someconstant•

Add violence related to alcohol and those numbers would skyrocket.

I love the stuff but it's such a problem.

152
AbShpongled•

Contrary to popular belief, alcohol is a harder drug than most illegal drugs.

103
hipposarebig•

Seriously. All the risk analysis I've seen have identified alcohol as being up there with heroin and crack in terms of danger. That sounds unbelievable to me, given the total normalization of alcohol overconsumption and decades of propaganda about the dangers of drugs, but it's hard to argue against given the statistics. Who knows how many hundreds of thousands of Canadian deaths can be at least partially attributed to alcohol abuse. If alcohol were invented today, there's zero doubt in my mind that it would be immediately, and justifiably, banned (not something I support at all, btw).

62
[deleted]•

[deleted]

20
hipposarebig•

Here's the thing: We don't all exist in a vacuum. Our decisions all effect each other in some way. Some decisions more than others, but it has an effect on others nonetheless. So the question is, if alcohol were invented today, would we be willing to accept the harm it presents to others?

The problem with alcohol is that it seems to be more harmful to other than any other drug (as discussed in the comment you replied to). For example, look at the economic impact: If people are drinking themselves to death at age 35, that's 20+ years of economic productivity that has been lost. We, as Canadians, invested significant money in the education and healthcare of this individual, and that all gets written off if they drink themselves to death. That hurt all Canadians. And if that individual had a family, that harms that family and society as a whole. Those kids will be growing up without a father or mother, which will harm their childhood development. And those children might be now be dependant on additional social services for their survival.

And even if that person didn't drink themselves to death, there are still broader societal implications from their alcohol abuse. Their alcohol abuse is certain to increase the severity of their health problems into old age, which costs taxpayers billions in medical bills.

Of course, the point at which something presents so much societal danger that it should be banned isn't clearly defined. But in the hypothetical situation where alcohol were invented today, I'd expect that any objective risk analysis would result in us banning it outright for personal consumption, as the broader societal impacts of alcohol would be deemed too great for alcohol consumption to be permitted. On the other hand, something like LSD would probably be legal, given that it's impact to others is quite literally orders of magnitude less significant than that of alcohol.

Now I'll emphasize again that I do not support alcohol prohibition in any form. I happily drink alcohol somewhat regularly, and it has played too great a role in human culture to even consider prohibition. I'm purely discussing the hypothetical situation where alcohol was newly invented today.

23
chapterpt•

I think any drug that can re-write your programming such that withdrawal could kill should be restricted - so alcohol, and prescription pills.

Heroin withdrawal feels like death, but if you stay hydrated and resting it's over when its over. That's why you can go under a medically induced coma to kick smack.

2
Hautamaki•

Well my wife and I didn’t think drug and alcohol abuse was a victimless crime when she was screaming and rolling on the floor of the emergency room with a bursting appendix and nobody could help her because the emergency room was already packed with addicts and alcoholics who had OD’d. If we agree that consenting adults should have the right to abuse whatever substance they want however they want because only they suffer the consequences then do we agree they see to their own medical needs and leave emergency rooms to people who just had bad luck rather than made bad decisions? I’d be fine with applying the same logic to smokers and the obese too for that matter. There are higher taxes on lots of these products that create extra unnecessary pressure on health care systems but there’s no way that a 400 lb food addict is going to pay for their lifetime healthcare needs with a cola tax, nor do cigarette and alcohol taxes cover cigarette and healthcare costs.

Which is not to say we’re doing it wrong as a society. I don’t think we are and I wouldn’t change a thing. All I’d change is the attitude that knowingly fucking up your body is your moral right because it doesn’t affect anyone else. It totally effects everyone else the second you show up a hospital for publicly paid for health care you need because you knowingly chose to fuck up your own body.

1†
AbShpongled•

Well said and heartily agreed.

9
Psychocrates•

My father is a psychologist who just retired from working at a prison. He said that the majority of violent crime involved alcohol and a lot of alcohol.

7
Fluuf_tail•

I'm not surprised, and yet the source of the problem is such a complex one.

0
yowzees•

Imagine putting it in pill form? No way people would legalize something that after a couple would make you black out.

2
GroundskeeperDilly•

You mean alcohol in pill form? Cuz it sorta already exists: benzos.

1
PensaiCanada•
0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Doumtabarnack•

Indeed, but I can't see it disappear anytime soon. It probably will disappear gradually for our children the way cigarettes consumption was dramatically reduced with our generation.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

11
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

4
hipposarebig•

There’s also the physical health impacts as well. Drinking just two glasses of wine a day will cause permanent physical health consequences. Binge drinking in any amount is incredibly destructive to the body, and can have immediate and long term health consequences.

