Idea for Red Dead Redemption 3

Discussion

I think it would be cool if the next Red Dead game took place during the Prohibition days so it could combine some of the horseback riding of Red Dead and the car driving of GTA. They could even use a lot of the same map as this one, except have some of the roads paved, and expanding and modernizing the cities. They could also add another major city in the north, something like Chicago. You could play as Jack, or even a new person who is part of Jack's gang of bootleggers and moonshiners, starting to feel the pinch of both the government and organized crime as they are forced to adapt or die. Your choices will matter, how well you play with the law and honorable you are might actually save you, whereas if you go rogue and gun everyone down, you'll face the wrath of both the government and the established urban gangs.

Just a thought for the plot, but I still think the setting would be awesome, driving around in old 1920's cars that you could customize, and / or horses when you are out in the country, using tommy guns and six-shooters. I would also just love to see St. Denis, Valentine, and Strawberry like twenty years after RDR2.

Posted Dec 30, 2018, 8:55 PM UTC

041
darthVkylo:john_marston: John Marston•

I hope they go waaay back not further forward

6
thoth1000OP•

How far back, and why?

1
darthVkylo:john_marston: John Marston•

Idk i just feel like cars would destroy everything. Maybe focus on old west instead of wild west. Somewhere near 1802?

0†
Kelpy_G_VEVO:arthur_morgan: Arthur Morgan•

W O A H T H E R E B O A H. I don’t think using flintlocks would be the most exciting red dead experience.

9
darthVkylo:john_marston: John Marston•

No but using mortar, sub machine guns, light machine guns and grenade launchers would make everything better? 😂 nah not for me fella

0†
thoth1000OP•

I don't believe there was really anything out there in 1802, and the gunplay would be awful as everything was muzzle-loaded.

2
darthVkylo:john_marston: John Marston•

That’s the key. Lol if u want magazine weapons, you are freely to play GTA.

0
L97vRt878gUbLg•

That’s actually a decent idea, and not too far off in the timeline to have some old characters in it. It’d be cool to see how the west developed.

4
FroggyNight•

Or just search google for Rdr3 prohibition. It comes up with 1920’s, chicago, cars, everything dude.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
wolfgeist•

Native American Tribe's fight for survival against the encroachment of Western white civilization is the best direction for the game to take. Tons of potential and in the appropriate setting.

0
apostolos0009•

I think it would be cool if we get to see jack participating in the world war or sonething

0
FroggyNight•

Ok I’m 99% sure you stole this post because ive seen the exact same “idea” a few times over.

-2
thoth1000OP•

You have? Can you show me where?

And just because someone else posted does that mean it's impossible for me to have thought of it independently of that person?

0
FroggyNight•
0
L97vRt878gUbLg•

That was 45 days ago...

1
FroggyNight•

That was just one post, there are tons with the same idea. This is nothing new.

1
thoth1000OP•

Oh, ok, someone had the idea a month ago on a post I've never seen, I guess that means nobody else can have the same idea and post it on Reddit. Sorry dude, would it make you feel better if I deleted this post?

0
FroggyNight•

Yup

1