Hunter‐gatherers as models in public health - Pontzer - 2018 [research]
onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1111/obr....Posted Jan 1, 2019, 8:10 PM UTC
Posted Jan 1, 2019, 8:10 PM UTC
Given that our current state of civilization is dependent upon grains and resultant manufactured foods, has anyone given thought to what civilization would look like if it was built upon a healthy lifestyle as modeled by hunter-gatherer societies? Almost every aspect of modern society, from our jobs to our diet, is inimical to our health, except perhaps for shelter, clean water, sanitation, and certain anti-bacterial medicines.
We can't all be hunter-gatherers. We have physical needs, for food, shelter, and clothing, that transcend philosophical beliefs. For most of us, just the Paleo diet depends greatly upon the mass production of goods, which is antithetical to the model hunter-gatherer society. Consider your clothes. Your home. Your job. What is the ultimate reason for your labor? What is the end result?
As an exercise, subtract grains, and all their by-products, from the world. Without those grains, what does civilization look like? Is what we have today; our cities, our population levels, our very way of life, possible without incredibly cheap, transportable, and adaptable, grains (and the foods which spring from them)?
I'm not saying this to say that grains are our savior. Rather, the shift from grains is much more than a dietary choice. It shakes the very foundations upon which our civilization stands. Remove grains, and you have to redefine civilization.
Some animals (chickens for example) seem to tolerate grains well. Removing grains from that part of the food chain seems unnecessary. But yes, the overall point is a good one, and perhaps deserves a repost as a new topic. The loss of really cheap calories would be a pretty drastic change to the world.
So many interesting points from this study on ancestral living:
Ancestral fasting glucose may be much lower than western med considers normal?
Any macronutrient profile can be healthy with real food?
Low-intensity movement throughout the day critical?
Good summary! I personally think your last point is the key. Low to medium activity thru the day seems to be the modifier on which varying macros are independent of health.
Having said that, I think the excess, easily available amount of processed food contributes heavily to overconsumption of crap. So there’s that to combine with the activity deficit that might sum up the Western SAD causation of diseases of civilization.