2
[deleted]•

I've seen a lot of people die in the course of my career, particularly many addicts, and few have been more horrifying than those who succumbed to their alcoholism

I've also personally witnessed any number of people going through withdrawals and detox, and I have to tell you, alcohol is the very worst of any drug of choice

What's particularly tragic, and traumatizing, is meeting people in their late 30's and early 40's who are actively dying and who didn't even realize they had a problem...

Some of them are working professionals, regular otherwise functional people who drink a bottle of wine a night with and after dinner, maybe have a drink or two at lunch if the office goes out, and take their alprazolam every morning for their anxiety (unknowingly treating their withdrawal symptoms)

Next thing they know they're being told they have less than three months to live

6
AbShpongled•

This is why I always wince when people say "drugs and alcohol", it's like saying "drugs and cocaine"

9
[deleted]•

You'll even see the distinction being made in the medical literature or establishment, with addiction centres labeling themselves as being dedicated to 'drug and alcohol recovery'

4
gordonjames62Lest We Forget•

unless there distinction is alcohol (legal) and other drugs (mostly restricted)

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
diablo_man•

Quitting alcohol cold turkey is super dangerous. Its actually one of the only drugs that can kill you with withdrawal. Lots of drugs may make you miserable in withdrawal but wont kill you, alcohol absolutely can.

My Wife's grandpa (apparently a happy drunk) finally decided to listen to his wife that wanted him to quit, went cold turkey, died within the week in his sleep, massive heart attack in his early 40s.

6
[deleted]•

quit cold turkey without withdrawal or a sip or real craving since

That's quite the phenomena, you're very lucky you didn't die

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
Ultimafatum•

And car accidents.

5
doggo_rocket•

Ban assault liquor

2
SamsonFoxOntario•

I suspect that the codification used here already picks up violence related to alcohol, but I can't find an example that proves it 100%.

1

Alcohol is the cause of, and answer to, all of life's problems.

48
TheProfessaur•

Thanks Homer

2
phoenix25•

As a Canadian paramedic, frankly I'm SHOCKED.

​

​

/s

45
bitethebullit•

As a Canadian ED nurse. Me too!

16
SUNLIGHTBEARD•

A nurse specifically for erectile dysfunction? Boy golly what a time to be alive.

14
MrCanzine•

The days are long but the work's not too hard.

15

Soft and long like

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

3
bitethebullit•

Was being sarcastic if you didn’t catch that.

-4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
matdex•

As a med lab tech measuring the ETOH and Osmo, me three!

2
tabarjack•

As a Canadian cynic... well caffeine is consumed by everyone that gets cancer. Far worse than alcohol.

-2†

https://monographs.iarc.fr/agents-classified-by-the-iarc/

https://monographs.iarc.fr/wp-content/uploads/2018/09/ClassificationsAlphaOrder.pdf

The international association for research on Cancer would disagree with you.

Most meta-analysis also tend to lean to coffee/caffeine being not linked to cancer

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5036059/

2
gordonjames62Lest We Forget•

hey!

Don't be disparaging my drug of choice.

1
MoistIsANiceWord•

Alcohol is toxic in so many ways, and yet very few people seem to want to openly acknowledge all of its ill effects. The culture of drinking is so ingrained in our society, with soo soo many Canadians drinking well above the recommended weekly limit.

I've struggled for what seems like years now with alcohol addiction, and see how much drinking is a part of Canadian culture in general and how hard that makes it for those wanting to not drink/get sober.

42
ohThisUsername•

openly acknowledge all of its ill effects

I think everyone knows about the effects, but it is a matter of a simple cost/benefit analysis. For a majority of people, the entertainment value outweighs the effects on their health. Same reason for why people do anything risky (driving, skiing, skydiving). We all know there is some risk, but we determine that the benefit outweighs to health risk, so we participate.

​

The article is also a bit click bait-y. It mentions the majority of hospitalizations are caused by "mental health and addictions". I'm sure there are many, many, many hospitalizations related to mental health and addictions (irregardless of alcohol being involved).

​

​

​

​

​

7
gordonjames62Lest We Forget•

they did specify that these "were caused entirely by alcohol" to distinguish them from beatings, stab wounds or car accidents that have other factors involved

1
[deleted]•

If you don't drink regularly in Canada like every weekend minimum people look at you funny. It's actually hard to maintain friends because so many people drink, it ends up being the majority of what they want to do in their free time with friends.

1†
asad16•

It's actually hard to maintain friends because so many people drink

You're looking in the wrong places, my friend. There are plenty of people who don't drink, and they are awesome to hang out with. They are less common, that is true.

