to do would be to completely live off the grid and grow everything yourself, kinda like Doug Forcett, but even then, that's morally neutral at best! I can see points like "You don't get a reward for not killing somebody" and "well everyone's guilty of something" being used by the Good Place committee people. Then the gang turns to Chidi to make a case using moral philosophers who argue that people are a product of their environment and that all those "de facto bad points" shouldn't count.
So even if you raise, like, a thousand dollars for charity or whatever, that's still not nearly enough to make it into TGP because you're still a human scumbag who partook in the destructive system, and it's basically impossible to not be a part of the system. The whole thing's forked up and it dooms all humans. I could even see something like one of the Bad Place demons helped out Columbus get to America because they know it'll lead to more de facto bad points for everyone on the long term.
Posted Dec 29, 2018, 4:13 AM UTC
This is, in a nutshell, Augustine’s social anthropology - humans, being fallen, create inherently corrupt systems. The only key is to escape the system...which is neigh impossible.
Honestly, if we take your theory and just assume humans have always been trash bags, but stood a chance for TGP because of some sort of debt reconciliation plan or grace period (like student loans) (also, ironically, we could theological call grace) - perhaps that ran out 500 or so years ago, and left it up to human to know better by now.