Likely moving away from Ting, just wanted to share why
Hi there. Just wanted to say that we've enjoyed ting in the past but have gotten to the point where using it causes anxiety and headaches. While I understand the reasoning and the business model, it is also the reason we're currently shopping for alternatives for our 4 lines.
As it stands we always manage to just break into the next tier with each category each month, which causes undue anxiety and the feeling of waste. For example, going from the $18 minutes tier, to the $35 minute tier can be done with a single extra long phone call someone makes and all of a sudden, that phone call just cost me $17 dollars which is a real bummer when you just make the next tier. Same goes for data; oops this self loading video AD just cost you $6 this month...
This forces me to be the phone warden for my parents, spouse, sibling,etc, and is really tedious with constantly having to remind about usage.
Anyway, this seems to happen on all the tiers and what started as $40-$50 bills initially, our monthly bills are now in the $100-$120 range due to increased usage, which is more than unlimited plans for 4 lines from big name carriers while still having to constantly watch data and minute usage.
Some of this is obviously due to more usage but it would be easier to swallow if the tier system you guys have in place would just go away. The obvious suggestion would be to either carry over the unused portion of each pool to the next month, so that I don't feel like every month is a giant waste of resources, or alternatively why not prorate the portion of each pool, so that If i'm only 10% into the next pool, I only pay 10% of that pools sum of money, kind of like taxes work.
At any rate, like I said, I know it's part of the ting model but with increasing cell usage in general, i feel like that model is going to hold you guys back in the end. That's just our experience and wanted to share some feedback.
Posted Dec 30, 2018, 10:12 PM UTC
It's not uncommon to outgrow us. It happens every day as people's needs change. That's why we're happy that competition exists. We still save thousands money every month.
This is what caps and alerts are for. This is especially useful if you'd save more money only removing one person (typically the highest overall user) to a competitor.
If you're constantly hitting tiers that make it too expensive even after you're using all the tips in our guide, we actually actively encourage you to shop around for a better deal, and don't settle for just the cheapest carrier when you're looking around. Look at their customer service and coverage, as well as any extras they give you for your money.
Which is why we don't try to compete with unlimited plans. Anyone who constantly hits the high tiers is not the best fit.
We've discussed scrapping our entire business model before, even offering unlimited pilots. What we've learned so far is that unlimited plans are a losing proposition every time. Either our customers overpay for usage they could never use (unlimited is 44,640 minutes/month) and we pocket the difference, or they over-use and we pay our network providers for way more data than we collect from the customer.
Neither sounds like a great option for us to make money or continue to be a sustainable company, and we're in the market to make money and be sustainable. We want to be around in a few years when some of our competitors exit the market. It happens a lot.
Fun fact, Google Fi does this. And that's how we used to do it, too. What we found through trial and error is that it stressed people out more than the buckets system in place now. That is, people wouldn't feel comfortable going out and playing Pokemon Go because they know that each one they catch is an extra $0.10 on their bill, rather than knowing they already bought the bucket of data and use it freely with an alert or cap in place. They'd contact us asking if they could buy data for a lower rate in small buckets.
And we sincerely appreciate that. Please shop around, and don't settle. You are always welcome back at Ting, and with open arms. Please feel free to stick around r/Ting, as you're still eligible for our swag giveaways.
I'm not a customer any longer but this comment is exactly why I still always suggest Ting to everyone looking for a new carrier. Amazing customer service and communication.
I suppose it would be a lot to ask to offer the option for those of us who would prefer the Google Fi approach (rollover or pay at the prorated amount based on the cost per minute/text/mb in that bucket)? I know about the 5 percent buffer, but it just means that 5.01 percent overage just cost you a lot.
I don't disagree, but it's a cost averaging thing. If most months you wouldn't have hit the higher bucket, over time you do still save money. If you're consistently hitting those higher buckets to the point it drives your cost-per-line out of line with your expectation, that's when you should shop around.
Perfect example: I'm a Ting customer. I have two lines, one for me and one for my wife. Some months I spend a little more time playing Pokémon Go than I do in our home (I work from home so I spend a ton of time there already), especially in the warm months. During the winter months, our Ting bill is low because we're not out using it. In the summer, our bill rises slightly to reflect the fact that we're out doing things. Averaging out our bills over the year, I pay probably $60-$65 for the two of us per month, even if some months it's higher.
If I were regularly hitting the high bucket months, I'd probably transfer out the higher usage user (me, in this case) to a fixed-price carrier and leave her, a low-usage user with an iPhone, so free iMessages, on Ting and pay about the same or save a small amount.
Even Fi has breakage, though. It's hard to quantify the breakage on their $20 UT&T "base plan" without knowing their wholesale rates, but if they are anything like our wholesale rates, they rely pretty heavily on routing calls and texts through Google Voice (which they already encourage) to make sure that even those customers who pay them just for talk and text are still decidedly profitable.
So what I'm thinking is like if we used 600 mb, we look at the bucket that's in, which is 1 gb, or $16. About 1.56 cents per megabyte, or $9.38 for 600 megabytes (interestingly less than the cost of the 500 gb bucket, but I acknowledge there must be some overhead making the low usage more expensive per megabyte). Or if that doesn't work, let's come at it from another angle:
We filled the medium bucket for $10. The difference to large is $6 which buys 500 mb, 1.2 cents per megabyte over 500, so it's $1.20 for our extra 100 mb, a total of $11.20 instead of $16. If we hit that total every month, we save $4.80 every month.
Repeat for text and voice... Now if course all these savings eat into ting so they probably have to raise rates in return, at which point you do get into a catch 22 where the new "fair" rates are at least as expensive as the old buckets, or at least wind up being a worse deal if you routinely hit the high end of a bucket.
Still, any word on those rumored new data rates? I recall seeing something here a few months ago.
Lots (and really a huge chunk of the business we're in including our competitors) rests on the fate of the merger of our two network providers.