2
plop0British Columbia•

where do you live? :) i don't drink. nor does my boyfriend.

1
facelessbastardRussian Empire•

Lol... Saying Canadians drink a lot and ''alcohol is so ingrained''. Ever been abroad? Europe? East Europe? Check stats for alcohol consumption on other places and you see how we are ''in heaven here''.

0
asad16•

IMO I think North America has a very unhealthy view of alcohol. It's more of a binge culture, rather than a casual drink like most European countries. I also found people more accepting of me not drinking in Europe than here.

4
facelessbastardRussian Empire•

Agree lots. Last call and these alcohol restrictions are to blame partly.

1
MoistIsANiceWord•

Yes I've been abroad and in my experience, the attitude toward alcohol was a good balance in Israel. There is no stigma attached to drinking, but everyone I encountered chatted about how N. Americans and most Europeans binge like crazy and drink at seemingly any occasion.

In my experience drinking with folks in Israel, sharing drinks between friends and romantic partners was very common, and drinks were spread out among a longer span of time with a lot more water consumed during/between drinks.

The drinking until buzzed/drunk really wasn't common at get togethers the way it is so often in Canada. And advertisements for alcohol were so much fewer.

2
facelessbastardRussian Empire•

Interesting! I have no knowledge about Israel, so I take your word for it. As for Portuguese, Spanish, Italians.... Boy do we drink. :-$

1
reasonablemannOPLest We Forget:poppy:•

I was curious to look this up after seeing the article on cannabis induced psychosis.

  • cannabis hospitalizations: 723/365 ~= 2/day in 2018
  • alcohol hospitalizations: 212/day in 2016
38
bitethebullit•

ED nurse, I have noticed a massive increase in the amount of presentations to our ED related to marijuana use. Mostly related to edibles. I triaged like 10 in one night about 2 days ago. Start with a small amount first people!

21
LlammaPandaCat•

Yeah those are mostly panic attacks and not actually health risking

17
[deleted]•

Yup if you're not used to it you feel like everything is going to kill you and you become a nervous wreck for hours.

You gotta learn to handle that feeling. Still scary as fuck when it hits too hard, but I can throw on The Office or something on Netflix and just distract myself till I feel good again.

7
Scrappykoala•

That is exactly what I do, except Scots tots, that episode gives me major anxiety at the best if times.

7
LysergicideCanada•

Right, people take some 10mg THC edible with no tolerance and have no idea that it's a much more powerful high than smoking it. Plus it takes about an hour or more to kick in depending on your stomach contents and metabolism, so they take more and redose. There are also different effects whether it's an edible made from crystalline THC (clearer head high, can be more intense in large doses due to lack of counterbalancing Cannabinoids like CBD) or from carboxylating dry leaf to make cannabutter (more like the effects of smoking, just exaggerated).

Honestly, I think those hospitalization figures will gradually even out over time as persons get used to it. Responsible Cannabis usage won't happen immediately overnight, especially with new users. At least the OCS provides a little fact sheet warning people to take it slow and easy at first.

Also with smoking/vaping/eating too much the worst thing that'll happen typically is getting paranoid/anxious compared with alcohol which could actually kill you from overconsumption.

3
AsylumsixOntario :Ontario:•

people are stupid that's the problem! Nothing wrong with edibles but it's just something you have to work yourself into, start off with 10-20mg and just get a feel for it, then next time up your dose a bit.

People are starting with 100mg+ Thinking the high is going to be something like smoking a joint... No no no no no... Low doses may be similar but high doses have a completely different effect

2
bitethebullit•

10-20mg is even too much for me. All I need is around 2-5mg and I’m good for 3hrs.

1
ispice•

Did they survive? Are they still recuperating?

-3
Referat-•

They ded

3†
Outdoor_life•

As cannabis wasn’t legal. It was likely under reported. As people may have been worried about admitting to using it. With that said, I still doubt it is anywhere near alcohol.

18
faelun•

Doubt that would account for that large a difference, some difference for sure, but not such a large one.

3†
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
ispice•

Does this include the 175/day injuries from drunk driving?

Can you do one for deaths?

At least 4/day die from drunk driving.

4
banjosuicide•

Here's some government info. I'm too lazy to write a summary.

2
gordonjames62Lest We Forget•

Tl;DR summary

you are lazy

1
banjosuicide•

Yes

2
pedal2000•

Almost like one is much more widely consumed...

1
workThrowaway170•

10,600% more widely consumed? Because it has 10,600% of the hospitalizations.

3
pedal2000•

I mean, depending on our measurement possibly. If you go by ounce I wouldn't be surprised.

1
workThrowaway170•

But why on Earth would you go by weight?

2
redpandasuit•

lol, i went another way and looked up those articles from a few years back about owning cats and the spreading of toxoplasmosis in regards to the early onset of schizophrenia in Canadian children.

1
SamsonFoxOntario•

If you bother to read the actual report, then you'd notice that hospitalization for alcohol delirium are only 5% of the total, as stated on Page 9, which works out to about 11/day.

1
KetchupkittyAlberta•

Sugar puts more people in the hospital than any other substance in history, lets ban it.

30
price101Canada•

And humans have been consuming alcohol much longer than processed sugar.

5
Grindlife247•

Fine by me.

2
steheh•

This.

-1
alantrick•

I can't tell if you're being sarcastic or not...

-4†
KetchupkittyAlberta•

Don't think it should be banned but its seriously toxic to the body.

Obesity, Heart disease, Hypertension, Diabetes are epidemics in western society caused by a huge over consumption of carbs/sugar. These things were not issues for anyone but the richest of people hundreds of years ago.

11
NaturalDisplay•

Freakonomics recently did a podcast on sugar. One bit I found really interesting was one of their interviewees comparing the effects of sugar on the livers of children and being comparable to livers in alcoholics. If I remember it correctly, fructose can only be broken down in the liver so large doses of high-fructose sugar (ie corn syrup) overload the liver and lead to growth of fat on the liver.

5
KetchupkittyAlberta•

Body treats it as a toxin, no if ands or buts about it. I seriously feel a million times better since cutting out sugars, literally is saving my life.

2
EvasiveBeaver•

There might be a good case for banning it because it's much harder to avoid than alcohol, it's in almost everything. But I worry that what ever companies do to substitute for it might be worse.

3
hipposarebig•

But I worry that what ever companies do to substitute for it might be worse.

Companies have been substituting sugar with "fruit juice" for decades. Of course, concentrated fruit juice is almost entirely sugar, so it's as bad as pouring raw sugar in the drink itself.

I hate this because people are buying these fruit-based products thinking its good for their health, when it's basically as bad as eating whole spoonfuls of sugar.

6
KetchupkittyAlberta•

I've listened to some speeches of doctors actually comparing giving sugar to children being no different than giving them alcohol. Sounded absolutely crazy to me at first until I really looked into how terrible the sugar/carb (inflammation) and insulin (anti-inflammatory) response within the body was.

I'm not about to completely cut out sugar/carbs from my diet all together but I'm certainly never going to go back to a diet that consists mostly of carbs/sugar.

3
reasonablemannOPLest We Forget:poppy:•

I've often thought of a tax of a half cent per gram of sugar or corn syrup in refined foods. All proceeds going to healthy lunches for kids in school.

-1†
tmed88•

People are always trying to justify cannabis being terrible yet they indulge in alcohol which is far more dangerous. Hypocrisy at its finest.

Thank you for this article. I've recently tried edibles and I give a thumbs up to enjoying it safely.

18
mactronengOntario•

Alcohol is the poster boy of "unnecessary dangerous items nobody is willing to give up" and far outstrips any other legal thing that kills people.

16
diablo_man•

Its basically the giant elephant in the room every time someone trots out the "If it saves a single life, we should ban/do X" when talking about anything else.

I love a cold beer after work as anyone, but as many have pointed out, if alcohol was a recent discovery/invention, it would never stay legal here.

12
mactronengOntario•

I love a cold beer after work as anyone, but as many have pointed out, if alcohol was a recent discovery/invention, it would never stay legal here.

I like to think that it would be legal because we can use our heads and do a proper risk analysis (maybe combined with controlled access). We've lost too many things to the "save one life" nonsense.

8
diablo_man•

Well, I would hope so too, but I wouldn't bet on it. Many things with far less actual risk get banned or stay that way far longer than they should have.

The real trick is that the people saying "if it saves one life" are never talking about things that actually affect them personally. People are already used to casual drinking though, and when it affects them personally are far less susceptible to initiatives that punish the majority of responsible users for the actions of the minority that abuse it.

6
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
AbShpongled•

Don't forget all the other drugs less harmful than alcohol.

-1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
wolfegothmogQuébec•

I'll drink to that...

12
jasonbenj•

Who exactly is CIHI? I had to do some research to even find out who they were. This gentleman is in charge (http://www.kgh.on.ca/about-kgh/board-of-directors/david-otoole-chair) and it appears that they just issue a lot of somewhat sensational studies (https://duckduckgo.com/?q=cihi&t=ffnt&atb=v105-5_g&iar=news&ia=news) . Not saying this isn't correct, just wondering what the bias is

9
theottomaddox•

https://www.cihi.ca/en/about-cihi/governance-and-accountability/management-team

That's alot of directors, vice directors, managers, and officers. Or does everyone working these get a title?

3
midnightbikeriders•

They're funded mostly by Health Canada, to do data analysis about the health system. They're the ones who collect and publish all the reports that we read about in the news on surgery wait times, hospital readmission rates, healthcare spending, etc. etc. Their wiki page has some information. According to this news article, they have ~750 staff. They're one of the major players in the Canadian healthcare system.

1
hotelhotel99•

My sister died of liver failure caused by alcohol at 45. She had two months warning before her death. She went in for jaundice and the doctors said sorry there was nothing they could really do. No one had any idea. She was never seen falling down drunk.. never slurred her words. She was a stay at home mom who liked to open a bottle of wine at lunch. Have a few glasses and I guess finish a bottle every other day. Sadly the idea of an alcoholic isn't considered this. It's the guy on the street stumbling around.

5
cgk001•

And whats the population sample exposed to alcohol vs heart attack? Slice n dice the numbers and you get any story you want.

4
Hautamaki•

Totally anecdotal but I’ve taken family to the emergency room a couple times in the last year (burnt hands, burst appendix) and it sure seemed to be packed mainly with alcoholics and drug addicts ODing.

3
Maximillion666ian•

Its boggled my mind for decades now that the government can sell alcohol yet Cannabis was illegal for so long. I've seen the horrible abuse drinking does first hand growing up with an alcoholic. I was being taught "say no to drugs" as a kid in the 80's yet i could see the effects booze had on my family even at a young age. I would hear on the news as a kid of drunk driving deaths and violent crimes committed after drinking. Yet you could go any day to a liquor store and buy your poison. A poison that's been proven to be as unhealthy as hard drugs like heroin on the human body. Yet now at age 42 I still see NOTHING seriously being down about the issue.

3
originalnutta•

It doesnt even have to be a disease associated to alcohol, it could just be falls caused by alcohol or fights when drunk.

2
redpandasuit•

passing out and freezing to death in the cold is another common one.

1
spartasveryownCanada :Canada:•

Hopefully these numbers will go down with the advent of autonomous vehicles.

Losing someone to drunk driving is heart-breaking.

2
reasonablemannOPLest We Forget:poppy:•

Can't wait. The number of deaths from drunk drivers is just unbelievable.

3
gordonjames62Lest We Forget•

the article didn't count traffic accidents. I share your hope, but the article was about something else.

On average, 212 Canadians were hospitalized each day last year for conditions entirely caused by alcohol. This number does not include people who were treated in emergency departments (EDs) without being admitted to the hospital.

The majority of hospitalizations were linked to mental health and addictions.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
Teahaitchsee•

I work in healthcare.

​

I still remember the first person I met with hepatic encephalopathy. She was a young adult woman with toddlers at home. Lived in a very affluent area. No gangs/drugs/violence otherwise involved.

​

She wouldn't stop day drinking. Her liver failure was caused exclusively by drinking. She had no other co-morbidities other than drinking. She had a loving husband who would visit her and adorable children. She would get better medically while at the hospital and with no real reason to keep her she would go right back home and... continue drinking. She ended up being a frequent flyer, in and out of the hospital. It blew my mind that she had a charmed or near "perfect" life from the outside but was self-destructing on the inside. And there was no reasoning, no detox, no anything that could stop her behaviour.

2
chapterpt•

But cannabis is still worse than alcohol - as per all of my in-laws.

2
SamsonFoxOntario•

Keep in mind that this is a summary of a more comprehensive report

The breakdown is more interesting, as they seem to include inpatient visits to alcohol addiction clinics as hospitalizations, which is somewhat misleading. I added my comments

Table 1 Top conditions entirely caused by alcohol, Canada, 2015–2016

  • Chronic alcohol use disorder (24%)

  • Alcohol withdrawal (23%)

  • Harmful alcohol use (18%)

  • Alcohol-induced cirrhosis of liver (13%)

  • Alcohol intoxication (9%)

  • Alcohol-induced acute pancreatitis (6%)

  • Alcohol withdrawal delirium (5%)

  • Alcohol-induced hepatitis (4%)

  • Alcohol-induced hepatic failure (4%)

  • Toxic effects of alcohol (3%)

The table uses the codes defined here

2
[deleted]•

Raise taxes on it even more. I wont really notice it that much for the 2-4 times a year I have a few drinks.

So much tax money to these people who cant control themselves.

2